Bathroom Vent fan repair - what do you typically do?

11 years ago

For you folks that regularly are called to repair bathroom vent fans (eg. Broan, Nutone) without opening the ceiling to replace it all, what do you typically do? Do you buy a same size kit, take out the fan insert that matches the existing housing, and replace that? Or are you replacing motors, or what? These things waste too much time. Especially with older Nutones, they can be hard to match size and get quickly.....and who knows which HD or other place will have what on their shelves any given week.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

User
11 years ago
I generally just replace them, especially when the fan in question is the more inexpensive type.

I'm a bit confused by the "opening the ceiling' wording. An entire unit can usually be replaced by simply removing the old and installing the new---unless the exhaust piping has to be attached in the attic.
snoonyb
11 years ago
Generally, you purchase the whole fan, "like", assembly, and then you can quite easily remove the motor/impeller assembly from the existing housing, remove the impeller retaining clip (if it has one) remove the impeller from the defunct motor, place it on the new motor and reinstall into the housing and insert the balance of the remainder into the trash can.
Related Discussions
bathroom fan for a small bathroom
Q
Comments (3)
A bathroom exhaust fan should produce 4 air exchanges per hour. Your bathroom is 7 x 7 which is 49sq.ft Assuming an 8' ceiling the total volume would be 49 x 8 = 392cu.ft We want four complete air exchanges per hour so that would be 392cu.ft x 4 = 1568cu.ft per hour. There are 60 minutes in an hour so we divide 1568 by 60min and it equals 26.13cfm. You currently have a 50cfm fan, which is twice the size you really require yet your having problems with the mirror fogging up. I suspect your problem is not the fan. Nature abhors a vacuum therefore a fan cannot push air out of a room unless there is provision for an equal amount of air to enter the room. You can test the theory by running the shower and leaving the bathroom door slightly ajar to allow more air to enter the room. Generally they make a slightly higer gap under the bottom of a bathroom door to allow more space for makeup air to enter the room but in some circumstances that does not provide enough makeup air. The solution then is to install a duct through the wall to an adjacent room and put a grille on either side. That will allow the additional air.
...See More
bathroom vent fan cover
Q
Comments (2)
Well, our electrician recommended Panasonic (apparently they are the most quiet) so we already installed the fan, but your suggestion inspired me to look for different Panasonic models and while doing that, I ran into this grille accessory, which looks a lot more attractive than what we have now. So thanks for helping out. Here is a link that might be useful: Panasonic vent fan antique grille
...See More
Vent Fan in the bathroom
Q
Comments (1)
"...one saying only the manufacturer recommends GFCI protection, not the NEC." This is correct, and all you have to worry about. Why would it need protecting? Because the manufacturer says so. NEC 110.3(B) tells us we must listen to the manufacturer.
...See More
Do you have Vent Fans in the Bathrooms?
Q
Comments (22)
Our very tiny master bath (40 square feet) doesn't have one and never did. There is a big viga running across the ceiling in this bath, so I'm not sure where a fan would go if I wanted one (I would consider one of those remote units like pal has, but we have a flat roof with no real space between roof and ceilings). The room has a window, though, which helps. There is a newer combo heat/fan/light unit in the main bath. Neither bath has ceiling light fixtures, so there is no competition.
...See More
homebound
Original Author
11 years ago
Ok, thanks guys.

Handymac, if there's no access from above, I don't know how you change the housing without added work and cost. In these cases I just find (hopefully) the same model and dimensions, then swap out the inner plate with impeller. Otherwise, I assume some ceiling repair, repainting, etc., but try not to do that.

Snoonyb, that's about what I do, except that if go to the trouble to find the match, I install the inner assembly into the existing housing, plug it in, and be done with it.
snoonyb
11 years ago
" except that if go to the trouble to find the match, I install the inner assembly into the existing housing, plug it in, and be done with it."

Thats all well and good, except that as often as not the new impeller can be different in dia causing a loss of efficiency.
lazypup
11 years ago
First of all, your wasting your time to look for parts in H.D., Lowes or any other big box home supply store.

Get the model number off your existing unit and to to a commercial appliance parts store and get the correct parts.
brickeyee
11 years ago
"Get the model number off your existing unit and to to a commercial appliance parts store and get the correct parts."

And pay more than a whole new unit (especially if you are paying a pro to do the work, he gets paid the same rate to drive around as to install things).
homebound
Original Author
11 years ago
I start with model# and dimensions.

Might as well buy the whole unit from HD (if it's there) and harvest what you need. But for some of the old, small 50 cfm Nutones, I know of one old-fashioned hardware store that keeps two motor housings in stock. Occasionally, one of our HD's has ONE motor assembly on the shelf but it's such a cr@p shoot to even make the trip.

As for the appliance parts store route, that might be an idea from the perspective of time-saving. I will check if they (Tribles) actually keep any motor housings onhand. (probably not, but we'll see.)
sdello
11 years ago
sometimes you can find parts online for good prices. Of course, you then need to wait for it to arrive.
alan_s_thefirst
11 years ago
It's possible to get replacement bare motors sometimes. Broan are good about having replacement bases -fan/motor, that fit into the existing box. They have a plug/socket, so you don't have to do any wiring.

That being said, I just replaced one, and it turned into quite a big job because the replacement base was more than a whole new unit.

I put in a new one, which meant a bit of carpentry etc because the boxes were different sizes.

I had to cut the nails/screws holding the old one in, and insert the new box from below, which required a bigger hole, and careful saw cuts in addition to allow for the nailing tabs. The fan cover covers the repairs from it, in the ceiling.

The insulation around the duct had no vapour/air barrier so I used a mylar bubblewrap product and foil tape for it. Since the house was old enough to not have had an vapour bag around it, I built one with the mylar stuff and sprayfoamed it in. Lastly I decided the fan should have its own switch, so I could use one of those timer/humidity sensing ones.

It turned out well and I'm glad I did it, it works better and is much quieter.

But in most cases, just replace the fan motor and base.
mike_kaiser_gw
11 years ago
I seem to recall ordering a motor from Broan or NuTone and it not being horribly expensive. Of course, for the really cheap ones, it might be easier to scavenge parts from a new one.