SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
olpea

Not thrilled with the winter weather

olpea
9 years ago

Not complaining, just very very concerned. We've had one solid week of warm weather in Jan. and there is no forecast of colder weather in the coming week.

This is the kind of weather which teases buds out early, only to get frosted off. This could be the makings of a complete tree fruit crop loss for the Midwest and the South.

I know better than to think spring is coming early. Very likely more cold weather is coming. After all, this is about the midpoint of winter. Because the trees have de-hardened, an extreme cold spell could even kill winter tender trees.

Comments (31)

  • fruitnut Z7 4500ft SW TX
    9 years ago

    It's snowing here right now. Isn't that headed to KS in the next few days?

    We were 75 on the 19th and 20th. That's just typical west Texas weather. The difference is we won't be damaged by cold this winter. The last two yrs it's been a total freeze out of fruit in April/May. I'm still not sure if any of 80 trees planted Jan 2014 are still viable going forward after April 2014 freeze.

  • drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
    9 years ago

    We have 4 inches of snow and the temps are heading toward single digits. Well Friday and Saturday are warm, high is 38F Saturday, but starts to drop each day after that. By a week from Saturday the high is 13 and the low 3F. Currently at 12:35pm the temp is 28F.
    So the Midwest is fine, sorry to hear about your warm temps.

  • Related Discussions

    Winter Weather Advisory For NE OK & other states

    Q

    Comments (6)
    Well, then why in the world did they cancel a Winter Weather Advisory scheduled to last through 4 p.m.? Maybe computer gremlins ate it. I'd say I'm jealous of the snow y'all are receiving, but...hee hee...I am so NOT jealous. I've already had my fill of snow for this winter and doubt it is done with us yet. Glenda, I hope your son makes it safely in this weather. Mandy, I guess the kids are excited about the snow. Ick. I hate all the mess of wet boots and socks and gloves and coats, etc. Now I know why my mom was never as thrilled about the snow as we kids were on the rare occasions that Fort Worth received enough snow to cover the ground. Have y'all looked at your overnight low temps for the latter half of the week? Some marginally hardy plants may be in a world of hurt. Mulch, mulch, mulch! Dawn
    ...See More

    Tomatoes are green and winter weather coming

    Q

    Comments (10)
    Personally, I think the magic of the dish is that it's crunchy and fried, but the hot, tart, juicy tomato cuts through any greasiness and keeps the dish tasting fresh and delicious. More complicated recipes only do so much to improve the basic yumminess of the dish, IMO, but it's fun to try other variations, too, especially when you have a lot of green tomatoes to work through! The only caveat is to make sure you don't under-salt it. I usually taste the first bit to come out of the pan, and if it's bland, I make sure to sprinkle the slices with more salt while they're still piping hot out of the pan.
    ...See More

    Warm weather! - when to start winter sowing?

    Q

    Comments (2)
    pegleg, 6C so about 42F? That's cold enough for the moist chill for those seeds that need it, but not warm enough your other types seeds to sprout. I can think of a few seeds that will germinate while temperatures are in the 40's but after many weeks of moist at that temperature - so I think you are safe in beginning your sowing. I have a lot of days and nights here on the coast in the 40F range, it works just fine. Seeds will begin to germinate when the weather starts to warm up in a couple of months. If I had to count on snow, I'd never have a seedling ;) We had a little snowfall of a few hours on Jan 4, none again since and it was gone by afternoon.
    ...See More

    Crazy weather - first jugs of winter - native seeds - too late?

    Q

    Comments (6)
    Thank you ncrescue! That is good to know. I am so used to putting my natives out in December and having them freeze & thaw in their jugs for months and months. I forgot that some people use the fridge to stratify. That's a good point. Whew. I put out my jugs with Foxglove Beardtongue and Bradbury's Monarda this evening, in the middle of the Nor'easter, so that was either true winter sowing dedication, or sheer insanity on my part, lol. Glad to know they will likely still sprout even though it's January and has been a warm (ish) winter. Thanks again!
    ...See More
  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    "It's snowing here right now. Isn't that headed to KS in the next few days?"

    I wish. The NWS has 50+ degree weather for pretty much all of the next week. Given what we've had in the last week, it's too warm for Jan. weather here.

    "So the Midwest is fine, sorry to hear about your warm temps."

    That's funny Drew :-) Around here we think of MI not part of the Midwest, but the far north!

