CPVC v. Copper

13 years ago

I have a very short question but I will try to give as much background info as possible. We are renovating our home in north central florida. It is a 1987 currently fitted with all copper piping. We decided to install an instant hot water heater - and we were convinced to put it outside. I think that was a mistake but that is for a different thread. Anyway, the plumbers used CPVC. They really didn't ask us if we had a preference, they just did it. This was run outside and through the attic. The supply lines eventually run down into the concrete slab in the kitchen. We need to move these a few inches in order to make the new oven fit (it was originally installed all messed up and they worked around it with cabinetry - we are essentially moving some pipes about 3" so that they are inside the wall where they come out of the slab). So they are using CPVC here also, which will be covered in concrete tomorrow morning. and our oven and cabinets placed on top of flooring (wood).

My unprofessional inclination would have been to just stick to one kind of piping in the house. Now it might be too late, but maybe not. There is still plenty of more work to do (re-hooking up sinks and stuff) and I can still decide on what goes in there, at the very minimum. But once the concrete is poured there is no going back.

Does anyone want to weigh in on whether we should switch back to copper or keep going with CPVC? My main concerns are: health reasons, fear of cracking due to weather, fear of releasing chemicals or breaking due to heat in the attic, fear of cracking under the concrete, fear of bad joints leaking under the concrete.

I feel like we really messed up by not researching this earlier, we just sort of took the advice of our plumbers.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

ladoladi
Original Author
13 years ago
oh I just want to be clear also that the CPVC / copper interconnect will be underneath the concrete slab, under our gas range.
maryland_irisman
13 years ago
Briefly, you shouldn't be concerned with using plastic. In today's world, copper is very expensive. I prefer using copper because the job goes faster and the end user can use the water right away without waiting for the curing process as is required with CPVC.

The content in cement has a tendency to eat copper over time. I think the CPVC would be fine at that location and you shouldn't see a problem as long as the transition from copper to CPVC is secure and leak free.

CPVC is supposed to be impervious to heat and not prone to introducing plastic type toxins into the water. What I have noticed with CPVC over time....When I've used the CPVC cutter in the past on new CPVC, it would be a nice smooth cut. When I have done work on a point where CPVC has been there for 5 years or more, the cut was different. Instead of a smooth slice through, the pipe appeared brittle and would snap when the blade was half way through. After truing the cut and using the normal CPVC prep with new fittings, it doesn't seem to make any difference. The CPVC is expected to expand and contract as is copper. With copper, the stress would be more inclined to effect the soldered joints. With plastic, the gluing process is supposed to meld the joint which would have virtually no more impact from stress than the rest of the tubing. The CPVC must be secured by brackets in a specific way and frequency to hold it in place and still allow for expansion and contraction.

50 years from now we should see what the application of CPVC produces. Poly plastic was supposed to be so great when it first came out. It's not allowed for potable water in homes here.
Related Discussions
Plumbing after a carbon block filter - copper or CPVC?
Q
Comments (2)
Doesn't matter as far as the water is concerned. Running the water through a carbon block will not make it more aggressive, might even make it a tad less aggressive.
...See More
Copper or CPVC to replace copper pipes?
Q
Comments (8)
"Is it necessary, or a good idea to replace the areas of the house that were not included in the remodel, since the house is 25 years old since it is M copper?" Yes, do a total replacement, as the copper has reached it expected life expectancy. CPVC is widely used in mobil homes due to it's flexibility and lack of out-gassing at the glue joints. "Also, the plumber wants to use several island vents, including one in a bathroom. He doesn't want to go through the roof." You need to have a short and serious chat with your contractor about quality of workmanship, because this is BS. "And yes I think this is all about the general contractor saving money, my husband is afraid that if we push him too hard about the pipes he will charge us more on change orders/items that he has completed, but will not give us a price on." In many states all change orders are required in the business and professional code, to be fully priced upon presentation for signature. But, why would you sign an authorization to proceed, without knowing what it cost? "We ask him how much adding or changing something will be, instead of telling us he just builds it without giving a price or change order. We have asked him several times to write it up, but he does not, Its really irritating and yes my contract states that he must give us the change order in witting, before he changes anything." If you know an attny. better yet where he lives, don't wait until monday, race over to his house and break in.
...See More
Repipe with Copper or CPVC?
Q
Comments (11)
"Premature failure of copper pipe is almost always poor quality pipe, or the wrong specification of copper pipe, or a result of the water conditions not being correctly treated." Which thickness of copper is recommended? M or L? "Every new tech fantastic plastic plumbing solution for the past 40 years seems to end up as a class action lawsuit down the road." It does seem that way. All the plumbers telling me that PEX has been used successfully in Europe for decades fail to mention that Europe doesn't chlorinate their water. PEX is degraded by chlorine. I want to see how it looks here in forty years.
...See More
CPVC to copper
Q
Comments (1)
One of the neat things I have learned here is easy to remember if you use a bit of logic. The codes proved that you cannot connect a metal tapered male thread into a plastic female thread. The logic being, that the taper causes the outer fitting to be forced outward Â a force that tends to break the plastic. The reverse is acceptable. The ÂpriceyÂ fittings are gland-types that seal by compression of a resilient washer against the fairly flat end of the male nipple. The force of the sealing fit is axial in the gland fitting. This is a very strong connection. And while a tapered (IPS) fit is very strong, it is limited by the strength of the plastic. (The strength of a plastic fitting depends on the ÂScheduleÂ and the material type. In PVC, a Schedule 80 female IPS thread can support the expansion force of a male IPS. However, the code still does not call that out as acceptable.) Of course, I do. And that should count for something Â at least in my castle. Pinoke
...See More
asolo
13 years ago
I'm no pro but I'm not sure I would be comfortable with that transition-point encased in concrete.
alan_s_thefirst
13 years ago
All plastics get brittle with age. I prefer copper but the concrete corrosion question is a good one, but if it's approved for it, it shouldn't be too bad.

I think PEX will come back to haunt us later on, as IT gets brittle, but I do think it's a clever system with a lot of advantages - but I don't know if it's worse in the hands of a DIY-er since the crimping seems to be a bit of an art. You don't set fire to your house joining it, though.

CPVC v. Copper

Comments (4)

ladoladi
Original Author

maryland_irisman

Related Discussions

asolo

alan_s_thefirst

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

CPVC v. Copper

Comments (4)

ladoladiOriginal Author

maryland_irisman

Related Discussions

asolo

alan_s_thefirst

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ladoladi
Original Author