skip to main content

Marvin Clad Ultimate Hi-Transparency Screens Not

10 years ago

I installed last year 3 Marvin Clad Ultimate Casement windows. They are fantastic, and really were put to the test this winter which has been so brutal (Chicago). I am going to be replacing two more of my casement windows this spring with the Marvin Clad Ultimates. The only thing I haven't been happy about are the charcoal hi-transparency screens with wood surround. They aren't hi-transparency at all, though the mesh is indeed very fine. Because they are charcoal, the screens look really dark on my new windows.

I removed the screens for the winter so I can have clear bright windows, but will have to put them on for the summer. I have to say, my old windows' 25-year-old clunky screens were less visible than the new Marvins' "hi-transparency" screens. So for my planned window replacements this spring, are there any other choices for screens for the Marvin Clad Ultimate casements? Do I need to go custom somehow? Why on earth did Marvin color their screens charcoal?

Featured Answer

PRO

East Bay 10

10 years ago

Marvin has a retractable screen with high transparency mesh but it is actually a little more "visible" than the non retractable. You will only have to deal with it when the window is open which is usually not much. I agree with you that the Marvin high transparency could be much better but the patents on other manufacturer's products like Andersen and Pella are still in effect. If you put the high transparency and the standard charcoal fiber side by side, you can tell a difference.

Comments (7)

User
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks Eastbay10. Retractable screens might be a solution. The two casement windows are tall and narrow - 24" x 73". Can retractable screens be installed on windows that narrow? How much ballpark would the retractable screens add to the cost?
Related Discussions
Starmark & Marvin Ultimate Combo install?
Q
Comments (5)
Just a quick follow up to keep my thread going... Well, you guys were right about Dave @ StrongWindows. We spent about 2 hours going through my different options and discussion about the Okna 800 vs the Starmark 900 casement windows. If anyone is in the Chicago-land area and shopping for window replacements, please do yourself a favor in contact Dave. I've since had a Marvin rep and it's night and day difference between the two. Dave took his time and offered suggestions. He's also been in the business for 30+ years and has a wealth of knowledge that he shares throughout the process. It was a little mind blowing when Dave looked at the windows and pointed out that there is no weather stripping on any of my casements and how none a even close to being sealed properly. I had a feeling that my windows were in bad shape during this brutal winter in Chicago...
...See More
Marvin Ultimate Clad vs. Marvin Infinity
Q
Comments (4)
The quotes are for a full replacement on my windows. I guess what sticks in my mind is the clad still has wood and has the potential for rot down the road. As for the Infinity it does not seem there is anything to rot on these windows although I am not sure which finish will holdup better in the long run. Another positive for the Infinity is the outside can be painted if necessary down the road not sure that is true the clad. So not sure what is best longevity. Both appear to be solid windows. I am more impressed with the clad dealer who has communicated installation procedures and what happens to minimize damage to the area surrounding the windows on the interior which will leave paint and wallpaper in tact when the job is done.
...See More
Choices, choices: Loewen, Marvin, Screens and Cladding
Q
Comments (2)
Looks like you and your GC have a couple of items to work out. While the aluminum clad window is in no way shape or form a bullet proof material, it is considerable more shielded and less prone to deteriorate as compared to bare wood. Wood windows require considerably more maintenance and upkeep. No comparison. A properly clad window will live much longer is only maintained slightly. If you need wood to the interior, have you considered a fiberglass window? Same construction look to the exterior, available with wood on the inside, and usually a bit cheaper. I would stay with the factory version of the roll away screen and I think your reasoning on the push out casements is completely correct.
...See More
Marvin Ultimate or Sierra Pacific Aspen Aluminum Clad Casement Windows
Q
Comments (11)
what did you end up going with? I live in MN. And we are building in Eagle, Colorado. We are just now having to decide on windows and SP Aspen 2.0 are the architect and builders top choice. Interestingly, we have Marvins in our Minnesota home that was built 25 years ago and we've had to replace them all (wood double hung and casements). They were the highest end marvin available when we built. The sashes rotted. We did an addition 12 years ago, used the "new improved" clad exteriors in the casements and.... yep... still have rot issues after only 12 years. Suffice it to say, I'm starting to think nothing lasts more than 20 years, so why pay extra? Any others with this experience? (We, too, love the SP fit and finish and I think we'll be going with them -- though we also bid the Anderson 500 series and they came in slightly less than the SP's)
...See More
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
10 years ago
They are indicated as an option in this case and what vendor "x" will charge for them is somewhat up to them.

