Houzz Logo Print
reallytrying_2007

Strugging Stepdad

18 years ago

My wife and I have been married for 5 1/2 years. We have two sons, 4 years and 11 weeks, and a 12 year-old stepdaughter from her previous marriage. Over the last two years, my stepdaughter has become increasingly angry and hostile toward me. The only apparent reason why she harbors such anger toward me is because I am not her "real" father, and she has fierce loyalty for her father, to the point where she builds him up to incredible sight in her eyes.

My wife is my stepdaughter's custodial parent, and she sees her father every other weekend, and at other times as well. Her dad is the type of person who tears others down to build himself up, and I'm certain this is what he has done with me. My stepdaughter has told me that her dad has told her she doesn't have to show me any respect whatsoever, because I'm just a "step" dad, and not her "real" dad. She does, however, apparently get along just fine with her father's wife, her stepmother...it just seems to be me that she consistently disrespects, and why not? Her dad has told her it's just fine for her to do so.

When my stepdaughter is with us, I try my hardest to make us all a family, but my stepdaughter tries her hardest to isolate my wife's attention and separate her from the rest of the family, as to push the rest of us....especially me....out of the way. I know she would prefer it if I were not in the picture at all, and she could have life the way she used to have it...with just her mom to herself, and her dad, although divorced, running things by remote control.

Unfortunately, I don't have the support of my stepdaughter's father to resolve this situation and help her to respect me, because this is exactly the situation he wants. He, unfortunately, craves control, and as much as I hate to say it, his daughter follows in his footsteps in that regard. We have been seeing a family counselor to try to resolve some of these issues, and my stepdaughter told the counselor, straight out, that she rules our house. My wife and I have told her that WE are the adults, and that WE make the rules, and she just scowls at us, no matter what punishment we levy against her. It's as if she just doesn't care. She has told us that someday, she will go and live with her dad, and my wife's ex has threatened to pursue custody several times, although we both know he doesn't have much of a chance of getting it.

Every time I deal with my stepdaughter, it seems like we're butting heads, or at least something negative. I'm taking away privileges for disrespect, or I'm threatening to take away privileges. My wife feels like she's caught in the middle sometimes, because my stepdaughter treats her differently than she treats me (a hell of lot nicer, that's for sure). Another six years of this is going to be fun (and I mean that entirely sarcastically) if we don't figure out how to get this under control somehow. My stepdaughter pushes buttons at every single opportunity. She either wants us to send her packing to her dad's (which we both agree is not in her best interest for reasons I won't get into right now), or she is determined to drive a wedge into our family, and I won't stand for that. I love my stepdaughter, but I also love my family as a whole, which creates a hell of a dilemma for me. Anyone else out there go through this? How did you cope? Any suggestions? Thanks!

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Welcome!
    I think the first suggestion many people here would give is "go see a family counselor" but you've already done that!
    The second usual piece of advice is "You can only control your own actions, but not the actions of others" and you seem to have figured that out already.
    So, you have a good headstart.

    I haven't gone through where you are (and hopefully never will) but I do know a few things about tween girls... I'm not saying this to excuse her bad behavior, but rather to show what she might be dealing with and help you see a fresh perspective when trying to find a solution.
    The tween years (about 10-13) are really hard on girls. They're establishing social hierarchies and these are often REALLY harsh battles. Ever seen the movie "Mean Girls"? It's not far from the truth! She might be negotiating a minefield every day at school and taking it out on you and the family.
    Tweens often face a lot of pressure from their peers to not respect their parents. But, ideally, the parents nip that before it gets out of hand. In her case, she's receiving validation from BD that she doesn't have to respect you, so it's growing and growing. She might not be "trying to drive a wedge into the family" but I can see how a tween girl trying to assert more power than she should have would be seen as that.
    A lot of young girls idolize their fathers. It's pretty normal for a tween girl to think their dad is unstoppably awesome... But it's problematized when the pedestal they've put their dad on starts interfering with other relationships (such as with their mom or stepdad)
    She's also a hormonal trainwreck at that age. I remember it, and it was AWFUL! I remember how every emotion felt enormous and made me butt heads with my parents sometimes too.

    I know I didn't offer any solutions, but hopefully that gives you a fresh view of why she's being this way.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My daughter was BAD in 7th grade. She was nasty to me, I thought she would stay this way. Argued over everything, constantly showed disrespect, I used to cry my eys out. But then it all stopped. It is age.

    She was never this way with her dad though, but I was a CP. He would tell me he does not know what i am talking about because not only she was nice to him, she also talked nicely about me in his presence.

    Your SD is nice to her dad because she only sees him here and there, same with her SM. She is rude to you because you are right there! Unless it is going to become a serious issue, i would hope it is going to pass.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm sorry to hear what you're going through, and can hear how painful it is for you.

    But as the previous two responders have already noted, that age is HORRIBLE for girls, and the family dynamics you've got going of "perfect" (but destructive) BioDad are working against you. The good news is that you're going to counseling, and hopefully, that will help.

    I imagine one of the early things the counselor will say is that Mom needs to firmly and immediately enforce a "no-disrespect" policy towards you. And also that you and your wife devise a short list of clear and unambiguous "house rules" with well-defined consequences. Then have a family meeting where Mom presents these rules - post them in a conspicuous place - then you try to limit your discipline of the girl to issues on this list, disengaging from the rest. (If the counselor doesn't suggest it, I'd ask her about it.)

    If you can stick with the counseling and continue working as a team with your wife, I'm betting that things will be much better in 2-3 years.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think Sweeby is right on. Mom really has to get involved here, regardless of how her daughter treats her. The two of you are a team, and you can't play together when you each have a different set of "rules."
    Expectations need to be set, and she needs to be the primary one to dish out the discipline. This doesn't mean you take a back seat and get walked on, but if the two of you are together and something is said/done by SD, mom needs to be the one to immediately step forward and shut the behavior down. This will show the girl that she is being disciplined because her actions are disprespectful, not just because she pissed you off. It's then less about the dynamic between you too and more about her behavior.

    Aside from that - tween years suck for girls. I am the custodial SM to an almost 13 yr old girl, and I know first hand how difficult it can be. Keep with the counseling, and keep your chin up. I keep hearing this will pass, and I'm clinging to that . . . .

    Best of luck, and keep posting.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Everyone is right, part of it is the age. This happens in homes with both natural parents living in the home. She is testing the limits, and your authority. However, it needs to stop, because as the oldest child, she is setting the tone in the home for the two younger children, and how they talk to you. They are so young right now that it may not be harming them yet. But 4 years from now, she will be 16 and could be very difficult, and your 8 year old child will be watching and learning.

    So I imagine it is finding something that works, in teaching her that regardless of what her father tells her, this is your home, and you pay the bills, and you will not be disrespected in your own home. Period. I have a friend who had a similar situation. The time outs in her room did nothing to change the behavior. This woman is a wonderful cook and her daughter looked forward to the wonderful dinners she made. One day, the pre-teen was again very disrespectful, and while the rest of the family ate the wonderful meal, she ate alone, and was only permitted to have cereal and water, and was sent to bed until the next morning. This was only done that one meal, but they said they would repeat it again, if the disrespect showed up again. I imagine she will test them again, and again, she will learn now that they will be consistant in showing her that she will not treat them that way. This worked for her because she loves her mothers cooking. some kids are picky eaters, and it would not work for them. Oh, and All electronics were taken away that night, and have not yet been returned.

0
Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz