Adding 1/4' drywall to existing HEAVY knockdown texture walls

11 years ago

So I have decided instead of paying thousands upon thousands for a professional to come in and skim coat and sand HEAVY knockdown texture walls, where itll be dusty all over etc for weeks, I will have someone add 1/4" drywall to the walls.

My main question is since they are adding 1/4" drywall wouldn't this cause issues with hiding some of the crown molding and baseboards? If I had to buy new crown molding and baseboards doesnt that costs thousands? Also how difficult would it be to re-do the outlets correctly when adding the 1/4" drywall?

The 1/4" drywall seems like the best solution because I have at least 800 linear feet of walls that have this insane knockdown texture on it that I want removed. I'm just concerned when this happens the molding will not look right. What can I do?

Featured Answer

Billl

11 years ago

All the molding will need to be removed, possibly recut, and reinstalled. Window and door jams will need to be addressed. Outlets will need be brought out to the new finished surface (they sell extenders, so that is pretty easy)

Definitely get quotes for both before making a decision.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

TexasCatherder
11 years ago
Actually, you can skimcoat yourself - it is time consuming but not hard. (I had no DIY experience!) My entire house had this heavy knockdown texture on the walls. You get a box of Sheetrock drywall joint compound, take some out and mix some water into it to get it easier to spread, and then smooth it on with a big drywall "knife". Let it dry, sand it down, and then repeat. I used a vacuum attachment for a shop vac when doing the sanding and it really minimized the dust. I worked on it every evening and saved a ton of money. If you want, I can post links to the materials I used. I think my actual materials probably cost less than $100. (PS I am a woman "of a certain age" so if I can do this, anyone can!)

You may decide that you can do the bulk of the work and then have a painter come in and do the "finish" coat, which would still save quite a bit of money. The main thing is that if you hire someone to do the skim coating, it takes several trips because each coat has to dry and then be sanded, and it will probably take 3 coats (depending on the original texture.)
Related Discussions
Removing drywall and ceiling
Q
Comments (4)
I am going to bring in contractors. I am just trying to get a feel for whether removing and replacing the sheetrock and ceilings is going to cost $100,000 or $10,000 or some range. We have a number of options here: 1. Remove and replace using an asbestos abatement contractor - we aren't required to do it but we could do it anyway 2. Remove and replace using a regular contractor 3. Remove texture from the ceiling and walls but leaving the drywall up and the ceilings there - Using an asbestos abatement contractor 4. Same as 3 but use regular contractor. There are cost factors involved, of course, but also doing what will be safest long-term. I know that either of these options will generate a lot of dust but I don't know if one option is safer than the other. Regardless of whether asbestos abatement is required, I want to feel comfortable moving back in. I am also a little at a loss on getting quotes since the room addition for the master bath will, I think, require getting drawings done. I know there are design build contractors but I am reluctant to tie myself to one company by having them do a design and then not to be able to get quotes from others.
...See More
Is orange peel wall texture 'dated'?
Q
Comments (13)
Granted, smooth walls are very hard to do well, and every little nick or wave in the drywall shows. But when done well, and painted well, it's pretty amazing. And it makes the room look bigger because you lose a visual sense of where the wall actually is, especially if you use a flat finish. I just got so tired of 11 years of that knock-down collecting so much dust and dirt. Another alternative is that with each successive painting of your textured walls, the pattern disappears as the paint builds up. When we bought our house, I immediately painted the bedrooms and noticed a huge difference, especially since I used 2 coats. I didn't do the common areas, and you could see the ridges and plateaus much more easily. To each his/her own.
...See More
Drywall debate with contractor, what to do?
Q
Comments (35)
There are 2 types of smooth finish in my midwestern market. "Ugly" and "Awesome". Ugly is about the same labor as orange peel & knock down (also called executive). Awesome smooth walls require leveling of drywall, complete skimcoat, and extensive attention to detail. Ugly is ugly because it ends up being really wavy and inconsistent. Especially true of old homes with previously plastered walls. The old lumber varied in thickness considerably and it was the job of the plasterer to level out these inconsistencies when he applied the mud. Drywall is the same thickness throughout and will not even out these differences. Smooth compounds this because it hides nothing. I've had some success with customers who get sticker shocked at smooth by switching to a very light orange peel. Not as awesome as smooth, but better than an orange peel. Still need to level the studs prior to installing the drywall though. Knockdown is the favorite of any drywaller due to the amount it hides. I've seen some pretty gnarly seam taping almost disappear when the k/d was applied. So in short, if you want smooth, be fine with paying extra for it or you might end up with ugly. Best of luck. Congrats on the baby!
...See More
which is worse: textured walls and ceilings or dark obtrusive kitchen
Q
Comments (9)
We have rented in a ton of vacation rentals. First, as much as I hate popcorn ceilings and just had them removed in my Fla home, short term renters aren't going to be thinking about the ceilings and textured walls at all. Before they rent they are going to be looking at the photos of the place to see how well it meets their needs. They will take a hard look at how the kitchen functions for them and how much seating space there is for their group in the living room. You are foolish to think that since everyone tends to hang out in the kitchen they won't mind a smaller living room area. People also want enough space for comfy chairs and a couch for their entire group to lounge on while reading, relaxing or watching tv. And, even though the two level counter is unpopular in this design obsessed forum, I suspect many potential renters would be happy with that eating bar that is separated from the working counter area. I'd brighten lighting (dimly lit places are one of my major gripes with vacation rentals) throughout the place and paint the walls a good light color. Accessorize so people think it is cute. Don't paint the cabinets because they will just get banged up whereas the wood won't. Put one or two thousand towards these types of things and save the rest of the money for when you eventually move into the place.
...See More
John Tebbs
11 years ago
I would skim coat it, because you can probably work around all the moldings and outlets satisfacttorily. I just finished skim coating (two coats and sanding)a hall ceiling, and it looks great. To cover it with drywall, as mentioned, requires removing everything and reinstalling. None of this will be easy or quick, but the skim coat will be the best solution with the least pain, in my opinion.
Fori
11 years ago
By the time you have it done, the texture will be trendy again. Is it really that offensive? :P
ms222
Original Author
11 years ago
This is very offensive, and the problem is the lower 25% of the wall is actually completely smooth. So it doesnt look right to begin with
ndeedles
11 years ago
I had that in a house I owned once. Hated it and don't blame your for wanting to get rid of it. Skim coating will cause less work with the trim, etc. as was said above.

I had a guest once trip on the stairs, fall against the wall and took all the skin off his knee and elbow. Hateful stuff, that texture.
powermuffin
11 years ago
Yes, I don't think it will ever be trendy; it is too obtrusive. I used Magic Trowel to patch our beloved plaster walls and it was much easier than the normal dry wall trowels for me. Give it a shot; you can always go to plan B if you do not like the results.
Diane

Adding 1/4' drywall to existing HEAVY knockdown texture walls

Billl

Comments (7)

TexasCatherder

Related Discussions

John Tebbs

Fori

ms222
Original Author

ndeedles

powermuffin

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Adding 1/4' drywall to existing HEAVY knockdown texture walls

Billl

Comments (7)

TexasCatherder

Related Discussions

John Tebbs

Fori

ms222Original Author

ndeedles

powermuffin

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ms222
Original Author