another chip that i didn't catch until it had been installed for a couple of days that the kd implied was my doing as it didn't look like it was a factory issue.
i have a matching divot on the bottom front of my super susan from a pot or pan(i am assuming)

I have the shrock (trademark) cabinets with the maple chocolate slab doors. I have only had them installed for about 4 months but I haven't had any issues yet. They installed perfectly with no damage to be seen. The finish is excellent and they are very solid (plywood construction) Drawer glides are soft closing and work very well. The only issue I had was the toe kick drawers I had installed are a little harder to glide. Stiff feeling. Not a huge issue though and they are loosening up over time and use.

We are a family of four (6 year old and 16 year old) avid cooks and make almost all of our meals from scratch. I have had friends with kids over several times to make cookies and such and the cabinets still look as good as they were first put in. Shocking considering when our youngest ones get together it is complete mayhem.

I would purchase these cabinets all over again though in retrospect I would not get a four drawer base just for size issues Wishing I would have gone with the three drawer. But if that is all I have to complain about then I will consider myself lucky. We will see how they hold up over the years though.

We've had Medallion gold quartersawn oak cabinets for a year, and love them. The finish is excellent, and the construction seems sturdy. The doors and drawers operate very smoothly. Our contractor was impressed with the quality of the cabinets, too. We had no issues in any area, and are very pleased.

Thank you all for your helpful feedback!

Ardcp thank you for posting your pics. I am considering the Medallion Silverline, so a bit concerning. I'm going to address the chipping/finish issue with my KD and see what they say.

We have had Schrock cabinets (Maple) for about 11 years now. I have had zero problems with them.

The finish on the doors still looks fantastic, even around the knobs.

I have over-loaded the pull-out cabinets with heavy casserole dishes and they have never buckled at all.

The only thing I do not like it that my drawers are somewhat shallow and sometimes things like flippers or spoons get stuck.

I do not have extended or soft close drawers so I can't speak to those.

That's all I can think to say about them and I wouldn't hesitate to get them again.

Just an FYI on advice from the KD; I asked my KD what the difference was between potters mill in gold and Lancaster silver ( same shaker veneer door) and she said nothing, no plywood upgrade, etc and it wasn't worth the $1500 extra. In hindsight, gold has better glides ( silverline has plastic attachments) and the people on GW that went gold had no issues whereas some silverline customers were posting issues. I had 3 boxes come in with chunks missing from the bottoms in addition to my other problems.
Plus my KD had 3 other medallion orders at the same time as mine and none had issues but they were gold level