Go with what you love. I looked forever for hardware and I finally found one that I loved in Michaelangelo bronze that was a good bit different than the American Bronze of my faucet. When I put them together, even though they were different, they blended beautifully.

I agree with holly, go with what you love. I have satin nickel hardware and brushed nickel faucet, they look the same visually. I think if they are both in the same color family, they will look fine together. The hardware is eye candy, you just stare at it, so you have to go with your heart as to what finish to choose, you don't want regrets.

I think so too. I'm not a purist and I'm being tugged towards a brighter shade of hardware in my space. Thanks for quick answers and support-although I always listen, even if not what i want to hear.

bumping this up.

Anyone out there who's actually done what I'm proposing?

My California migrated lighting designer-who's helped me immensely on many kitchen design issues, is a bit more of a purist on finishes. My notes of our early discussion show he suggested hardware in satin or stainless steel for their sheen but not brushed nickel which is more matte. Antique nickel, brass, antique (aged) bronze etc was also high, polished nickel not so much.

Also, I recently saw a "what's new in 2013 kitchens" and it said popular hardware are satin, orb, some brass, but not seeing as much polished.

If you know of a "bright" satin cabinet hardware maker, please do share. A lot might depend on the base metal in the collection. :/

Thanks again.