Need your advice - New Pool Build Specs

12 years ago

Hi, I am a newbie Northern California pool owner and am working on the design, components, and finishes for the pool. I have been surfing this site for a few weeks looking at finishes/tiles and am grateful for everyone sharing their photos. I have a couple different bids and am a bit worried about making the right choice. The bids are all fairly close, so I'm most concerned with quality of build and long-term management of the pool. I'd love your feedback on the items below. Thanks so much!

Specs:

Depth 3.5-7.5'

18x36 free form w/ 7.5' diameter raised spa with 2'wide spillover

baja step 6.5'x4' with umbrella sleeve

Questions:

1) Hayward used to be a mediocre brand, but in the past couple of years has improved supposedly. Is that really the case or is it marketing hype? One pool builder recommended not using Hayward, but instead using: Sta-Rite/Pentair with a Jandy Controller

2) Do we need the ozonator? Do they work or are they a gimmick?

3) Is the pool size good? Some friends have said it seems big. It would take up less than half of the backyard.

4) Is 7.5' for a spa a good size? How many people does that fit?

5) What size should the baja step be? Is ours too big/too small?

6) Are Fujiwa tiles good quality/tough? They are pretty and an upgrade $$, so I want to make sure they'll last.

7) Does anyone have a pool builder in the San Jose area that they loved and would recommend, or hated and we should avoid?

8) Any other recommendations of things to absolutely do or mistakes to avoid?

Finishes:

Pool Finish: Blue Granite Pebblesheen

Waterline Tile: 6" Fujiwa Tile, Bohol Valley - http://www.fujiwatiles.com/product.asp?plid=78

Step trim tile: 2 options (NPT Minikoyn TK-1341) (Fujiwa Tile TNT033)

Coping: Arizona Flagstone Medium Buckskin (to match the existing patio & firepit)

Equipment:

Skimmers: 2

Filter: Hayward Cartridge 525sqft Swimclear

Pump: Hayward Ecostar Variable Speed

Heater: Hayward 400K Lo/Nox natural gas

Cleaner: Kreepy Krauly Platinum

Saline SWG: TBD

Controls: Hayward/Goldline Pro-Logic PS-8

Additional Sanitation: Perfect Pool Ozonator

Spa: 6 jets, 1 air blower 1hp bottom mount

Lights: 2 Savi Melody Blanco in Pool, 1 add'l in spa

Solar: Heliocol 11 panels (or 10)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

poolguynj
12 years ago
1) Hayward is still a mediocre brand. I try to avoid it when I can. None of the big three are perfect but Pentair still still #1 IMHO. Jandy/Zodiac is catching up though.
2) You don't "need" an ozonator.
3) Pool size is fine though 3' to 7.5' vs. 3.5' to 8' depth usually allows diving and is more frequently seen.
4) This size with usually hold 4 - 5 people comfortably.
5) That is your decision. You might like to get some marking paint and outline the pool in the yard.

I can't offer my opinions on 6, 7, or 8.

