Uh -- pick the one you like?

Sorry, that wasn't very nice of me. Perhaps you could say something about the context in which you'll be using these? What's the house like, how do your tastes tend to run? As it is, it's hard to know what to say other than "I like that one."

You might run this by the home decorating forum and explain the style of your home to get opinions over there.
Give details on the interior of your home concerning casings/baseboards,trims and wall treatments such as wainscotting,etc to give them a better picture of where you are going with this and what might fit.

The doors should match, at least a little bit, the style of your house.

Does you house have a style?

The third is unique enough to look dated or out of place. Six panels are quite common. I actually put 2-panels doors in my own house. Style wise they are a match, but by not being 6-panels doors they are different enough to be different.

Mongo

We have three panel interior doors, painted MDF (or is it MFD?). Every spec house in America seems to have the 6-panel, hollow core.

Remember, you will be dusting all the ledges! LOL

I like the first or 3rd. I don't think they'll really go out of style. 2 Panel is classic and the bottom one looks like an old country pantry door. I think it is neat. Is the 2 panel a flat or raised? We just put all flat 2 panel doors in out basement. I love them.

I like the third, but I'm biased: I used a very similar door in solid pine. Fits well in my 'turn of the last century' look.

mongoct, house style? I'd love to answer that. I have no idea! People ask me all the time and it's embarassing that I just don't know! I just pick out what I like and have never worried about it fitting into a style or theme. I actually thought about starting a thread here about 'what is your style'?

All of the doors are flat. I'm not a fan of trying to make something look like wood if it's not and I'm too cheap to buy the real deal!

tjgoldie, I love what you said about it looking like an old country pantry door. It's funny to me that my DH picked this one out too and he tends to like more modern things. I didn't tell him that I felt more like you because he would have changed his mind!

oruboris, do you have pictures posted anywhere? I'd love to see your doors and your home!

Thanks everyone for your help!

sara
i like number 1, then number 2, then number 3. number 3 would be just perfect as a pantry door, but i don't know how it would look if every single door were this style. in our house, for example, the first floor has 7 interior doors. IMO the third one is very farmhouse country which is great painted white and installed in a farmhouse (new or old) but would fall flat in a rambler, ranch, split level, or bungalow. even a remodeled one. door number 1 is your most versatile and will fade into the woodwork. that would be my style, don't know about yours...
BTW we are converting all of our nonmatching doors to the style the previous owner picked (door 2). that will leave fewer for us to buy. but in our case, we are staining them, which is a better look for the 6 panel i think. good luck, doors do make a difference!! kren

You can't go wrong with Door #2. That's the standard 'default' door that everyone has. It's not something anyone will say "Wow!" about, either positively or negatively. A Safe Choice. (yawn)

Door #3 has the potential to be great if it's really nice quality door. But if it's not - if it looks "near miss" in person - then it would be a big problem all over your house. So I'd call that a risk.

Door #1 is unconventional enough to be interesting, but also classical and traditional enough to be low-risk. It's not so detailed that it needs to be "high quality" to pull off the look. (Kind of like how inexpensive black slacks can still look good, but cheap pants in white? Uh unh...)

So my vote is for Door #1.

I'm glad that so many like door #1, because that's what I'm getting. :-)

Door #1 is what I see in most older homes in my area. It's a classic, especially if flat-paneled.

To me, door #2 reads New Construction. Not that that's a bad thing....

I prefer 3 panel doors myself but you didn't list that option. That's what we went with. Of the ones you listed, I'd pick #1.