Electric vs Manual Velux Skylight

14 years ago

Going to buy Velux Skylights. Manual opening windows are approx 50% cheaper than the electric opening. Is the convenience of the electric worth the price. We have vaulted ceilings but should be able to get to them manually with a rod. One concern I have besides price, is the more intricate a device, the more chance there is for failure/malfunction. Anyone been able to compare there function and durability. Any one had any particular complaints with either type?

Thanks

Featured Answer

napagirl

14 years ago

I wish my Velux was electric!
Unfortunately we did not have time to order an electric Velux before the new roof was put on, so had to buy a manual from HD. While I love having a skylight, I wish it was electric.
We have a split level home with 8' ceilings and a foyer with a balcony and a 23' vaulted ceiling. Every evening and every morning during the summer I walk up a half flight of stairs to the balcony to manually open and close the skylight and vent the hot air out. Sacramento is even hotter than Napa .... get the electric.

You don't mention how many or where the skylights will be, but if cost is an issue, maybe you could get by with only one or two electric units and the rest manual. My one small unit (20x36 ??) does a good job venting because its in the highest part of the house. Even tho our skylight has a SW exposure, I did not get the blinds bec I didn't like the look of the screen with a "puckery" hole to access the operator. And I guess that's one more thing that would have to be dealt with when I manually opened the skylight.

Another option might be a whole house fan ..... but that might be more expensive than the electric upgrade.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

downtowner
14 years ago
We have electric ones. They work great. We don't open them a lot, but they work great when we do. We live in a noisy location and erred in having the opening face the highway noise.

We got two kinds of shades. We don't really use them.

Why would you want to open your skylights? How often would that be?

If you get the electric ones, get the wall switch. I think the manual remotes are standard.
xrayvision
Original Author
14 years ago
In Sacramento CA area, gets pretty hot during day, but relatively nice at night - so during summer open them to air out the house in evening. We have vaulted ceilings so would also help let out the hotter air towards top.

Thanks for info
Related Discussions
Can you tell me about skylights in the kitchen?
Q
Comments (22)
I think it also depends on your climate. We live in Chicagoland. Freezing cold and hot summers. We had a beautiful velux installed in our kitchen by whom I call, "Mr. Skylight". Great light. But, Big BUT, ever since the skylight, we have to wear coats to eat in the kitchen in the cold winter. A few years ago, I had someone come out to insulate around the skylite. It helped somewhat. On many days, we switched from parkas to sweaters. On the worst days, we ate in the dining room. My dh places portable room heaters next to his skinny body to tolerate our cold kitchen temps. When we do our reno, we will, unfortunately, have to rip out the outside west wall and install superduper insulation to make our kitchen habitable in the winter. Yes, I love my skylite. It has been insulated twice;first, at install, by Mr Skylite, and then again, a few years later. I dont like wearing parkas in the house, esp, while eating dinner. Bulky, clumsy, and makes for trembling hands and tear-stained sad faces, The new reno, hopefully, will make us all have big smiley faces. Easy to see big smiley faces in all that natural lite. Druthers, artificial lite, as opposed to 'natural' would have made me perfectly happy, as long as I didn't have to wear a winter coat at dinnertime.
...See More
A quick question about skylights
Q
Comments (19)
Years ago, when we added 10' to the E side of our former house to expand two bedrooms and a bath, we had Velux skylights installed in those three rooms. They were not fully venting, but had a pull down (by means of pole, recessed hook) vent at one end that would let warm air escape. The vents had insect screening. Open, and they were just about year round, the vents also let in an amazing amount of sound, like the sound of rain at night over my bed ;) Hail was a definite clatter. Not once was there a leaking issue in many years, and this is coastal Washington - I'd add that the Velux were the only brand the designing architect would recommend for this climate at that time at least. I haven't had reason to look into them recently, we no longer own that house.
...See More
Skylights & Privacy
Q
Comments (3)
Velux offers blinds in between the glass cartridge in the unit so you can be in complete control of your living space. Some are manually operated and some are electric. Getting deeper, the technology is presently available to frost a transparent glass by hitting a button that sets off an electric charge in between the glass cartridge and the glass is instantly frosted. Hit the button again and its clear. How much money do you have? Go for it. THe Porch Guy PS: Please don't get the frosted ones, you'll regret it. You loose the sky...
...See More
How are you guys holding up in this "Snowpocalypse"??
Q
Comments (42)
Perhaps not for you, Tree. Here it has been a difficult six weeks. We have set record low temperatures as well as having overall temperatures 10-20 degrees below average for most of that time. We got something like 7' of snow in that a month and a half. Normally, I have an hour commute, and since I work part time, I stay home when the driving is bad since my commute can get to 2 hours or more. There were a couple of weeks that only went to work 1 day because every other day it was snowing. However, today for the first time since some time in December or perhaps late November, we woke to temperatures above freezing! While it was only 33 degrees, and densely foggy, it makes me hopeful. We have started mud season here. The front walk is finally draining, and driving the dirt roads feels a bit like dancing with the car sashaying in the soft mud. The farm truck delivering manure to the field got stuck yesterday, half in the road and half in the field. After an hour of trying various combinations it took a front end loader pushing from behind and a large truck pulling from the front to free it from the mud. The snow is no longer as high as the window sills in front of the house, so I have hopes that spring is finally on its way.
...See More
afsa
14 years ago
If you choose to have the electric operators make sure you get the rain sensors as they will be a nice feature
xrayvision
Original Author
14 years ago
Still deciding on exact size -- but pretty sure going to go with two 23" x 46" skylights ($950) -- one in small kitchen (13 x 11ft) and one in connecting small breakfast nook (9 x 11ft) - about 10-11 ft up from floor. My dilemma is for only $200 ($1150)can get one 44" x 46" and put it in between both rooms. But that will go right over our peninsula/bar sitting area and we would loose the pendant lights we were planning - wife not too keen on that.

Those would be our only skylights.

Napagirl, I heard they have a device that can convert a manual to electric. I only know that it exists, don't know price, reliabilty, etc...
ron6519
14 years ago
There's no reason you can't retrofit an electric opener on your skylight. It's just a device that gets mounted at the skylight base. Running the wires might require opening some walls or ceilings.
Ron
napagirl
14 years ago
xrayvision, I agree with your DW - don't give up the pendant lighting bec you'll miss it when the sun goes down.
I still vote for the electric openers.

ron6519, Thanks for letting me know I can retrofit my manual skylight to electric.
I'll look into that before we finish this remodel.
xrayvision
Original Author
14 years ago
Just a follow up. Bought 2 electric Velux. The 2009 model is on sale at a local place 20% off because they are coming out with new line in 2010. So if anyone looking may want to call around. I got mine at Truitt and White in Berkeley CA, but sale only applies to their current in warehouse stock (so look for a bigger place that actually has them on site/warehouse).

Electric vs Manual Velux Skylight

napagirl

Comments (8)

downtowner

xrayvision
Original Author

Related Discussions

afsa

xrayvision
Original Author

ron6519

napagirl

xrayvision
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Electric vs Manual Velux Skylight

napagirl

Comments (8)

downtowner

xrayvisionOriginal Author

Related Discussions

afsa

xrayvisionOriginal Author

ron6519

napagirl

xrayvisionOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

xrayvision
Original Author

xrayvision
Original Author

xrayvision
Original Author