kitchen countertop, marble or quartzite, first world problems

11 years ago

This is my first time to the Gardenweb well of knowledge since The Big Big Remodel started on May 1. I love love my general contractor, Silverado, Inc., in Salt Lake City, three thumbs up, so I have that going for me. I work more than full-time and am the single parent of four (by choice, not complaining) and I don't have any time to run around and look at stuff, so mostly I just shoot from the hip on finish decisions and order a lot of things on line. My Amazon account is getting a thorough workout.

Now I'm faced with the big countertop investment and need to try harder. The house interior will be transitional, not really modern, but the bathrooms especially are fairly contemporary. I couldnÃ¯Â¿Â½t enlarge the kitchen, so it is galley style, one slab of stone should cover it all. I want a gray stone, and have narrowed my choice down to the lovely slab of Palisandro Nuvolato marble or Super White quartzite (there were 15 slabs, so I didnÃ¯Â¿Â½t make them move them, I know one will work).

The stone yard guy says not to worry, a honed finish on the marble will avoid etching problems and reasonable care will avoid stains. My fabricator has Super White in his home with a polished finish and he says he has had no etching problems. Of course, the fabricator wants to avoid any future performance issues and is pushing me toward Silestone, which is lovely, but I want a natural stone in the kitchen (Vitrazzo Cubist recycled glass in master bath and Quartz Reflections Ceasarstone in two smaller bathrooms/laundry room).

The stone yard guy is trying to get me a piece of honed Palisandro from a Sun Valley, Idaho, installation so I can go crazy and try to stain/etch it. I have a little time before it absolutely has to be installed.

My question is: am I crazy to even consider a soft marble in high traffic kitchen? TIA with my first world problems.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

cat_mom
11 years ago
Welcome to the world of GW TKO!

I can't tell you if you're crazy or not, LOL, but OMG is that stone gorgeous!
beekeeperswife
11 years ago
Whatever that slab is in your picture, get it. Just get it. It is drop dead gorgeous.

And I gotta love a stone guy who says you will be fine with honed marble. My kind of stone guy.

My SW is etching. It's something I'm trying to embrace. The only etchings that make me lose my mind are the rings from things. And some are too big to be glasses, so maybe plates? I don't know. The miscellaneous dark spots from splashes I'm over.

But, please, let us live vicariously through you and get that slab pictured.

And don't you dare leave GW without showing it installed!!!

