skip to main content

wood countertops in kitchen: Bally Block: Good Stuff

hellothererobby

15 years ago

Hi, I am putting in wood countertops in my kitchen throughout the kitchen. Does anyone have experience with the Bally Block butcher block countertops? They use a product called Good Stuff and Durakryl 102.

I want something easy to maintain and stain and water resistant, etc. I also found this other company Craft Arts that says their product is heat resistant and water resistant. THey use waterlox. Their product is a lot more expensive. Any Bally Block, Good Stuff users? I would love to hear if you are still happy with your countertops and how the protective sealers are working? ALso, any experience with Craft Arts and waterlox and how that might compare, THanks! Robby

Comments (7)

tetrazzini
15 years ago
I've applied Good Stuff to furniture pieces at work, and my boss thinks it's a good product. I haven't used it in my kitchen tho. Will you use it around the sink? If not, I don't think water resistance is a major issue.

I can vouch for the quality of Bally tho. We've had a Bally "island bar", which has a hard maple edge-grain top, for 20 years. We used the oil product they gave us for a couple of years, but then stopped and haven't used anything on it since. The hard maple doesn't show any signs of damage, water or otherwise. The quality of the piece is very good. We've been 100% NOT careful with it, tho I've never used knives directly on it. It doesn't look pristine, but it looks pretty darn good. I know that it would be restored to new by sanding it. Stains, like from grape juice, just seem to fade after a couple of days, and this is using no finish product. I'm planning to use Bally butcher block counters when we remodel.
kmgard
15 years ago
I'm sorry I can't help answer your question, but I would really like to have wood countertops in my kitchen as well. A guy who did an estimate for our cabinets told us that butcher block counters would cost almost the same as granite. Would you mind telling me if you've found this to be true?

Thanks!
Related Discussions
would porcelain tile that looks like wood make a good countertop
Q
Comments (12)
A real wood butcher block top would look a LOT better. It's not only the grout lines, although that's a biggie. It would just look, well, "college dorm apartment", without the inexpensiveness of it. You can be creative on a budget, but sometimes thinking outside the box needs to stay outside the box if you want a certain look. If you're doing the tiling, it might end up being as expensive as a nice Boos butcher block. (A lot more than Ikea) If you have to pay to have it tiled, granite slab would be cheaper. You could even do a simple stained plywood top with real wood edging for a fraction of the tile and have a nice looking counter until your budget recovered to get the one you really want.
...See More
Pics of kitchens w/ butcher block and marble countertops?
Q
Comments (6)
Here's my kitchen with all three! I love all three. I am glad though that I have the soapstone on the perimeter with the sink and stove because it's so impervious to anything. I also love my marble but I do NOT baby it in any way. It is honed and un-sealed -- however, I don't care if eventually it gets stained, etched etc (although 4 months later it's still unstained). But I would guess if it was right next to the stove where I'm super messy and lazy to cleanup, that might not be the case. The butcher block is really not in a high food prep area so I can't really say how it takes abuse, but there is an ever so slight crack under our coffee pot I'm assuming from the heat/steam. Here is a link that might be useful: My kitchen with Marble, BB, and Soapstone
...See More
Getting walnut BB! Any experience with the Good stuff?
Q
Comments (3)
I don't know about walnut BB, but I do have wood boards and was always told only use mineral oil on them. If you are using it for food, you don't want to put anything on the wood that is non-digestable as it will chip or wear off in small quantities and end up in your food.
...See More
Waterlox, Good Stuff or Tung Oil
Q
Comments (53)
I just installed a maple countertop. After much research I went with the Good Stuff - I did three coats. Less than two months later the finish is mostly gone - I need to finish it with something that will last longer. Is Waterlox a good choice? I presume all I need to do is sand the counter to make sure all the Good Stuff is gone and then apply the Waterlox sealer using a brush. Any advice?
...See More
kompy
15 years ago
I've found butcherblock slabs to be MUCH less than granite. Now, the problem is getting someone to take the slabs and fabricate them to fit your kitchen. The labor part is probably what takes the cost up on the BB. But I would still think it'd be less.
stw954
15 years ago
You might want to look into Devos (out of Texas) and Brooks Custom (somewhere in the northeast). They are still expensive but significantly less than Crafts Art. And they all use Waterlox (though Brooks tries to obscure that).
tetrazzini
15 years ago
hellothererobby, I have to apologize: Our island was made by Boos Brothers, not Bally! My brains's been on the fritz lately. Can't tell you anything about Bally's quality, sorry!

kmgard, people here have gotten edge grain countertops from IKEA for a very low price, tho they're not maple, and they're thinner than the typical ones. But they look good.
hellothererobby
Original Author
15 years ago
Hi thanks for the feedback! now we are considering using craft art wood countertops. anyone have any experience with those? they say u can use any kind of sink with it and they are heat resistant. does anyone have it/seen it? how has it held up with water, stains, heat, etc. thanks for any feedback;\
also, anyone have experience with Brooks Custom or Devos?
thanks again. Robby
allison0704
15 years ago
I ordered my can of Good Stuff from them for our antique pine island countertop. Great stuff! Have been very pleased - 3 years in new house. Our sink is in the island. We are good about wiping up splashes but don't ever wipe the "cut ends" at the sink. Pictures below; scroll down to French Gray Island Kitchen. You can click on them to enlarge.

Here is a link that might be useful: My Kitchen

Sign Up to Comment

Related Stories

WOODWORKING How to Clean and Care for Your Butcher Block

By R. Olson Design

Keep butcher block counters and boards looking sharp as a knife — and sanitized for safe food prep — with this advice from a pro woodworker

KITCHEN DESIGN Butcher Block Makes the Cut for Holiday Kitchen Prep

Countertops and cutting boards will likely take a beating over the holidays. These butcher blocks have the chops to perform under pressure

KITCHEN DESIGN Wonderful Wood Countertops for Kitchen and Bath

By Pangaea Interior Design, Portland, OR

Yes, you can enjoy beautifully warm wood counters near water sans worry (almost), with the right type of wood and sealer

KITCHEN DESIGN Cool Countertops: Wood and Stainless

Consider One of These Alternatives to What All the Neighbors Have

WHITE KITCHENS 4 Dreamy White-and-Wood Kitchens to Learn From

By Mitchell Parker

White too bright in your kitchen? Introduce wood beams, countertops, furniture and more

COLORFUL KITCHENS Kitchen of the Week: Bold Color-Blocking and a Central Banquette

By Carol Crotta

Glossy red cabinets contrast with black surfaces and white seating in this cooking-dining space designed for entertaining

KITCHEN OF THE WEEK Kitchen of the Week: Good Flow for a Well-Detailed Chicago Kitchen

By Jeannie Matteucci

A smart floor plan and a timeless look create an inviting kitchen in a narrow space for a newly married couple

KITCHEN DESIGN New This Week: 4 Surprising Backsplash and Countertop Pairings

By Mitchell Parker

Make your kitchen workspace stand out with colored ceramic tile, back-painted glass, butcher block and more

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Modern Art Inspires a Color-Blocked Look

By Becky Harris

In a midcentury beach house on Martha’s Vineyard, a redesigned kitchen embraces the look of Mondrian

COLORFUL KITCHENS How to Color-Block With Confidence in the Kitchen

By Natasha Saroca

Master the art of color-blocking in your cooking and dining area by following these foolproof design tricks

Sponsored

Remodel Repair Construction

9 Reviews

Industry Leading General Contractors in Westerville

More Discussions

Quartzite Veins Turned Pink/Red

35

Chip in brand new laminate countertop by cabinet installer!

11

kitchen renovation

7

Vitoria Regia Countertops

7

quartzite countertop suggestions

6