Scott
ldjd
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks. The PB all say that going from 7.5' to 8' requires additional engineering in our area, so we were holding off on going the extra 6".
Related Discussions
Design Phase - Pool Specs (Need Input) - New Post
Q
Comments (1)
ollieboy, we built a Spool or a Social pool and you may get some ideas from our pool build. Look at http://www.thathomesite.com/forums/load/pools/msg0718532217198.html?21 Hope this helps
...See More
New pool build specs and details
Q
Comments (16)
Quote: "I have checked out my PB with the BBB and everything looks great. He has built pools for 5 personal friends dating back 8 years and none of them have had any problems and recommended him highly." Excellent, sounds like a great track record! ==As far as automation...forgive my ignorance...would that be the Pentair Intellitouch Wireless? He has included the 4 keypad in our bid but I'm wondering if I should request the 8 keypad. Any thoughts?== Yes, I just responded in your other thread too but the Intellitouch is your automation system. Since you've got Pentair automation you should definitely consider the 4 speed Pentair pump (4x160). It's an excellent and efficient pump and can be programmed to run at various speeds for different functions through the Intellitouch. Regarding the keypad, it really depends on what you're controlling. Is it the QuickTouch remote? If so, that's just a simple 4 button on/ off keychain-sized controller. They also make a full-featured controller that allows you to make adjustments as well as turn things on/ off (costs a lot more though). ==One other thing...our weeping wall will have 4 weepers along the 40' wall. There will be a loveseat in the water in the back center so no weeper there. Should I request a fifth weeper at the loveseat? Would that require additional plumbing or pumps?== Hard to picture what you're describing, do you have a plan you can scan & post? I guess it depends on whether you want water spilling on you while you're seated or not. It would require additional piping, but probably not another pump.
...See More
New Arizona Pool Build - Advice from the Experts?
Q
Comments (15)
Caveat: I'm not a builder, so this is just a consumer opinion. I believe the typical pool should draw more water from the skimmer than the main drain - useful for circulation and cleaning of surface debris. There are even some who claim drains are "old school" thinking and can be eliminated. Makes a 2-1/2" drain line coupled with a 2" skimmer line not make sense to me. I would suggest both at 2-1/2" but bow to Scott's more extensive experience if he revisits this thread. In my area the cost difference between a 10' stick of 2" and 1-1/2" is about 50 cents. Since there is no practical cost difference when compared against the larger pool construction costs, there is no reason not to have both in-floor and wall returns to be 2" except at the fitting itself. I have in-floor (but not cleaning) and wall returns and they are both 2" right up until the pipe penetrates the pool shell. In general flow/pump terms, to prevent cavitation noise and pump wear, the suction side flow capability should be the same or greater than the pressure (in-floor wall return) side. Hence something like 2-1/2" on suction, 2" on return. Note: two 2" pipes together flow about the same as one 2-1/2" pipe, so a 2" drain and a 2" skimmer all the way back to the pad is about like a single 2-1/2" from pool to pad. Rebar requirements depend on a lot of variables that are local to soil, etc. In my area (virtually 100% sand - Florida barrier island) 12" on center is sort of standard until depths exceed 6 feet.
...See More
Seeking advice on new pool build plaster
Q
Comments (3)
I was under the impression that Diamond Quartz was just the premixed product that the applicator mixes with Portland Cement to form Diamondbrite. We are going through the same process in Fort Worth, and have narrowed down to Diamondbrite or possibly Quartzscapes. Pebble Sheen and Pebble-Tec (and Stonescapes Mini-Pebble) were beautiful, but just a bit too rough for our little ones' feet (and swimsuits) in our opinion. Plaster is nice, but we'd like something a little sturdier after formerly owning a white plaster-finished pool. We ARE leaning toward Diamondbrite over Quartzscapes because of: 1) the premixing quality control issue you speak of; 2) the feel of the samples (Quartzscapes is a little rougher, though not bad); 3) our Pool Builder is ambivalent, but says his applicator has had good results with Diamondbrite and he is coming around on the product; 4) the color selection is more suited to what we're looking for (grey-green) than Quartzscapes - at least in the samples we got; 5) we've seen and felt Diamondbrite in a pool and the owner has nothing but positives to say about it; and 6) I've seen a few negative reviews here or at Trouble Free Pools (can't remember which) about problems with Quartzscapes blotching or not looking like the samples, which scares me even though I have a TON of confidence in our PB. Hope some of that helps. As for the light, from what I've read elsewhere, I'd guess 1 light should be enough to light a pool of that size, though it depends on what look you're going for. For instance, I expect some shadowy areas and attenuation at the edges of the pool at night, and even prefer it.
...See More
MPK 09
12 years ago
Hi, we went with an 16 X 36 freeform and one thing I didn't know prior to building is that it is 16 at its widest point. Now that isn't a huge deal for us, because we're not a big family, but it might be if for others. Also, our sunshelf (which is about 5X6) really eats into that width in the shallow end. Our spa is 7' in diameter and I think the 7.5 or 8' might be better for when we have friends over. It really depends on how you plan to use it. Good luck!!
ldjd
Original Author
12 years ago
16x36 was our original dimensions until we realized that it was the widest point. Our widest point now is 20' and our narrowest is 16'. also, I should have clarified that the extra engineering would be needed to bring the depth from 7.5' to 8', the spa size is unlimited (except for cost to heat, expense to build, and space in the yard).

Scott, will 7'5' spa really only hold 4-5 people? We were hoping to get in at least 6.

thanks!
c9pilot
12 years ago
Spa advice:
Set your kitchen chairs around in the pattern you're getting (circle?) and use a tape measure to approximate the sizes you're considering. Then sit a bunch of people in the chairs and see how it feels.
Are your knees all bumping together?
Then, have someone measure the height from the seat of the chair (bottom of your butt) to the height that you want the water when you're simmering in the spa. Around here the standard is 18", but I had mine dropped to 21" because I wanted the water over my armpits. If you have a tall torso (or big butt in my case) the standard height would put the water just above my sternum - too low for me.
I also had the PB stagger the heights of the jets, so that each seat would hit a different part of my back, although the range is not huge.
Hope this helps.
ldjd
Original Author
12 years ago
great suggestion on how to figure out the size, seat height, and jet types. thanks!
dssxxxx
12 years ago
Cleaner: Kreepy Krauly Platinum

Forget this one.

Go for the Dolphin or Aquabot. No comparison to any cleaner that goes in your skimmer.
poolguynj
12 years ago
Platinum is a pressure side, updated Legend. Kreepy Krawly is the division at that specializes in pool cleaners. I suspect you were confused with the original KK.

Scott
ldjd
Original Author
12 years ago
another cleaner option is the tiger shark cleaner. do you like that option better?

Need your advice - New Pool Build Specs

Comments (9)

poolguynj

ldjd
Original Author

Related Discussions

MPK 09

ldjd
Original Author

c9pilot

ldjd
Original Author

dssxxxx

poolguynj

ldjd
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Need your advice - New Pool Build Specs

Comments (9)

poolguynj

ldjdOriginal Author

Related Discussions

MPK 09

ldjdOriginal Author

c9pilot

ldjdOriginal Author

dssxxxx

poolguynj

ldjdOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ldjd
Original Author

ldjd
Original Author

ldjd
Original Author

ldjd
Original Author