Marvin Clad Wood Conduct Cold, Leak Air and Condense

greggz1959

14 years ago

Just installed 26 Marvin Ultimate Insert Double Hung window, Low E 179 with argon double-paned, clad aluminum outside, primed pine inside, in November and having major buyer's remorse one month later.

The installer shimmed, leveled, and foamed around each frame. Old weight pockets are filled with fiberglass. Exterior perimeter is sealed as well with backing rod and Titebond weathermaster sealant. No air is coming through the rough opening and frame. However, plenty of air is leaking through the new windows themselves, called "blow-by" as the Marvin rep calls it. Also, at the top of the unit, the jamb tracks don't go all the way to the top and there are gaping holes with air pouring in where the jambs should be sealed instead. So much for quality contraol at the factory. In addition, the cladding and spacer bars are conducting much cold, especially at corners where convection is occuring. Even though the rep said we got "warm edge" stainless steel spacer bars,we are getting chronic condensation along the bottom edges of both sashes, even with low indoor humidity, at 20 degrees or less outside. Much cold air blows through the foam bulb weatherstripping in winds or 20 mph or more. Today I had to run a hairdryer to heat up the window to open it as it was frozen shut. When I did get it open, I tilted in the bottom sash and saw ice, yes, ice channeling up the interior track of the sash itself, as well as running along the interior of the jamb bulb weatherstripping, and also ice pockets at the bottom of the sill, inside the tracks, sitting on top of the foam cube, and along the inside of the bulb weatherstrip running along the bottom of the sash and sill. Plus, the side jamb foam bulb weatherstripping soaks up rainwater from the sill which then freezes and makes the weatherstripping rigid rendering it inflexible and unable to move with the movement of the sashes in high winds, hence more air infiltration. When I stand in front of these windows, the conduction of cold is worse than when we had the original single panes with storm windows. I wasn't expecting air tight, but this is ridiculous. The Marvin seals are simply inadequate in our New England weather. Our reason for springing $28,000. for these windows was to never have to rope caulk and plastic over windows again. However, I spent the entire day yesterday applying rope caulk to the new windows. Yes, the air infiltration is less, but the conduction of cold is still so intense from the aluminum that we still feel quite a draft standing in front of the units. Now were considering buying interior storms to cope. I think that's probably a cheaper alternative to suing Marvin...but at this point, we feel majorly ripped off. Yes, the windows look beautiful and they replicate the "prairie style" of the original windows perfectly, but what you get in aesthetics you lose badly in terms of energy efficiency. I confess, I am a design snob and that's why I avoided vinyl because I wanted to preserve the look of our 100 year old house. However, "Fashion windows" don't equal good sense. This is a hard lesson to learn.

Comments (10)

PRO
East Bay 10
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
I see some of your problem right away. Why did you choose low e 179 when there is much more efficient glass available?
websnooper
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
How...of all the issues that he is discussing, would you say that Low-e 179 is his issue?

To top it off, your suggestion of what is wrong is likely incorrect.

Low-e 179 may be the correct glass package for his climate region.

To the original poster, I would get in touch with Marvin. I have read several posts about them and they, apparently more than most, seem to take care of any customer issues.

