Weather Shield Sliding Patio Doors vs. Andersen 400 Series Glider

16 years ago

I am in the process of deciding on what brand and model of french door look sliding glass doors to buy for replacing my existing old aluminum sliders. I originally had looked at the Andersen 400 Series and Pella's comparable product (can't remember the exact model name off hand) and had decided to go with the Andersen product.

Recently I became aware of Weather Shield's products in a roundabout way, i.e., Home Depot's Home Services division was out at the house to measure and bid on the 3 windows I need replacing as part of the overall project and the rep mentioned they could do the sliding glass doors as well. It turned out though that they could not supply the Andersen product (even though Home Depot sells it in the store) but rather had a "custom" product they market under the Sequel brand. With a little bit of querying the rep disclosed that it is something made for them by Weather Shield.

As it turns out HD's Sequel is indeed made by Weather Shield, and is really just Weather Shield's Collections series rebranded. I also discovered there is a Weather Shield showroom local in my area so after talking to the rep there it appears that their signature Weather Shield line is more equivalent to the Andersen 400 series although it does offer more choices in interior wood options, etc.

From what I can tell the Weather Shield product is well made and I like that it has aluminum vs. vinyl cladding for the exterior. Also the additional interior wood options are a plus. The price is very similar to what I have received for the Andersen 400 series although slightly cheaper. From a warranty perspective, Weather Shield's has a similar 20 year glass and 10 year non-glass coverage but is not transferable (not a big issue in my mind). However, the rub I do see is that for the last 10 years of the glass warranty they will only provide replacement parts at 50% off of current pricing.

Does anyone have any experience with Weather Shield's Weather Shield line? Any experience with their Collections or Legacy Series may be helpful as well since they are likely very similar in base construction.

Thanks in advance!

Featured Answer

starkite

16 years ago

I saw numerous windows brands and think that the Sequel is a solid window for the price. I am sorry to hear that you had bad experience with WeatherShield, the same manufacturer. Can you share the problems that you encountered that was not covered under warranty?

The Sequel had a lifetime warranty including accidental damage. This is probably the part that is covered by HD rather than WeatherShield. I would assume that window technology and design have improved the last 15 years.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (14)

ibwindows
16 years ago
After 15 years I have managed to take all my weathershield products to the dump. Yes they had a 20 year warranty, unfortunately everything that failed with them wasn't covered.

Read the fine print.
Related Discussions
Andersen 200 vs. 400 series
Q
Comments (42)
I can't compare Andersen with Pella or any others, or the 200 series v. the 400 series, but I bought Anderson double hung windows and a sliding door, and I am sorely disappointed in them. I paid a LOT, esp. or the door. I had no choice but to get the top of the line because I had to get the bronze exterior color. The screens on the windows are flimsy. The hangers for the screen sliding door are plastic and break all the time. I've had problems with a new lock I installed on the sliding doors in December since December…. I would not buy Andersen again. But for all I know, the others are the same. I and so anti-corporate America right now. The greed is out of control; the mentality of cutting on quality in order to increase profits is anathema to me, but that's what they're doing, everywhere.
...See More
Renewal by Andersen vs. Home Depot sliding patio door comparison
Q
Comments (0)
Hi! We are getting 2 sliding patio doors. Have looked at a variety of doors and are coming down to 2 doors: 1. Renewal by Andersen 400 Series Frenchwood sliding door or 2. Home Depot Andersen 400 Series sliding door They both look similar but price at Home Depot including installation is about $1,500 less per door. How do these 2 doors compare to each other and is one better than the other and why? Thanks!
...See More
Opinions on Windsor Pinnacle vs. Andersen (400 and A-Series) PS Loewen
Q
Comments (5)
Thanks WoW! I don’t need a wood window. Only requirement is black exterior. Windsor and Andersen were easy options because my Framing company carries them. Loewen (unfortunately out of budget) is from an independent installer/dealer who also carries Andersen, Lincoln,and Provia. What are your top choices in the Windsor/Andersen budget range? I’m open to another brand/material but these are the things that have been holding me up: I have a full light front entry door with sidelights and transom. There are also three sliders (2 three panel, and 1 lg 8x12 four panel). It’s hard to find showrooms that have similar floor models to test out. Would like them to operate well and feel solid. Same with front door. I’d like it to “feel” like a front door and not a “patio” door. Know what I mean? Installation company. Was hoping to have sales and install from one company. From the forum, I see that Marvin Integrity would be a wise choice, but I sent a bid to a dealer/installer and what I got back had so many errors and took so long to receive, I didn’t feel comfortable moving forward. Is it best to blanket all Marvin dealers with a bid request and see who rises to top? Or another brand that you recommend? I’m in Pittsburgh. Thanks.
...See More
Ply-Gem Pro Series 700 vs. Andersen 100 Series
Q
Comments (17)
I have used both extensively (over 200 remodels - most had window upgrades). We used Blk/Blk A 100's on our place in Sacramento, CA (can see pics of both in our profile - 45th St used A100, Quonset for the Ply Gems). I was a little disappointed in them, honestly. They looked great and made the design element pop, but the single-hung units felt cheap and less-sturdy than many of the Ply Gems and MI's I have used in the past. Now building houses in TX, and again considering A-100's vs Ply Gem 500's for a couple projects. Pricing is a huge factor (both have good warranties), but I have not had ANY leaking with either window.
...See More
Related Professionals
Baker Window Contractors · West Springfield Window Contractors · Sunrise Window Contractors · Verona Window Contractors · Avon Lake General Contractors · Jamestown General Contractors · Kemp Mill General Contractors · Milford Mill General Contractors · Mililani Town General Contractors · Mount Vernon General Contractors · Newington General Contractors · Troy General Contractors · Valley Station General Contractors · Valley Stream General Contractors · Orland Park Carpenters
ibwindows
16 years ago
Just a few of the problems.