    You do have it made though, being close to the Great Lakes to moderate spring frosts, which offers lots of protection. There is a reason that region is called the fruit belt.

  • drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
    9 years ago

    That's funny Drew :-) Around here we think of MI not part of the Midwest, but the far north!

    I know it's not very accurate we should just be the north! MN and WI too are rather northish. MI goes farther south.
    I'm tucked away in the Southeast bottom corner. Canada is actually south of us! Well some of it. Detroit is south from here, and south of Detroit is Windsor. A little section of Canada, often neglected by Canada too. I consider it part of Detroit, more than part of Canada. It's not, but it's right there across the Detroit river.
    Yeah Windsor on a little pennisula south of Detroit.
    The Great Lakes froze early, but then it got warm and they melted. Frozen now, so that helps keep it consistant. And as you say protects the region.
    http://mapq.st/1zzWqRa

    So what kind of temps are you have there? Above 45F?

  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    "So what kind of temps are you have there? Above 45F?"

    In the 50s or 60s for the last week.

    Cooler today. Tomorrow 47F, Sat. 54F, Sun. 57F, Mon. 49F, Tues. 58F, Wed. 53F.

    Keep in mind the ave. high temps here in Jan. are generally 40F.

  • derby41
    9 years ago

    I thought the same thing olpea. It has been really warm here in southwest missouri. I dug up two nanking cherry seedlings 4 days ago, potted them,and brought them indoors. They already have green leaves poking out the end of the buds. It got so cold here last winter that my peaches didn't have one single bloom on them. I am really hoping for some fruit this summer

  • brookw_gw
    9 years ago

    I was concerned as well when we were in the low 50's last weekend. Blueberries are showing signs of awakening as are the currants and gooseberries, and it looked like some of the peach buds were swelling just slightly. However, lows all week have been in the 20's, and daytime temps in 30's. I was also elated that the blackberries looked unharmed after some near zero temps. Our temps next week are even lower.

  • drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
    9 years ago

    Olpea,

    Yeah that is high we have not been past 40F since September. Temp is still 28F here, and is going to drop soon with nightfall. Lows next week look scary here, near zero. 10 days ago it was -4F Hope that remains the coldest temp this year! Lows are around 3F next week here.
    Yeah I would be concerned that is just way too warm!
    I would ask all our Canadian friends to point the fans south! Southwest please, plenty cold here!

  • don555
    9 years ago

    The western warmth is making its way pretty far north now. Sunny and 50F here today, in the prairies 500 km (300 miles) north of the US border. Five more days of 40-45F in the forecast, then cooling. Average high this time of year is 18 F.

    Don't think it will be enough to break dormancy around here. I'll just call it a nice January thaw.

  • derby41
    9 years ago

    I thought the same thing olpea. It has been really warm here in southwest missouri. I dug up two nanking cherry seedlings 4 days ago, potted them,and brought them indoors. They already have green leaves poking out the end of the buds. It got so cold here last winter that my peaches didn't have one single bloom on them. I am really hoping for some fruit this summer

  • Michael
    9 years ago

    Greetings from a way too warm north central part of the state Olpea. I hear you loud and clear. Recently, I looked through the high and low temp data from the NWS observation station here very close to town. The readings go back 15 years and showed that these temps in the mid 40-50 degree range we've been having for going on weeks now are way out of the norm. I too am concerned for my trees and all trees in the area for that matter. Did you ever figure out how to use The NWS NowData on the web for your area? E-mail the town nearest to you and I might be able to get our local NWS observer to tell me which specific station is closest to you. If nothing else, you can get kind of close just to see how far off the normal temps have been in your general vicinity though not the temps for your specific location.

  • alan haigh
    9 years ago

    The peaches shouldn't be vulnerable yet- probably haven't reached their chill requirement. It's Feb. warm spells that are more killer (dormancy breaks more easily then) and your temps aren't too warm. If things return to "normal" in a week I bet you'll be fine.

  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    I got your link Michael in the email you sent. It's such a good link to past information, I'm posting it below.

    Anyone can use the link. To find a location, click on climate locations tab and use the arrows. I had to use the arrows a couple times to get over to the Kansas City data.

    Once you have the location you want, the "Observed Weather" and "Local Data/Records" will give all kinds of past data for the area.

    In my area, the average highs for Jan. are 38F and the average lows are 20F. Been a lot warmer than that for this
    year.