They are not a "need" item and more of a "want". Typically when you get into the "want" items, you tend to pay a bit more for those guys.
PRO
East Bay 10
10 years ago
"Roughly" they add about $150 each to the cost of the wood framed screen and they are available up to 72" tall. What I do see on a window that tall and narrow is that you have a tendency to grab the window low to slide it and it is very unstable. It needs to slide from the middle. Just remember that if you do order them.
User
Original Author
10 years ago
If 72" is the maximum height for retractable screens, then I can't get them because the two windows will be 73" tall. I also saw on the Marvin website "bright aluminum wire" screens as a choice instead of charcoal hi-transparency. Has anyone seen these, and can tell me whether these are less visible than the charcoal hi-transparency?

Here is a link that might be useful: Marvin Ultimate Casements Screen Options
susan62
7 years ago
Hey Sahmmy...did you ever learn more about these screen options? We are going to purchase a Marvin patio door and trying to decide on a screen. From the 2 in square samples we saw the "bright aluminum wire" looks much better in terms of transparency than the "charcoal hi-transparency".. but who knows when it is a screen that is 4' x 7'? Would love to know your outcome! (We are also considering retractable screens but we have a four panel configuration that may complicate that).
ef_houseman
7 years ago
Most window companies use Phifer UltraVue mesh for their "high transparency" screens. You can get a sample from Home Depot and compare it to standard charcoal mesh. You may not see much of a difference from 5 feet away, but look at both screens from 15 feet and the UltraVue screen will be nearly invisible.

Not all companies will use UltraVue on a door screen, however (because the mesh is delicate and not feasible for large sizes). So they may have substituted Phifer BetterVue, which is still better than standard charcoal, but not nearly as transparent as UltraVue.

The same principle applies to retracting screens -- companies are very reluctant to use lighter mesh on a retracting screen, because it is very delicate and can get twisted up when it rolls back into the tube.

Sign Up to Comment

Related Stories

EXTERIOR COLOR Exterior Color of the Week: Bewitching Black

By Jennifer Ott Design

Think you’ve got what it takes to pull off this bold, trendy color choice for exteriors?

MOST POPULAR Find the Right Glass Door for Your Patio

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

It’s more than just a patio door — it’s an architectural design element. Here’s help for finding the right one for your home and lifestyle

SMALL HOMES My Houzz: Sweet Sophistication for a Manhattan Studio

By Corynne Pless

Color and ruthless editing make a 350-square-foot apartment pretty, neat and bright

VACATION HOMES Houzz Tour: Moss-Covered Lakeside Cottage Now a Modern Marvel

By Nora Burba Trulsson

A 1949 Michigan weekend cottage with a sunken roof gets a makeover that stays true to the house's humble roots

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: Just Being Modest on Lake Superior

You don’t have to go all-out to have a retreat that’s all good, this Wisconsin vacation home shows

TASTEMAKERS Pro Chefs Dish on Kitchens: Michael Symon Shares His Tastes

By KitchenLab Interiors

What does an Iron Chef go for in kitchen layout, appliances and lighting? Find out here

HOUZZ TOURS My Houzz: Midcentury Modern Style Transforms a Vineyard Bungalow

By Andrew Snow Photography

Spectacular surroundings and iconic design inspiration meet in a major overhaul of a 1960s Ontario home

TRADITIONAL HOMES Houzz Tour: Tudor-Inspired Outside, Open and Contemporary Inside

By Becky Harris

A designer shows respect for a home’s historic St. Paul neighborhood with a fresh take on Tudor style

MOST POPULAR What to Know About Adding a Deck

By Mitchell Parker

Want to increase your living space outside? Learn the requirements, costs and other considerations for building a deck

MATERIALS An Architect Shares His Go-To Materials

By Eric Reinholdt, Architect

Aluminum doors, porcelain tiles, polished concrete. Here are the features and finishes this professional returns to time and again

Sponsored

Hope Restoration & General Contracting

35 Reviews

Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations

More Discussions

Manual exterior solar shades for second floor windows?

2

Need advice re: exterior windows

6

Window height vs function.

5

Retrofit a skylight into existing roof

7

12' Wide Sliding Glass Doors

5