Fogged glass after 4 years, replacment supplied at pro rated cost... Twice the price I could buy it locally. Plastic parts broke they no longer had replacements for. Foam in jambliners just gave out allowing unlocked windows to self tilt.
0
tube
16 years ago
I've ran into problems on both. Weather Shields rotting out and Anderson's vinyl chalking over time. Fiberglass would be my choice.
0
ibwindows
16 years ago
Rot sends a window to the dump and means buying a new one. Chalking is corrected with soft scub. I can buy a heck of alot of soft scrub for the price of a new window.
0
michiganman
15 years ago
The question was about patio doors. Why are windows being brought up? I'm trying to decide between Pella, Weather Shield and Marvin. If anyone has any advice or experience on PATIO DOORS that they would like to share, I would like to hear it.
afsa
15 years ago
their answers were about a lack of a company backing up a product and poor design, workmanship and parts. But since your interested only in their doors, their great no problem they used all the crap in a different plant on their window lines. WTF
0
michiganman
15 years ago
Hey afsa, Weather Shield does have a bad design on their windows, but I'm told that is not the case with their sliding doors. Do you have any worthwhile information to share?
afsa
15 years ago
Only that I have sold Weathershield, wood, clad and Visions 2000 vinyl and would not put any of them in my dogs house. Windows or Doors, but that is just my opinion
0
michiganman
15 years ago
So who do you think makes a decent patio sliding door? I need a custom size (10' x 7'), so I'm told Andersen isn't an option. Marvin will customize for about twice the price of Weather Shield. I've seen a lot of complaints about Pella. Any other suggestions?
0
michiganman
15 years ago
So who do you think makes a decent patio sliding door? I need a custom size (10' x 7'), so I'm told Andersen isn't an option. Marvin will customize for about twice the price of Weather Shield. I've seen a lot of complaints about Pella. Any other suggestions?
afsa
15 years ago
Personally I would go with the Marvin, although i do not currently sell Marvin when i did I found there sliding doors to have about the least amount of service call backs of anything believe it or not this side of Anderson. But since they do not make a custom size they are not a realistic choice. I have found Weathershield and its sister companies, Vetter, Peachtree and Crestline to not stand beind there product very well. If it was available through a reputable distributor you may have a chance but i don't trust the company.Just my honest opinion. Yes Marvin is expensive but i truly believe in Windows and Doors you get what you pay for and there is a reason they are more $$$$.
HU-341546034
2 years ago
When I built my home 23 years ago the contractor would only install Weathershield products. I asked him to switch to Pella but he refused. He stated that the weathershield products were far superior to all other brands. I should have "FIRED" that builder. I allowed him to build my house and use the best wood and exterior clad doors and windows that they had at that time The Weathershield windows and especially the 4 section sliding patio door have been a disaster. We had numerous problems and the factory people and their REPS were a joke. We have lived with our bad decision since our house was built. I can't attest to the quality of their products today but when we bought them 23 years ago it was our biggest mistake.
0
millworkman
2 years ago
It's no better but honestly Pella is just as poor a choice.

Weather Shield Sliding Patio Doors vs. Andersen 400 Series Glider

starkite

Comments (14)

ibwindows

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

ibwindows

tube

ibwindows

michiganman

afsa

michiganman

afsa

michiganman

michiganman

afsa

HU-341546034

millworkman

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US