Good luck.
Related Discussions
Biggest air leaks in a home
Q
Comments (18)
it is difficult to feel the air leakage at the ceiling. unlike walls the wind doesn't blow against it. same for floors of homes on piers. at best, when hvac system comes on..it pressurizes the house, so that would be when you would feel a slight leakage at recessed lights. but the blower door depressurizes all 6 sides. top, bottom & sides of the structure. with this depressurization, air is pulled into the house via air infiltration sites. the oversized cuts in ceiling..recessed lights around supply boxes and bath vent fans these oversized holes are covered by trims, supply grills and bath fan covers. so trades make the holes...but don't seal them. just cover them up. now floors..huge leakage site under bathtubs. plumbing pipe cuts are oversized. plumbing access are left unsealed. my advice to folks is to look for spiderwebs as they build their webs where air moves. balloon framed walls are never good to find. this is a pathway from crawlspace into attic. lots of balloon framed walls in older homes on piers. every house is different but there are some common leaks that apply to most homes. if you invest in blower door test..have ductwork & returns tested. thermal scans are nice visuals, but anyone that has tested homes for a few years should be able to find leakage without thermal scans. best of luck
...See More
window education needed please Marvin, Pella, etc.
Q
Comments (8)
My husband & I just had a discussion about windows yesterday. He said some days he's ready to just replace all the Pellas we put in our home when we built 11 years ago. Today I'm going around with my Liquid nails, opening each window to determine which pieces are falling off & gluing them back together. Ours are crank-outs, a designer series with the mini-blinds in the middle but not the triple-paned sealed variety. We'd had Pellas in our previous home with good luck & felt confident in our decision in '96 to put Pellas in the house we were building even though they only came with a 1 year warranty that year. That should have been a red flag. Recently we had to replace a window pane due to a lawnmowers rock chip. When I watched the guy replace the pane of glass I could see part of the problem. The metal cladding on the outside just clips off and doesn't fit real tight. It just wasn't sealed tight enough, plus they only spot glued parts of it so as moisture or air gets in, the glue gets brittle and the parts break down. That's my take on it from a non-professional, frustrated homeowner. Would we use Pella again - NO WAY!
...See More
Deciding between Marvin, Pella, Anderson, and Lincoln
Q
Comments (23)
Wondering why a "clad" product when you could have all vinyl... honestly the best choice for windows. Why choose vinyl? Vinyl windows have welded corners which are strong and leakproof. Be sure to look closely at the corners of products you're considering. If corners are screwed, stapled or glued, they will leak over time. You could not only have damaged windows, but a damaged structure, as well. Vinyl is so durable it resists fading, it's maintenance free, and it lasts a lifetime. In fact, our windows have a transferable, Limited Lifetime Manufacturer's Warranty plus the Good Housekeeping Seal 2-yr. money back guarantee. That's how sure we are about the quality of Earthwise vinyl windows. Although many don't realize this, vinyl is a sustainable product. Did you know the main substance used to produce vinyl is an abundant resource? It's salt! And vinyl is 100% recyclable. So why waste trees? Vinyl windows are some of the best in energy efficiency. At our company, we take energy efficiency one step further: We built our windows and patio doors to provide optimum performance for your specific climate. Forget the ads you're hearing now that suggest vinyl windows will warp - it's just adspeak. It's actually wood, composites, fiberglass and aluminum that warp over time. I hope you'll have a few minutes to look into the reality of today's vinyl windows because they're certainly very affordable. (Just our 2-cents worth...)
...See More
replacing rotting wood windows with aluminum clad
Q
Comments (15)
I agree, afsa, we have been diligent about painting and caulking these all wood windows which I believe were either Huddig or Huttig (a local company which sold out to another local millwork company) for about 10 years now. I'm just tired of fighting against the elements. Every year I have rotten sills and rotten brick mold in the lower corners of the windows. I even had my painter remove the tracks that hold the sashes to caulk and paint behind them where water was obviously penetrating. The sashes are warping and the gas seals are failing, and worst of all there's wood rot in the sheathing below the windows behind the stucco . . . again!! I don't know if this is primarily a window problem, an installation problem, a stucco problem, or some of all, but my experience with all wood windows has not been good to say the least. Hopefully, new windows, installed and sealed properly will keep my home from becoming a bigger money pit! With all that we have spent on maintenance and repairs, we could have paid for at least half of our new windows by now. I a hopeful to find a solution :-)
...See More
macv
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
The OP should learn how to be more concise, get to the point, and use the return key so others will be willing to read his monologue. I wasn't.
skydawggy
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
I agree with Websnooper and Macy. Did you actually talk to a Marvin factory rep or someone with the company that did the install. I find your experience very hard to believe, as I know Marvins reputation for first class service.

Call the MARVIN home office and get a manager on the phone. I'm certain they will solve the problem for you.
afsa
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Greg, you wrote of the same complaint in a different thread. This sounds very odd to me as i sold Marvin for years and never heard if this problem and i live on Long Island and the wind had been known to blow here and be cold as well. I would definitely look up the factory rep and have him to your house because something does not seem right with this issue.
hey_starfish
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Are you sure it's the windows and not that the house is 100 years old?

There wasn't much insulation technology used back then and I doubt the blame can rest with just the windows.

Perhaps your home needs an energy audit?
skydawggy
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
This is just another one post, drive-by shot at Marvin. I love it how these kind of posters never stick around to answer questions. Likely just a competitor.
tube
14 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Where are you located? I have some friends in the Marvin service department I could get you in touch with.
PRO
Big Win Interior Design
3 years ago
We are also having problems with one of our aluminum clad mahogany interior Marvin's. We have others in this house that we've replaced as we work around the remodel. One of them upstairs is a mulled unit just like the one that is giving us trouble.

same as the original poster, the cold air isn't coming from around the sides where you would expect to find it from a poor installation. It's coming from the edges of the actual window that you lift up and down. My husband just checked the temperature and it's 40° and you can feel the air coming through. It would move curtains if we had any up.

The seal is different on this one for some reason, so maybe that's the difference. It feels more rigid than the spongy seals on the other Marvin's we have in the house. Regardless, I guess we need to call someone out to take a look at it. If they call it pass through air and say that's normal, we're going to have to rethink our plan for the rest of the house. We are about to put Windows all over a porch that will be four seasoned and opened to the house. We certainly don't want to put all the money into climatizing the room just to have freezing air come in through the expensive windows.

I'm not sure what the accusations are about in the comments. but I did want to let everyone know that we are having the same problem with one of our mulled windows.
Cathie Peterson
3 years ago
We bought Marvin windows thinking they were the best and paid a pretty penny for them. We ended up having them removed and replaced with another brand because Marvin would not help. They would send parts that we had to find someone to install but they could never understand the issue correctly. It was the opening mechanism...it wouldn’t work, eventually even broke and we had to nail the windows closed until we bought replacements from a different company. We would never suggest that anyone buy Marvin wood windows. It was an expensive nightmare. We thought they had the best windows until we bought them. I didn’t even know they had a reputation for good service-definitely not our experience.

Marvin Clad Wood Conduct Cold, Leak Air and Condense

Comments (10)

East Bay 10

websnooper

Related Discussions

macv

skydawggy

afsa

hey_starfish

skydawggy

tube

Big Win Interior Design

Cathie Peterson

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US