I know it all comes down to personal preference but I want to get an idea what most people would go with. Please dont suggest we change our mind about going with an island as we're already decided we will get it. Just want to see what other's would choose.
Option #1 Island 3 ft. including overhang with 34 inches of space around the island
Option #2 Island 2.5 ft. including overhang with 37 inches of space around the island
Option #3 Keep 3ft island but move it more towards the breakfast area. If aesthetically this looks good, we would actually prefer this as we dont want a breakfast table.
Here is our revised kitchen plan: