What is happening to my cacti? Mutant growth

19 years ago

Hey everyone, I recently bought this Cacti ('Echinocereus subinermis') from Gardenworld in Melbourne. It has started to develop this weird 'growth' on the side that looks nothing like the original cacti. Is this normal and just the cacti branching out, or is it an anomaly due to grafting (even though I didn't believe this cacti was grafted). I am confused because the tag said it was a clumping plant.

Picture below.

Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:2111535}}

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

dendroleon
19 years ago
My FIRST POST to this Forum.

The "weird growth" looks like one of the flower buds on my Echinocereus pentalophus. You should have a nice large yellow flower in a week or so!

According to Anderson in "The Cactus Family" (2001) the subspecies 'inermis' is often spineless and often remains solitary while the subspecies 'ochoterenae' is normally spiney and branches.

Your plant is definitely not grafted.

Best wishes,

Mick.
dendroleon
19 years ago
My Echinicereus subinermis (label lost) from Collectors Corner two years ago now has two flower buds on it. They look just like the mysterious growth on your plant, which I imagine has turned into a flower by now.

Why don't you post a response to the Forum telling what has happened? Other members may be interested, and without follow-ups Forums die!

Regards, Mick.
Related Discussions
Mutant Calendula :0 What's happened?
Q
Comments (2)
It's like plant tumors! have seen this with my older Rhodedendron bush -- I mean it's like 65 years or more old. it has one basket ball sized crazy round clump/ ball of crazy out of control clumping flowers on flowers -- the general appearance is a tumor/ abnormal growth. the rest of the old thing is sparsely covered with half hearted normal blooms when it does bloom. The crazy one reappears every year.
...See More
What happens when my plants freeze/are frosted on: my exp
Q
Comments (5)
I hear you suze9. I live in The Great PNW. About 20 miles S from Seattle. Zone 7b I guess. Where is live is about 2 weeks behind Seattle weather wise. Normal Feb temps are 40-45, night time 35ish. The drop to 18 is somewhat unusual, even in Dec, Jan. It's been an unusual year, again. Snow in Feb is rare. March, almost unheard of. This year the ?last? snow was beginning of April. Today was 75. > Larger transplants can work well for some, for sure - > but at some point it is definitely possible to start > too soon, to the point that you don't get any benefit, > or are even set back because of it. I am trying to find that point. Expense versus effort versus results weighted. This is my third year running of 'starting way too early'. This year was the earliest yet. Last year I had my first ripe tom June 6th. That's a pretty major feat around here. 'Course the weather from June through July sucked, very cold, so the benefits were minimal. LOL. Plants were HUGE, 10-15'tall by end of season, tomato count, ENORMOUS. Ripe tomatoes, not so much. My starts are not normal put in a 1 gallon pot and let them grow starts. I continually 'repot' them into larger and larger containers. I bury the stem deeper each time. They are essentially pre-trenched plants. 1' of stem or more buried by planting time with vigorous root growth all along it. Lat year the tops are 2-3' tall. The plants suffer no delay/transplant shock when put into the ground from pots. Critical for the short season here. Growing an inch a day, to growing an inch a day right after transplant. This year, I am making cloches so my efforts are not lost to the AGAIN expected cold june/july. And by starting so soon, if things go wrong, I have time for Plan B and Plan C starts.
...See More
Persimmon Tree growth suddenly stopped. What happened??
Q
Comments (8)
Some with experience dealing with this problem have recommended not planting persimmons at or adjacent to the sites where afflicted trees had grown. This recommendation is based on the observation that afflicted trees in a number of plantings have occurred in a somewhat grouped pattern (rather than randomly throughout the planting) lending the idea that the disease process is contagious. But there are other reasons why the grouping may occur, and as the disease etiology remains unknown, this recommendation is really just informed speculation, and so it wouldn't be totally unreasonable to try another kaki at the site of your afflicted tree. There is some literature showing that certain varieties of kaki are less likely to develop KSD than others, and they parallel those varieties that have been shown to be most cold-hardy. The idea is that KSD often appears after a winter when the trees were stressed and the cold hardy varieties are thought to be less susceptible to cold induced stress. Great Wall and Smith's Best come to mind as varieties thought to be relatively resistant to KSD. My own experience has been that the rootstock has been more determinant than the variety in the development of KSD. For your purposes that would translate to choice of nursery, and I have found that persimmons from Edible Landscaping and Just Fruit and Exotics have not had any KSD for me after 15 years of observation. Another option is to purchase kakis on lotus rootstock, which do not develop KSD and are available from some of the west coast mail order nurseries. Problem here though is that kakis on lotus may not perform very well in the East and are less cold hardy than the virginiana rootstock to which your tree is likely grafted.
...See More
What happens in Fall root growth
Q
Comments (4)
Hug, my comments were generalized, not specific to any one tree type. And yes, I'm near-certain that species would vary to at least some degree. Cats and dogs both have four legs, one nose, two ears, etc.....but the veterinarian that therefor decided they could be treated exactly alike would soon need another line of work. So it is too with trees I suspect. The feeder roots are simply not permanent structures, growing, expanding, then dying all through the growing season. The structures embo speaks of above are the more permanent parts of the root system, not these very fine roots with fungi embedded within and without. And too, once one dips their toes into the world of mycorrhizae, things become bewilderingly complex in a hurry. Helper bacteria that set the stage for fungal symbionts, trees releasing messenger chemicals into the rhizosphere to "call" out to various fungal partners.....it is anything but simple. Incidentally, we often lament this lack of "feeder roots" on stock we may receive, but it probably matters a great deal less than we may have been thinking, again due to the less than permanent nature of these structures. The tree can make more! One thing's for sure-if you want to see lots of these very fine roots-what we've been calling feeder roots-withhold nitrogen fertilizer. Nothing shuts this whole process down faster than fertilization. We bury bare-root trees upon receipt in a mixture of old wood chips and a bit of incidental soil. It is nothing less than amazing to see the amount of fine root regeneration these plants create in this very low-N situation.
...See More
dancacti
Original Author
19 years ago
It's a bit of a sad story really. I was so excited after reading that the 'mutant growth' was a flower, I picked it up and showed my girlfriend. (I don't think she was overly impressed.) Anyway, I then put the plant out on a table outside where it would get plenty of sun, and as soon as I put it down, the stalk fell off! I wasn't very happy, but I guess you can't cry over spilt milk... My feeling was that whilst the stalk looked perfectly healthy, maybe the cactus was getting too much water, causing the flower stalk to rot.

