Apples to Oranges: KD's, framed/frameless, Shiloh/Diamond?
autumn.4
10 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (28)
kksmama
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoRelated Discussions
"'Best" cabinet line for frameless white painted kitchen
Comments (25)The ones I am looking at right now are: 1 - Bellmont 1600 2 - Bellmont 1900 3 - Canyon Creek's Katana Line (I wish they had the higher end line up here, they seem much better and very customizable) 4 - Barkers 5 - Durasupreme is here, but I fear it is too spendy. Egads, though, you can notice the difference in heft. I've been afraid to price them. 6 - Brookhaven. I went to Home Depot and learned that Innermost isn't sold in Alaska's HD stores. My research is still so preliminary. But, I'm impressed with the finishes with Bellmont, and that you can mix 1600 and 1900 series to make it more affordable or customizable where you need it. But, so far, Bellmont 1900 is almost twice as much as Barkers with walnut/clearcoat lowers and white painted uppers - and Brookhaven is more than Bellmont, of course. I'm comparing apples to apples as best I can, but it is difficult to really ensure that given how things work in the pricing game. I'm willing to pay more to get what I want and ensure they are good down the road if I have to, but I admit, I'm struggling with how to figure that out....See MorePlease help with comparing cabinet options
Comments (15)Thank you all for your helpful advice. First of all, let me clarify, that I do value the kitchen designers and meeting with them a few times to gain more insight into their approach, the chemistry, any wow ideas, etc. At the same time, I do have some definite thoughts on what I want to do so I'm hoping the KD can enhance my vision and point out things that could be better done in a different way more efficiently. I am also asking for references. I posted my list because that's the part I am having trouble with since I really want to understand the cabinets and what makes one more expensive or better quality than another. I also would like to know out of curiousity, what is different about the truly highend $250K kitchen and their cabinets vs. the brands I am looking at. Is it an exotic wood? Is it a lot of custom detailing, etc.? The extra money can't all go to the KD. It would also just confirm that I'm doing the right thing given my simple tastes even though the reno budget is less than the 15%-20% of the house but could reach six figures. I like to learn and want to understand the terms e.g., "max door without a stile" is foreign to me but I want to know what the KD is talking about to make an informed decision or to have more influence. For example, I discovered that Woodmode/Brookhaven said they used particle board for the frame and I read about MDF being higher quality than that and plywood even better. So I know that if I go with WM./BH, I will need to factor in an upgrade to plywood. This makes me wonder about all the other things on my list that I sort of know but not really and maybe things that haven't even made the list. Point well taken that there are things beyond the list that I might not know about. However, we did hear about Rutt going into bankruptcy and emerging a different company. However, that doesn't mean that I want to ignore the things I can learn about. The comments about all of the brands, particularly P&F and Rutt being good brands is VERY reassuring and helpful. I will try to focus on them a little more. I happened to look at the Woodmode options for pulls/handles and really didn't like any and figured we would just have to buy those separate. Not sure if that would be the case for the other two. While this wouldn't be a make or break decision on any brand, if I see a trend of a bunch of things that in total are a deal breaker that would be useful to me. Maybe something like the thickness of the drawers or shelves doesn't really matter. Iakuval, first, I hope I've clarified to you that I am looking at the kitchen designer. I did find your segmentation of buyers interesting and am not sure where I fall. Price is important but not the driving thing at least not yet. On shopping for a kitchen, Sure, we have a range of the budget but it's a pretty wide one. Once I see how the costs come in based on my "outcomes" approach of what I want in the kitchen and adding up costs, I can see where I want to cut if it seems unreasonable. On shopping brand/color/door, I think every mfgr has the style I am looking for. Therefore, I do want to compare the quality of the cabinets themselves. But true, If KD and all other things are equal, then a small thing can sway our decision, Roco: I will check out Crown Point, though it is a late entrant. I don't want modern. We like transitional or contemporary but sometimes I've seen what I would call "modern" called contemporary. Maybe it's updated traditional? :) Goosler thank you for the net net of what you think I will find. I operate under those assumptions until I see otherwise. We haven't chosen the GC yet. We are meeting 3 on Tues and hopefully 1 the following week a fifth seems AOL and maybe not up to the job - we want licensed and insured contractors familiar with the permits for our town I will stat another thread when I have time and can find photos. I will call it something like "White Cabinet Kitchen Remodel Follow Up" Thank you all for your comments! I feel so fortunate to have stumbled upon this wealth of minds/knowledge. Plus, everyone seems very welcoming....See MoreNeed help deciding between KD
Comments (27)indedecisive- ply sides always cost more and veneer interior also costs more than melamine. Better, well.... Last I knew(3 yrs ago) Wood-Mode used ply sides for framed cabinets but frameless were furniture board (particle) with veneer and there was an option to "upgrade" to plywood. The biggest difference aside from style between BH and WM is in the finish. WM adds a final step applying paste wax. Things may have changed. Unless I wanted the veneer interior I personally would not pay to upgrade frameless cabinets to ply- I actually prefer not having ply for frameless. Many brands higher end brands have switched to ply for frameless. One that I carry just switched from this fabulous composite of veneer/mdf/osb/mdf/veneer- to ply. I not thrilled with the idea as the old material was atomic. The switch was entirely due to consumer push back and has nothing at all to do with what is best, it was the strongest most stable material available for that application, but the public knows better. Re construction options- you can request 1/2" bottoms for drawers that carry a load along with heavy duty glides, Plywood shelves when shelves are over 30" and will be heavily loaded (for my own BH kitchen I got 1/2 bottoms on one cabinet, skipped all the rest- 8 years now). With all the drawer upgrades I would not expect any problems as happened to a2gemini, even at 42", unless something was defective or improperly done....See MoreWhite Shaker Battle: Ikea vs the rest of the Cabinet World
Comments (69)This is a great thread and I've read it with lots of interest. I'm not as interested in IKEA vs. the rest as I am in frameless vs. framed. I grew up in Europe with frameless cabinets and have now lived in the US for nearly 30 years with various framed cabinets. I still like frameless better from what appears to me be a usability factor, but maybe that is all in my head, but the things that I'd like more information on is to figure out if this is just in my head. What is the inside dimension of a drawer for a say a 30" cabinet for the different brands, or use the 36" or an 18" as an example. The same goes for how much space is wasted in say in the 171" direction and the 143" direction due to the framed parts? It might not be much, but having gone from a large kitchen where I had plenty of storage and the frame was smaller to a smaller kitchen with framed cabinets that has more frame (I assume to save money on the doors) this is something that is really pushing me towards frameless feeling like it has less wasted space and be more comparable across lines of frameless cabinets vs. framed ones where that seems to vary by the manufacturer. One thing that to this day annoys me with the framed cabinets is the lip on the bottom shelf. I love it when I visit my mom and friends in Europe how easy it is to slide out a stack of plates from the bottom shelf and not have to go through the lift motion first....See MoreMrs_Nyefnyef
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoSparklingWater
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agosuzanne_sl
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agojakuvall
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agosuzanne_sl
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agosuzanne_sl
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agojakuvall
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoGreenDesigns
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoGrace76
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoGrace76
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoSparklingWater
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agojakuvall
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoSparklingWater
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agowilliamsem
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoannkh_nd
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agosuzanne_sl
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoa2gemini
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agojakuvall
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoa2gemini
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoautumn.4
10 years agolast modified: 9 years ago
Related Stories
KITCHEN CABINETSChoosing New Cabinets? Here’s What to Know Before You Shop
Get the scoop on kitchen and bathroom cabinet materials and construction methods to understand your options
Full Story
suzanne_sl