Need advice on healthy, high-protien cheap canned cat food

11 years ago

The vet wants to put my kitty on a healthy, high-protien, low-carb, canned cat food. But they all seem so expensive! I'm used to friskies that I can get on sale at Krogers, but I think that is the protien equivalent for a cat of a bag of potato chips. All the ones at the pet store are about $2 for a pretty small can (and that can add up if I want to feed this to my kitty all the time)

Has anyone been able to find a relatively healthy, protien-rich canned cat food that is also relatively affordable?

Featured Answer

lzrddr

11 years ago

you can usually purchase Fancy Feast in large quantities for pretty cheap (less than 40 cents per can) at Walmart, and sometimes Target. The kind without gravy (the 'feast' forms) are nearly all high protein, low carb and decent fat and salt ingredients and are pretty good diets for cats. The gravy ones have a lot of carbs in them (more than necessary). Some of the Fancy Feast flavors are considered by some internal med professors (mine in particular) to be among the best all around cat foods available on the market (even better than all the fancy veterinary diets per this professor of Veterinary Medicine). But there are many good quality canned foods available. Just try to stay clear of the ones with lots of grains (or any grains if possible) in them.

'By products' however are not usually something you need to avoid as these are still protein sources- just not ones we humans would normally want to eat, but that still have nutritional value. These do make the foods more affordable, but not at the expense of the kitty... not so with all the unnecessary carbs- thosea ARE cheap and unwanted fillers.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (16)

oregpsnow
11 years ago
Petsmart has their own brand - Authority - that is reasonably priced and good quality. The price right now is $.80 a can. It is far better than any of the cheap grocery-store foods.

I am a total sucker for my cat and I buy her the expensive stuff. But I can afford it. I totally understand how buying good food for your cat can get expensive. Bravo to you for caring enough about your kitty to feed her good food.
laurief_gw
11 years ago
If you live near a Trader Joe's, I've heard that their store brand of canned cat food is pretty decent quality for an affordable price.

It's also MUCH more economical to buy 12-13 oz cans than the smaller 5.5 oz or, worse yet, the 3 oz. cans. Some brands, like EVO and Wellness, offer the larger cans. It's also cheaper to buy by the case, and it can be cheaper to buy online and have it shipped directly to your door. Most of the online sellers have frequent sales and promotions, often including reduced prices AND free shipping if you order a certain amount.

Of the premium, high quality, high protein, low carb canned foods, EVO is usually the least expensive.

Laurie
Related Discussions
Canned grain-free cat food w/o veggies
Q
Comments (28)
I buy Merrick 96% meat canned food to add to the dried food my dogs eat, so seeing your need for a mostly meat food for cats caught my eye. I pay $2 a can for 13 oz or so at our bargain-basement independent pet food store. It is 9 % crude protein, 7 % crude fat, 1.2 % crude fiber, 78% moisture. It does not have the added taurine that cats need, though their cat food does have it. I have no idea what the cat food costs. You might want to look into it, though. I see it does have Guar and carrageenan, though. Merrick Before Grain Salmon Canned Cat Food Ingredients Salmon, Water for Processing, Whitefish, Dried Egg, Yeast Extract, Glycine, Calcium Carbonate, Sodium Phosphate, Potassium Chloride, Salt, Guar, Choline Chloride, Taurine, Carageenan, Mixed Tocopherols, Vitamin E Supplement, Zinc Amino Acid Complex, Iron Amino Acid Complex, Manganese Amino Acid Complex, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Copper Amino Acid Complex, d-Calcium Pantothenate, Vitamin A Acetate, Niacin, Lecithin, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement, Folic Acid, Ethylenediamine Dihydriodide, Cobalt Glucoheptanate, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Biotin, Thiamine Mononitrate, Sodium Selenite Guaranteed Analysis Crude Protein (min.) 10.00% Crude Fat (min.) 4.50% Crude Fiber (max.) 1.40% Moisture (max.) 78.00% Here is a link that might be useful: Merrick
...See More
dry food for cats that can't eat dry food ;)
Q
Comments (11)
Lukkiirish, the problems with your cats was not due to wet feeding. Dry food is made to shatter IF the cat bites down on it. Of course, when it does, it's nothing but mealy grit that easily lodges in the gingiva. This leads to periodontitis, resorption, and other painful conditions. The only way to care for cat teeth at home is to brush them. Your claim that dry food is good for feline oral health is no different to claiming that eating saltines will clean your own teeth. If you know the anatomy of a cat's mouth, you can see that there are no chewing surfaces, ie., the molars are high on the outside and low on the inside near the tongue. This facilitates shearing action, which, rather than chewing, is what a cat's mouth is evolved to do. Chewing animals have flatter molar surfaces, so that food can be kept in place for chewing. Imagine the action of a mortar and pestle. The tool is designed to hold stuff in place for grinding. That's what your teeth are made for. Cat teeth are shaped to provide a scissor-like action. So, on that alone, you can understand why dry food is useless for feline oral health. Next, dry food is by nature very high in carbohydrates. It must be, since the plant matter is needed to glue the meat meal grit into kibbles. If you're reading labels, good-but if you're not translating them, then you have no idea what you're feeding your cats. Any claims on dry food labels of "50% protein" are utter hogwash. Firstly, any plant matter that is useful protein in any other animal feeds is also considered useful protein in cat food, despite the fact that cats cannot utilise plant protein. You need to know how much animal protein is in the mix, and manufacturers are not always going to tell you that if you call them. Secondly, you need to calculate dry weight to get a grasp of how much of ANY protein is in the mix. If you're lucky enough to get facts from the manufacturer, then you still do the maths. The best dry food on the market is probably less than 20% animal protein, which is grossly insufficient for obligate carnivores. Then you need to consider that cats are not particularly interested in drinking water. Everyone claims that "my cat drinks plenty of water!" But no one can tell you how much water "plenty" is! A cat's natural diet is prey, which is about 70%-80% water. So is wet food! Dry food? Under 10% water. Cats will drink, but are not thirst-driven, so are unable to know if they're getting enough water to function. The dry-fed cat will walk away from the water dish long before it has consumed sufficient water. As a result, dry-fed cats have undue strain on kidney function, digestion, urinary function, and who knows what else because they are always dehydrated. Dry-fed cats are also far more likely to be obese and to develop diabetes and hypertension. Oh, and let's not forget how many dry-fed cats end up with an excess of urinary crystals or even blockages! This is almost always due to dry feeding, which leads to concentrated, alkaline urine. Cats need the sufficiency of wet food fluid intake in order to reduce urine's concentration and to flush out crystals. The higher animal protein in wet food helps to maintain appropriate urine acidity. Another interesting thing is that so many people are completely hoodwinked by the"grain-free" movement! It doesn't matter! Grain-free does NOT equate carbohydrate-free! Grains are often primary suspects in food allergies. The grain-free bandwagon needs to be halted for the sake of our cats. Grain-free dry foods contain as much carbohydrate as do grained foods. You'll frequently see claims that cats in the wild will eat the stomach contents of their prey, but this is not fact. Cats are not keen on stomach acids needed for plant breakdown and carefully avoid eating any part of prey digestive tracts. I suppose that laboratory cats who are only fed digestive tracts will consume them in hope of avoiding starvation, but not cats in more normal surroundings. Lastly, I'm always hearing from people who claim to have cats who were dry-fed only, and lived to be 32 and never had a problem. Well, genetics can make some cats lucky enough to slip past troubles, but these are very much the minority. I also suspect that some of the owners were lying about the cats' longevity, or the cats had outdoors access so supplemented their dry food with nice juicy prey. It is also likely that the cats were never taken to the vet so any problems they may have had were never diagnosed. It's like the centenarian who, when asked the secret to his long life, answers " booze, cigars, and unrestrained sex!". Does that mean that EVERYONE should live like that in order to become a centenarian? Of course not. I see no problem with using dry food in place of cat treats. It's less expensive. Ten to twenty pieces of dry food in a day are amazing as training rewards. But there is no real benefit to dry feeding.
...See More
Cat food and diet question
Q
Comments (13)
Ok looks like I had some typos...I should have been more clear, too, about what foods he was on. When we first got him we fed him the Science Diet food that they had been feeding him at the shelter. Once that got close to running out we switched him to the Blue Buffalo Indoor formula that our other cat was on. He ate that for about 6 months before he started having troubles. We took him to the vet and he stayed for a few days (little bugger kept pulling the catheder out) where they put him on the s/d food and some other medicines. He got to be home for a couple days when he strained again and I noticed his urine was the wrong color so back to the vet he went for another couple of days. He stayed on the s/d food until the first week in November where we switched him to the c/d food once his urinalysis came back clear and he was using the box with no troubles. I then went on vacation and the vet said it would be ok for both cats to eat the c/d food. I want to find a food that I approve of (I really liked the ingrediants for Blue Buffalo, too bad they dont agree with little boy's system!) and a food that I don't have to purchase from my vet. I work over nights and they are only open during the day. Plus 50$ for a 20lb bag of food that I dont find to be of high quality is hard to swallow. I can pay 30$ for food that I like and that makes the kitties have soft fur and nice breath but this stuff is already making them feel ragged. It could be the dry weather though so I shouldnt blame the food. Anyhoo, I looked at that link listed above and there seems to be a couple of foods I could look into. Hopefully they are available in my area and the vet knows something about them. I'm guessing, since no one offered it, that there wouldnt be a home-cooking option for this little guy. It would probably be very difficult to make sure he got everything he needed and would still be something he'd eat. The girl cat eats any and everything so whatever dietary needs she may have will not be hard to get her to eat. My husband wondered if we should not give him tuna fish water since fish is something to be avoided. I'll tell him not to. Thanks again for the help!
...See More
My cat is fat: Food recommendation and kitten update
Q
Comments (19)
I found Dr. Pierson's website 2 years ago and put our 16 lb. VERY food motivated female on an all-wet, no-free-feeding diet and she did wonderfully. On top of the weight loss, her bowel movements improved 100%, as she used to have soft, pudding-like movements quite frequently when we gave her dry. Her energy levels did a complete 180 degrees as well and she was back to acting like a kitten. She is exactly like Sarah's cat in that if you food down, she will eat it ALL and then go over to the other kitty's bowls and eat ALL of their food...and then beg for more! We knew that if we didn't get a handle on things, she would become obese quite quickly. Now, she gets Wellness Chicken or Turkey wet food twice a day. We have to feed her separately from our other cat, as she will inhale her food in 3 seconds while our male is just getting started. We also noticed that wet foods with fish or seafood are too rich for her and contribute to her getting what I call "pudding butt". She managed to trim down 3 1/2 lbs and looks great! Here is a link that might be useful: Cat Info Website - Feeding Your Cat
...See More
calliope
11 years ago
And this is what irritates me. The local markets used to all sell the large cans of cat food and several brands of that as well, and one by one they dropped those lines and sell only the tiny, tuna can sized meals. Then they started adding the ultra cute, gourmet tiny cans. In addition to the expense of this junk, the majority of them are little shreds of meat floating around in a sea of 'gravy'. My kitties would only lick up the gravy and leave the meat. So many times when chatting with other cat owners at the cat food isle they say the same thing. Why do they insist on producing stuff cats won't even eat? In the assortments, half the time, they'd only eat on variety out of the pack and the rest would go begging. I am down to one store now who will sell the large cans of pate'. Thanks for the tip about pet smart, I'll check it out.
Gracie
11 years ago
Our last kitty was addicted to Fancy Feast gravy, and when his appetite declined at age 14 due to disease (which FF probably contributed to), we noticed we were throwing away a lot of licked-clean chicken chunks. So we searched for pate styles so he could put on some weight. We discovered Wellness Chicken Formula and Turkey Formula, which both our old and new kitties love. Petsmart sells the 5.5 oz. can for $1.79. They have beef and fish flavors too, but make sure it says "Formula" on the label.
oregpsnow
11 years ago
Wellness is good - especially the Wellness Core - but $1.79 is a lot of money for many folks. The Core is almost $2.00. That is why many people feed Fancy Feast or Friskies, or the very weird Meow Mix.

It is good that there are a few affordable alternatives to the not-so-great stuff.
krycek1984
11 years ago
we feed ours the fancy feast garden greens in the teal cans. the quality is visibly better than other supermarket brands, including regular friskies. instead of "meat" floating in gravy, it has a dense creamy texture. i find that this is more filling and palatable for kitties. the small can just contains less gravy.

of course this is not equal to high quality brands like core.
ms_minnamouse
11 years ago
Do you belong to a Costco or Sams Clud? I wonder if their kitty food is any good.
ms_minnamouse
11 years ago
I agree about the by products. Organ meat and other yummy things animals love but some humans view as disgusting. Non-skeletal meat (organs and the like) is more nutritious than skeletal meat (breasts, fillets, etc.).
petaloid
11 years ago
I'm another fan of the Trader Joe's canned cat food.

Our cats get three of the flavors on rotation and they are happy.

Also, pet supply stores have quality brands at cheaper prices if you buy by the case.
stir_fryi SE Mich
11 years ago
I often wondered why "by-products" are discouraged --- if a cat in the wild where to kill its prey -- would it not eat the organ meat and others?

Unfortunately, we are often restricted to serving what our cats have decided they will eat. For my cat, that mean Friskies shredded canned food -- he won't touch pate'.

Now, I totally agree that corn and the like has no place in a cats diet.
Mary
11 years ago
I have found this fantastic site by a vet and you MUST go there, too. You will find your answers, and I recommend you share with your friends with cats, and even YOUR vet.
http://www.catinfo.org
beckyg56
11 years ago
I have 2 diabetic cats. I had to look around to find a good high protein food they would eat. We started out with the RX food which in addition to being costly- they wouldn't eat it. So I did some looking around and found that Friskies Classic Pates are a good high quality high protein food, as are the Fancy Feast Pates.
These are actually higher in protein than the over priced RX foods!

Since putting my cats on the Friskies Pate, they are diet controlled diabetics- no more insulin!

Make sure though that you read the labels as the shreds and slices in gravy are not higher in protein like the pates are.
Vanessa64
10 years ago
Interesting what you say about your cats diet controlled diabetes.
I was just now surfing around, to find out if any body has anything good to say about Friskies. My three cats only like Friskies and Petsmarts Grreat Choise. Yesterday I bought three tiny little cans of Max Cat, expensive and supposed to be super healthy. They actually liked it! Hooray, I thought, finally a high quality food they will actually eat.
Then I put on my reading glasses to study the label and congratulate myself for being such a good cat owner, buying food I can barely afford. Real meat, no by-products, blah, blah, blah and - 8% protein!! All three flavors. The Friskies and Grreat Choice have 10%. So I am sticking to those two brands.

Petsmart and Petco have price match, so I pay $0.46 a can, (Friskies 5.5 oz) that is what the price is at Walmart, and then I still get my reward points from the pet store :)
Vertise
10 years ago
I agree on the Fancy Feast addiction. My cats will not eat anything else. They used to eat the healthy Wellness food until I had to feed a sick cat whatever he would eat. I swear they put something in it to addict them, just as it's been discovered they do with people food. I hate these irresponsible companies and their junk food because I can't get my cats to eat anything else now.

This post was edited by snookums2 on Fri, Aug 30, 13 at 14:45
schoolhouse_gw
10 years ago
snookums2, I had to go back to Fancy Feast Turkey Giblets Feast for my 15yr.old. He had eaten dry Meow Mix all his life until he had dental work one year and I offered a wet - the FF. He woofed it down. Now that he is older I started to worry after reading so much online about the evils of this food and that food, ugh, thinking I contributed to his decline, ect. ect. I started to buy the expensive food. And I took in a feral and wanted to give her the best I could too. Well, Kitty wanted FF. He would eat the other but not as happy, lost weight. So recently I went back to FF just for him. At this point, he's got quality of life and if he will eat anything I let him. Except I do sneak in what I feel is healthier stuff now and then. ha.

Petco is the only local store I can find the Turkey Giblet Feast Classic. He doesnt' like the "Turkey Giblet and Gravy".

Need advice on healthy, high-protien cheap canned cat food

lzrddr

Comments (16)

oregpsnow

laurief_gw

Related Discussions

calliope

Gracie

oregpsnow

krycek1984

ms_minnamouse

ms_minnamouse

petaloid

stir_fryi SE Mich

Mary

beckyg56

Vanessa64

Vertise

schoolhouse_gw

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US