I just had my cabinets custom made by a West Hartford cabinet maker. He was great to work with and put up with me and all my indecision. The quality of his cabinets is excellent. Everyone, the GC, fabricator, plumber, electrician, are all impressed with the quality. I found him to be very reasonably priced. I'd be happy to share that info with you...I just hope nobody thinks I'm advertising? His name is Bill Petrunti of Petrunti Designs and Woodworking.

Richard Sanca did a wonderful huge built-in bookcase for us and I've recommended him on this forum before. A true craftsman with reasonable prices. I'm linking his website below. If you'd like pics or further info on the work he did for me, please feel free to PM me. Here is a link that might be useful: Richard Sanca website

I am not sure why you want an "Amish" cabinet maker. We are just starting our kitchen renovation that we have been planning since 2008. My husband works with a man who does custom cabinets with his brother who is retired. He is fair, honest, consciencious, works very quickly and I could go on, but you get the idea. We just contracted with him to do our custom kitchen. His prices are more than fair, he just finished his son's kitchen. He does very nice work and his cabinets are very high quality. We are going with mahogany cabinets. I think you might be within his reach location wise. He lives in Green Springs, which is several miles from Fremont, Ohio. His name is Todd Neirman(sp) and his cell phone number is 419-307-3673. He took us around and showed us other cabinets he has made. Good Luck.

Traciel - I was in the processes of looking at cabinets on Long Island and the prices I was quoted, without any bells and whistles, was insane. Also, I wanted a medium toned wood stain that did not have orange undertones. I only saw this stain on very high end lines. Lastly, I wanted an old world look with inset style cabinetry, which was another significant price up charge at most places. We planned a family trip to Lancaster for a holiday weekend and I Planned to visit Amish cabinet makers. I researched garden web and someone had mentioned Blue Mountain woodwok in Bath, PA. We stopped there and we were impressed with their quality and range of available stains. They offered inset style for a fair upcharge. OVer the next few months, I worked closely with their kitchen designer Patti through blue print changes and my preferences. I was very happy with Blue Mountain. i recommend you check them out if you are in that area or even make a special trip. Good luck. http://www.bluemtnwood.com/home-1/