oh yes, where are my manners?, of course, welcome aboard!
Related Discussions
Countertop Geology, Part 5: Marble, Quartzite and other Favorites
Q
Comments (168)
@karin_mt So let me ask you a few more questions then: Does genuine quartzite scratch and chip in that kind of fashion? Would it be reasonable to assume that I would have at least 100 little chips (not natural pits... chips that expose white) and scratches ranging in size from consolidated micro scratches to big gashes several cm long two months after we moved in if this was actual quartzite? Would it be reasonable to expect that to happen all over the stone, even in extremely low traffic areas, on a genuine quartzite slab? Is there any reliable way to test the stone that is installed on my counter to see what it is? ie whether it is actual quartzite or a marble? If so, how would I do that or who could I contact? I just find this to be extremely simple: I paid a small fortune for this stone because I thought it was beautiful and dynamic and all of the research I did on Quartzite as well as the info I was given from the slab yard indicated that it was harder than granite (which I have had in 3 other houses and NEVER seen anything like this on) and beautiful like marble. Thus the cost. So I am not a geologist, but it really seems as simple, at least to me, as it has scratched and chipped in a random, ridiculous fashion so it must not be the quartzite that we paid thousands of dollars for because quartzite does not do that. Where am I wrong?
...See More
Kitchen Island Countertops . . . Marble or Soapstone?
Q
Comments (10)
I like the soapstone perimeter with the carrara marble island top, at least 2" thick, preferably 2 1/2 with a very sculpted edge. Looks like money because it is. I have soapstone and a very small butcherblock work table (2x4) that's pushed against the wall because my kitchen is 17x11, with six doors and two windows; on any case too narrow for a fixed island. My soapstone is hard and very plain (tiny veins). Haven't had any issues with scratching or chipping. I did let some soda spilled on it sit, and it has appeared to etch it. Soapstone is user-riendly, and I have no doubt that I could resurface it myself (I DIY-ed my tops). Etching and staining are the chief antagonists to marble remaining pristine. But aged marble has a payina it's own; whomever says stuff has to be showroom fresh forever isn't living in the real world. Casey
...See More
Advice needed from marble countertop wannabe owners…quartzite? help!
Q
Comments (45)
Thanks Lily Spider :) My inspiration photos all have marble counters lol!!! butI think I'm back on track again - I love classic and I wanted real stone so I think thats why I went the black granite route (though I guess this seems strange after considering marble!)… I've always liked honed black granite and I need to be somewhat practical re the kids - one of the reasons for the kitchen reno (besides the fact that we moved here a year ago and the current kitchen is awful) is to provide space for the kids to be able to 'eat in kitchen' at the peninsula during the younger years while they are still messy (i.e. dropping food everywhere) and to provide a place for them to color/hang out etc while I'm cooking…I don't want to be on top of them the whole time which is why I ruled out the stones that etched/stained/scratched - I think the black granite is a good compromise for me and usability for them and will work in well with the other components of the kitchen…thanks for getting me back on track Lily Spider (my husband almost had a heart attack when I said I was second guessing lol)
...See More
Quartzite problem: it looks like the veins are 'smudged' HELP
Q
Comments (43)
I have selected this Brazilian Quartzite (called CRISTALITA WHITE) for my kitchen countertops...two book matched slabs. The slabs are being sent to the fabricator. No one at the distributor was able to tell me what the coppery looking areas/veins are. I do like them a lot, but I am wondering if they are going to cause any problems down the road, based on what is in this thread. They are smooth to the touch areas - same as the light gray/white that surrounds them. Does anyone have any experience with this type of stone - Brazilian quartzite with copper/iron veining? A second question is that these slabs are currently polished, and I was leaning towards a honed finish. Initially, my fabricator told me that they hone all quartzites as a policy, based on their experiences and outcomes. But now he is saying that my slabs don't need to be honed - they should stay polished. I have used this fabricator before with excellent results, so I trust them, but I am looking for input from other professionals and remodelers regarding my specific type of quartzite slabs with the veining. Thanks.
...See More
womanontheverge
Original Author
11 years ago
I know right? It's so gorgeous and I'm stunned I can even find it in our lovely second-tier city. I thought it would be a big city kind of stone. It has sparkles in it too. A FB friend mentioned that a honed finish might look kind of lifeless and I should shoot for a polished finish and just accept the etching and embrace the lived in look. I have to agree that I would rather have a few etches on a lively finish than a lifeless finsih without etches. I'm leaning toward the marble, WTH, it's only money, but only if one slab can cover the whole kitchen and no worries, if it looks as good as I think it will, I'll be posting dozens of pictures.
slush1422
11 years ago
WOW - that slab is gorgeous!!! Get it! I agree with beekeeperswife! My Moon Night (aka Super White) has never stained but has etched - but because it's honed no one can tell but me, and that's only a certain angle in a certain light. I have three kids too that give it a good beating (3, 5, and a 12 year old)
windycitylindy
11 years ago
That is one of the most beautiful slabs I've ever seen. I would get it in a heartbeat!
deedles
11 years ago
It reminds me of a wintry sky. Really pretty!

Oh yes, welcome!
jgopp
11 years ago
I've had my super white in my kitchen for over a year and a half, and I can tell you that it does etch and dull here and there. But if you're willing to keep it clean and use a nice stone polish on it every week or so, it'll keep looking great. It is not by any means bulletproof though so be sure to wipe up spills and things sitting on the counter for more than a few hours.
windycitylindy
11 years ago
I agree with jgopp on the super white. Ours has a few minor etch spots that no one would ever notice unless I pointed them out. It does scratch relatively easily, but in our kitchen at least it's many tiny scratches which are giving it more of the lived-in patina without detracting from its beauty. It hasn't stained from anything, including oil, and it only etches if something is left sitting on it for a while. Lemon juice takes a few minutes to etch. Tomato sauce seems to just dry on the surface without etching it at all.

Every time I walk in my kitchen I smile at my counters because I think they're so beautiful. Get something that will make you smile when you see it.
angel411
11 years ago
Welcome! Love the slab but I love your username even more. So appropriate for GW as you will discover!
finestra
11 years ago
I love that slab and would grab it in a second - faster than a second if it is quartzite.

I have marble (montclair danby) and had "Granite Shield" sealant put on it. It was sprayed on and did not change the texture of the stone. It is supposed to be a lifetime sealant. Today I canned 24 jars of tomatoes. My friend helped me and she was slopping cooked tomatoes all over the place. Not one stain and very little if any etching (the Danby seems a little harder than the european marbles).

My only problem with the marble is around the sink. You have to be careful not to bang heavy pots into it or it will ding. I never had this problem with my AB granite. And Quartzite is supposed to be hard like granite. If you go with a marble which is softer, I would suggest a farmhouse style sink.

kitchen countertop, marble or quartzite, first world problems

Comments (10)

cat_mom

beekeeperswife

Related Discussions

womanontheverge
Original Author

slush1422

windycitylindy

deedles

jgopp

windycitylindy

angel411

finestra

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

kitchen countertop, marble or quartzite, first world problems

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

womanonthevergeOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

womanontheverge
Original Author