    Hman,
    It does look like there is some cooler weather on the horizon. Perhaps spring weather will be the real question, as it generally is.

    Here is a link that might be useful: NWS data

  • Michael
    9 years ago

    I've looked back into the high temps since the cold spell ended and this warm snap began. We have had a few high 40s but that's it, mostly it's been low 40s which is normal, I'm not to worried now about the high temps, just more danged drought. The wettest / snowiest times are ahead though, February - April so there is hope still.

  • jagchaser
    9 years ago

    Im not excited about it at all. I actually had the frost go out on a couple mud holes in the yard already.

    I remember last year in mid jan we had 60 and 3-4 days later I was -15f or so. It did it again in feb to -12 I think. If we can gradually cool back down without a cold snap I think it will help.

  • clarkinks
    9 years ago

    Olpea,
    I am concerned as well but farming in Kansas is always like this. When I was still planting row crops I would invest thousands and sweat every time it hailed, rained, dried up, wind blew etc.. Farming in Kansas is for gamblers if we were not risk takers we would not last the first year. I wish for a nice apple/peach/pear crop but my blackberries are my crop that's never failed me the last 20 years. The blackberries have been in the family at least a hundred years as I got my plants from my Grandpa. They bloom in late May or June and ripen July 15 - August 15. I hope this year treats you well Olpea!

  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    Clark,

    You're right, farming is a gamble.

    I'm over on the extreme eastern part of the state, which is really more like the MO climate.

    Someone once told me the KSU extension claimed peaches completely fail once out of every ten years in KS.

    For central MO, supposedly peaches only have a full crop 4 out of every ten years, a partial crop 3 out of 10, and a complete crop loss 3 out of 10.

    I looked at some of the historical winter weather data in the link in my last post.

    You might be interested to know that in the last 125 years, there have been roughly 5 events which would have killed peach trees in KS (I defined any winter temps below -17F as a year which would have killed peach trees, even though there is of course some variability of how much cold peaches can tolerate and still survive.) On average a peach orchard will be killed by cold about every 25 years.

    In terms of crop failure, I looked at years were temps dropped below -13F. There were about 25 years, out of 125, in which temps were below -13F, or one out of five years.

    I know a grower on the KS side who has been raising peaches commercially for 14 years. He's had two complete crop losses in that time (one failure from spring frost, and one from winter cold).

    Apples of course are much more reliable.

    This year I signed up for crop insurance. It doesn't pay very well for a crop disaster, but it's better than nothing, and the premiums aren't too bad.

  • jagchaser
    9 years ago

    If I asked for crop insurance out here on fruit trees they would probably look at me like I had 3 eyes! Im positive it would be the first time they heard of it here. I wont because I don't have near the orchard you have and Im not dependent on it for income. Interesting idea though. How do they figure the compensation on a loss? Im familiar with how they do wheat or corn, but have no idea about fruits.

    I talked with the UNL fruit specialist one time and he though SW to SC Nebraska should be ideal for tart cherry production, and he had been trying to talk someone into doing a commercial sized orchard 10 ac or more. I didn't think about crop insurance, but it may make the difference and make that a possibility. Now you have me thinking!

  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    Jag,

    The crop insurance is through the USDA (your local FSA office).

    The last farm bill (2014) upgraded the crop insurance for tree crops. Because of that, they extended the deadline to sign up, but the deadline has passed for this year 2015.

    The new crop insurance lets you "buy up" coverage, up to 65% of expected yield and up to 100% of market price. Keep in mind their "market price" is wholesale (read cheap) not retail. Also their "expected yield" is very low (like 130 bu/acre).

    Still the insurance is something. I posted a link to the fact sheet below.

    Keep in mind orcharding in the Midwest is a tough business. I started my full time orchard 4 years ago, invested tons of money and time without any return. For the money my wife and I have invested in the orchard, we would have done better just to have left it in the stock market, and that wouldn't have been any work! Then there's the opportunity cost of the work I could have done and gotten paid for.

    I do hope at some point to make some money back, but the real reason I do it is because I love it. The air, the sunshine, the joy of producing delicious and nutritious food (not only for myself, but for others). That's why I started and hope to be able to continue.

