X-Post How can I update these stairs?

11 years ago

My stairs are oak, but the shirt boards are fir or pine, maybe both, so they look mismatched. I don't want to paint them because none of the other trim in my house is painted. I also want to get rid of the scrolls since they don't go at all with the contemporary style of the house. Even the bullnose stair treads bother me - too traditional in style, wish they were straight edges.

One thing I am thinking about to deal with the issue of having different woods that don't stain the same is using contrasting colors of stain on oak and other wood. I think if the trim was designed right, it could look very contemporary.

I know better than to think I could modify these stairs on my own, and plan to hire a woodworker to do the job once I know what I want to do.

I was hoping those of you with woodworking experience could give me some suggestions.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

lazy_gardens
11 years ago
You really want bullnose, because the center of square treads will wear into rounded very quickly and it's obviously worn in contrast with the squared edges.

Where are the scrolls?
numbersjunkie
Original Author
11 years ago
On the outside, not very easy to see in the photo. But in person they are very obvious because the stain on the oak scrolls does't match the pine on the fir/pine boards underneath.

Yes, I did think about a square edge getting worn. Maybe just take the bull nose off the outside edges and it would improve the look? The pieces on the side are trim pieces, not part of the tread. But as I said in my original post, I would never attempt any of this myself.
Related Discussions
Help Updating Bathroom - x-Post
Q
Comments (5)
Hi: Our home is similar to yours: a master bath with soaker tub and shower, and a second bath on the opposite side of the home for guests. I can only speak from my experience, but I wouldn't take out the tub. My daughter was 17 when we built this home, and she was a bath fanatic. We now have two grandchildren, ages 3 and 5, each of whom I keep one day and evening per week. All their baths are taken in the guest tub. I found the MB soaker tub too large to fill, as well as not feeling I could easily hold onto them when they were younger. I also know that realtors used to call a bath with only a shower 3/4; I don't know if that still holds true.
...See More
X-Post Updated Kitchen with just Staging
Q
Comments (16)
It looks much better - but I think you need to acknowledge the fact that a lot of it is due to a much better quality of photography, taken from a different perspective with a better camera and/or photographer and different lens. Of course touches such as artwork and a couple accessories help a lot, but it's important to recognize the photographer's contribution here too! I'd like to see the "before" taken from the same spot, by the same camera/photographer, if you really want to compare the power of the staging alone. This post was edited by tinan on Wed, May 1, 13 at 18:00
...See More
Re: What can I do with my new house, Exterior, etc. X-Post
Q
Comments (10)
Change out you siding with hardi board. Add a porch roof like the pic.posted that partically follows the roof line to camo. the fact that the roof is wider on one side. Starting at the new porch roof edge add a wide trim board that goes across to the other wall., where the main roof meets the side wall and use hardi shingles above in a different color than the body of the house. Consider nicer window upstairs. I cann,t see the total slope of your yard put it looks like you have enough slope to put in a rock retaining wall. Add a few semi large focal rocks above and some low growing evergreens and a nice stone walk way and multch . Add something like river rock and easy care plants down in front of the rock retaining wall and you probly have the nicest house on your block and it would all be easy upkeep if you use the right plants and multch.If your able to do it your self all that should be less than 3000. We did alot of the same stuff with ours this last year and consider it a learning exp. as well as sweat eguity.
...See More
Update on farmhouse plan (X posted building forum)
Q
Comments (122)
Shades- All your windows are so pretty, in that picture. I like having lots of light/views, too. Shade cloth sounds like a really good idea. I didn't think about the privacy...but that's a nice benefit, too :) I posted this on my unfitted kitchen post, but I wanted to get your input, too. I've been debating about putting the washer/dryer in the mudroom (for various reasons) and a fireplace type of surround, around the wood stove. I don't like the idea that a hot surface would be so close to the entry. So, that being said...I was playing around with some new ideas for the kitchen. I'd like to have a bigger baking area and maybe a little place for marble, out of the main work space. Then, it hit me, what if I moved the wall oven/microwave into the pantry area (I still have the range oven in the kitchen) and I could put the baking area, between the wall oven and corner pantry. I have the farmhouse sink (with the drainboards on each side) in the pantry, for watering plants, washing veggies, arranging flowers, etc. The main sink (maybe a farm sink?) would be for clean up (especially big mixing bowls, pans, etc.) and the little bar/prep sink on the island, is for drinks and washing produce, out of the fridge. Although it's just the two of us, most of the time...we do have a lot of people over in the summer and at 'harvest time' so the extra room is really nice. What do you think? Oh, and I'm thinking the marble in the baking area, blue countertops on the L part of the kitchen, and butcher block on the island...and maybe around the pantry sink. From Fairy tale cottage
...See More
glennsfc
11 years ago
I think I see the scrolls...hard to pick out. I believe the stringers and risers are chestnut, not pine or fir, but not having the opportunity to see up close, that's my best guess.

Very difficult to update a staircase such as this.
glennsfc
11 years ago
Saw your other pic on the remodeling forum and I saw the scrolls and the stringers. Yes the stringers are pine or fir, as you say.

You will have to do a lot of redesign and rebuild to get the look you're after. Painting the risers and stringers will change the look some and may give them a new and fresh appearance. Yes, you need to lose the scrolling, in my opinion.
numbersjunkie
Original Author
11 years ago
I have someone coming out this week to look at the stairs and some other projects I am considering. We'll see what he thinks can be done. Saw some nice round metal balusters and a handrail that I would love to have BUT the spacing on the balusters would be different. Darn.
numbersjunkie
Original Author
11 years ago
The contractor/woodworker I spoke with today says he can cover the side boards with thin sheets of oak, and scribe them to fit. We talked about getting the stain to match, and he thinks he can get it reasonably close, but if not maybe I will have the steps refinished. We are added new flooring too so the older sections may need to be refinished anyway.

He seems very competent, so I'm hopeful. Now I just have to hold my breath when I see the estimate! We also talked about replacing the railings and balusters with something more contemporary, but I expect that will be too expensive to even consider.

If we do this, I will post an "after" picture.

X-Post How can I update these stairs?

Comments (6)

lazy_gardens

numbersjunkie
Original Author

Related Discussions

glennsfc

glennsfc

numbersjunkie
Original Author

numbersjunkie
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

X-Post How can I update these stairs?

Comments (6)

lazy_gardens

numbersjunkieOriginal Author

Related Discussions

glennsfc

glennsfc

numbersjunkieOriginal Author

numbersjunkieOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

numbersjunkie
Original Author

numbersjunkie
Original Author

numbersjunkie
Original Author