Marble questions

11 years ago

I am trying to figure out marble varieties that are more suited for kitchen use. We are thinking to use it on a table that will be the main table for eating. Please help me do the homework and try out a few samples to persuade DH :)

I like white marbles with defined viening. Some of the carrera etc.. seem more grey and too busy with lots of specs of grey. Is there a link someone has that shows marble varieties. Is there a hardness level etc. for marbles similar to soapstone that makes some types more suited for kitchens and resists stains? I can live with the etching but stains are my biggest worry. Especially with red wine, curry, soy sauce, etc..

One thing I took away from reading other threads is that honed is way better for stain resistance than polished (even though most of the onlibe sites recommend polished.) Do I have to look for honed marble or get them to hone a polished slab. I am not sure if there are stone shops in SF bay area who stock a lot of honed marble.

I see that most people recommend getting it sealed at the fabricator and do it a few more times. Do the sealers still keep the surface food safe? Can I roll pastry on a marble table that is sealed with somethin like 511 sealer (this was the type recommended in some posts). Any recommended products?

Lalitha

Comments (6)

hsw_sc
11 years ago
I don't know anything about which ones are harder than others, but the staining should not be a problem if it is sealed. I have had coffee, wine, etc sit overnight (actually, this happened this morning) and the stains wiped right off.
wishiwasinoz
11 years ago
If you are not dead-set on marble, there are some beautiful quartzite options. It is almost as hard as diamonds, & from everything I have read & heard, it does not stain or etch. The veining of a slab I saw earlier this week was beautiful. The white quartzite I saw has only had slight veining.

Here is a link that might be useful: White macaubus quartzite
Related Discussions
Marble questions: opportunity, love and fears!
Q
Comments (16)
MLK58, nice remodel. What material did you use for the shower floor? I LOVE the inset shelf in the shower. Very functional. Golddust our shower is 4'3"x7'2" and the ceilings are 10'. Kim - we have been using this bath almost 2 years. When the tile man installed it, they sealed it. That is their standard protocol. It sounds like it will need to be sealed again at about year 3. I have no problems cleaning this. The mosiac on the floor have been a problem, but we believe it to be a problem with the product. My installer is awesome and can't figure out what is happening. If you look closely at the pictures, you will see some gray staining on the floor and going up the sides. We assumed it was water from underneath, but there was no leak. The ripped it out and reinstalled. When they sealed it, they drenched the marble with the sealer and really let it soak and then wiped it off. Witihin a few weeks, the gray stains cam back but in different places and in weird patterns. We are in the process of changing the material so I am interested if anyone else has had this problem with mosiacs carrera tile. That being said, I would still install marble because I love it.
...See More
One more marble question....
Q
Comments (10)
There was a post a year or so ago about heating stone counters. The kitchen owner wondered if anyone had experience with this given how cold stone can be. At the time I thought heating a counter was a little crazy, but with reflection I can see the point of it. Stone will be cold on the elbows/forearms, so I guess it depends how often and how you intend to use the space. My peninsula is similar to the picture you pasted above, my quartzite counter is flush with the 15" walnut overhand for seating. I just did a comparison test with my forearms resting up against each section of the counter - the walnut is certainly fall more pleasant to rest up against. If you really love the look of all marble, I'm not sure this should stop you, but the stone really does get cold! And I like the look of stone and wood together. My last kitchen had the overhand section raised over the main island. The clean up sink was on the island as well. Just a note - water did regularly splash up against that raised wood "backsplash" to the sink - it is important to treat the wood properly here I guess. It is more of a problem if the wood has a stain on it.
...See More
danby marble question for gw folks
Q
Comments (4)
Hi Jem, I have Vermont Danby Olympian White throughout my kitchen, including all countertops and a slab back splash. I have some of those little white horizontal wavy lines, most of them are so deep that they can't be felt, others are fissures that can be felt a bit. Since they're a naturally occurring part of the stone, and my fabricator confirmed that they weren't cracks, they don't bother me at all. If you have a fabricator who you trust, you can have them take a look. Just make sure you use a fabricator who is familiar with marble, ideally Danby. One who has rarely/never worked with marble might not understand, or might tell you to steer clear because they're not sure themselves whether the little lines are a problem and want to cover themselves. Another idea would be to contact Vermont Quarries. I've found that they're really helpful. Good luck, and pls post pics if you have them!
...See More
Yet another white marble question...
Q
Comments (2)
I liked the calacatta nuvo Cesarstone...until she said it was around $120 square foot! They had misty carrara quarz as a table with a huge scratch running up and down the edge of it. Not exactly a good advertisement!
...See More
kamkar2006
11 years ago
We have danby marble and it was honed when we bought it. It was sealed with a sealer made by dupont. I have spilled EVERYTHING on it, wine, lemon, green fruit juice etc., nothing stained but everything etches. I don't mind the etching too much and now I don't really worry about things dropping on it. I am going to seal again soon because after our fabricator applied the seal on the marble it left marks where the wiped on the sealer and now as to be honed and re-sealed.

Danby is pretty hard as I have already dropped a few heavy items on it and it has not cracked. It does have some nice veins but it more white. I think the more veins the better as I wonder if etching shows up less with more veins?
nycbluedevil
11 years ago
Take a look at the Calacatta varieties as well as the Danby. I originally wanted Danby but the stone yards were out of it so I looked at Calacatta Caldia and fell in love with it. It is very white with green and gold veining. The veining is softer than the Calacatta gold, which is more defined. I don't have pictures yet but if you check out Arena Stone you can see some very good pictures of various lots that they have. Arena has tons of white marbles. I know you are not in the NY area, but it should give you an idea of what is available.

I thought I read somewhere that honed stains more easily than polished but with a sealer, it shouldn't matter.

Good luck.
lalithar
Original Author
11 years ago
I will look at Calacatta and Danby.

Any input on the sealer? Does using a sealer make the surface not foodsafe? What sealer did you use and how often. It seems to be mostly a simple application - apply and wipe off.

washiwasinoz --> I really prefer marble to quarzite.. quarzite like Bee's is so pretty but looks too polished and modern for my space..
finestra
11 years ago
I have Danby and had Granite Shield come and put a "permanent" sealer on it. I haven't had any stains. I have Montclair Danby and it has some large gray veins, which I think may help to hid some etching. Last week I canned 24 jars of tomatoes and they were all over and not one stain.

I do have a ding near my sink though where a pot must have hit it. I wonder if I would have been better off with a farmhouse sink rather than an undermount.

My Danby was 1/2 the cost of the Calacatta we were looking at.

Marble questions

Comments (6)

hsw_sc

wishiwasinoz

Related Discussions

kamkar2006

nycbluedevil

lalithar
Original Author

finestra

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Marble questions

Comments (6)

hsw_sc

wishiwasinoz

Related Discussions

kamkar2006

nycbluedevil

lalitharOriginal Author

finestra

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

lalithar
Original Author