    Here is a link that might be useful: NAP program

  • clarkinks
    9 years ago

    Olpea,
    On this site I've grown reliance peaches for nearly twenty years. I lose about 40% of my crops due to frosts in the spring and twice to cold winters. I have 4 of the trees currently. I removed a couple that got in the way of a pond I built. I really only have experience with reliance for that long. One of my original trees is still alive and produces well. I started growing other varieties about 5 years ago so they are still not tested 100% yet. I had limbs broke out due to wind damage last year and I lost 80% of my crop to the cold winter. My other fruit produced better than ever. Most all of my peaches came from one reliance peach tree that is grown beside the others. I'm at a loss as to what the difference was.

  • jagchaser
    9 years ago

    Very interesting. Im sure if I had a bunch of losses that they would adjust the farm average down the same as they would do with grain crops.

    Lots of things that wouldn't work the same as grain. I can see issues with how they prove your actual yields.

  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    If you have a production history, you can keep track of your yields, or you can have a farm survey, or you can accept FSA numbers.

    I have a friend who uses a farm survey for his peaches. He pays for someone (an FSA rep) who comes out and estimates the yield every year. He has to pay mileage and some other fees. He said it amounts to a couple hundred dollars for the farm visit, but easier than doing all the recording.

    Clark,

    Although I don't have Reliance anymore, I do like the idea of hardier peaches. Because of last winter, I'm going to try to plant more hardy varieties, as long as they taste good.

  • franktank232
    9 years ago

    This covers the first week of Feb. The signal has been very strong of cold air returning in that time frame.

    {{gwi:2118366}}

  • ericwi
    9 years ago

    It has been unseasonably warm here in Madison, Wisconsin, as well. Daytime highs are around 35 to 40 degrees F. However, it freezes at night, so the lakes stay frozen. We have very little snow cover, about an inch or two. It has not been a good year for XC skiing, or local snowmobiling. Our blueberry shrubs remain dormant, and if we get some cold weather in February, they should do fine. I have yet to fire up the snowblower, all the shoveling has been done by hand.

  • Michael
    9 years ago

    Howdy OLPEA, Jag sent me this, you might remember 2012, perhaps we're off to another one of those years.

    Here is a link that might be useful: 2012 heat

  • drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
    9 years ago

    It's like I'm on another world. It has been cold here and now a week from today the low is -5. I'm freezing here! Starting again to worry about fruit buds and blackberry canes making it. Hopefully the predictions will change I don't like the negative numbers!

  • olpea
    Original Author
    9 years ago

    "you might remember 2012, perhaps we're off to another one of those years."

    I hope not Michael. That was a year not easily forgotten. Not only was it very hot, it was also windy and it never rained all summer, until late Aug. I remember when you stepped outside it was like standing in front of a blow dryer.

    Supposed to be 63F here Wed. The record for this area on that day is 65F.

    This post was edited by olpea on Sun, Jan 25, 15 at 10:44

  • clarkinks
    9 years ago

    I'm really starting to get worried we will be at 70 degrees Fahrenheit tommorow and 60's for several more days. We are getting high winds today and got a light rain last night. My trees are going to think its spring. Before long I may think its spring. Drew if you need a vacation Kansas might be the place for a warm non crowded getaway this year.

  • alan haigh
    9 years ago

    I looked up the weather in Topeka KS (I lived there when very young) and you folks have nothing to worry about yet if accuweather has it anywhere close to right.

    First of all, until the chill requirements are met dormancy is pretty much stable and susceptibility to weather induced budding is gradual . Secondly, I don't see a pattern of sustained warmth nearly adequate to set off early budding based on my experience here.

    The last time we had first growth in March here it was set up by an entire week of temps in the '70's during the day and low '60's or high '50s at night- basically warm spring weather. It created the earliest spring in memory, but somehow we avoided lethal frosts. A few years later with a warm spell a bit later we weren't so lucky.

    Short bursts of warm weather are a normal condition in our winters here- often enough to create a full thaw, but in 25 years watching we've never had spring in Jan or Feb. I believe that solid weeks of very warm temps in that period must have occurred several times.

    In March you can begin the high anxiety mind set of a hen mother. There will be plenty of time for that. Extreme cold is all you generally need to worry about in mid-winter in your zone, I think.

  • drew51 SE MI Z5b/6a
    9 years ago

    I guess so Clark! Well maybe you should come here! Not now in the summer. You guys can come up to th island for a week or weekend. It's a little frosty right now on the swimming dock!

  • clarkinks
    9 years ago

    Sounds great Drew! Looks like it would be a great spot in the summer.