There's a few other furry growths on other parts of the cacti, but they haven't progressed to the stage of another stalk yet. Oh well, maybe next year.
Rosiefuture
19 years ago
You often find that with cacti that aren't prepared to support a flower into blooming. Often a cacti will produced quite a few buds but some of them won't develope and they will drop off. My epiphyllums produce numerous buds but only the number that the plant can support will go on to flower, and of those that flower maybe half will produce fruit.

Marion - Rockingham
Joylene
19 years ago
I would reccomend potting your Echinocereus into some fresh mix. Echinocereus grow well with moisture, heat and food through the summer months. The scoria type stuff it is in can't support it for very long. Joylene.
dancacti
Original Author
19 years ago
Hi Joylene, thanks for that. I think I'll give it a go.
It hasn't tried to flower again, which is a shame.
thefof Zone 8/9 UK
19 years ago
Hi Dancacti

Just so that you can show your girlfriend, what she missed, here are a couple of pics of mine, taken this summer in the outdoor bed.
{{gwi:2111536}}
{{gwi:2111537}}

LOL

Fof

What is happening to my cacti? Mutant growth

Comments (7)

dendroleon

dendroleon

Related Discussions

dancacti
Original Author

Rosiefuture

Joylene

dancacti
Original Author

thefof Zone 8/9 UK

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

What is happening to my cacti? Mutant growth

Comments (7)

dendroleon

dendroleon

Related Discussions

dancactiOriginal Author

Rosiefuture

Joylene

dancactiOriginal Author

thefof Zone 8/9 UK

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

dancacti
Original Author

dancacti
Original Author