Toilet vent pipe causing moisture issue?

12 years ago

Hi all -

My husband and I just bought our first house this summer and discovered that the ceiling in a closet had peeling paint--finally went to scrape/paint and found that the ceiling in one corner is actually mushy. Went up into attic and found 2 things:

1) the fan for the bathroom (bathroom is on other side of wall from closet) is buried somewhere in attic--either under insulation or in between ceiling and attic floor and is not vented from what I can tell (we stopped using it!)

2) There is a rather large black iron looking (cast iron?) pipe running up through the attic to the roof and it seems to be very close to where the ceiling issue is in the closet. I was told by some (who did not actually see the pipe) that this is probably the toilet vent pipe. I noticed that there was some condensation droplets on the pipe in some areas, particularly the lower part where it gets close to the insulation.

While I know the bathroom fan is sure to be causing major issues and needs dealt with, I'm honestly leaning more towards the vent pipe as to the cause of the ceiling issue as it seemed to be right in the area where the ceiling issue is----does this make any sense at all? I told my father of my findings and he does not seem to think this pipe should be sweating/have condensation on it (not sure of proper term!)>

Any ideas? I'm planning to "dig deeper" this weekend, but providing it is this pipe, what can be done to stop the issue?

Thanks!!

Cassie

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

bus_driver
12 years ago
In cold weather the vent pipe might sweat from moisture migrating from the living area below. I would expose more of the pipe by pulling the insulation away from it. Except for possible fire hazard, spraying the outside of the vent pipe with urethane foam should solve the problem. Other effective insulation for the pipe should be researched. Of course, the inside of the pipe must be left unobstructed.
0
jakethewonderdog
12 years ago
Cassie

A couple of points:

1. The bathroom fan has to be vented through the roof or eaves. Having it vent into the attic space can cause condensation on cold surfaces (like the vent stack or wood framing)as well as mold and other problems.

2. It could be that the drops of water are condensation on the pipe - but that wouldn't be my first guess. The pipe would have to be significantly colder than the surrounding surfaces AND the humidity would have to be very high as well. What I have seen is that the vent is typically a little warmer because of hot water usage and because it's in a heated portion of the house before it exits to the attic. If anything, the condensation should be be closer to the roof. An exception might be if you are in a very cold climate (UP in Michigan, for example).

I would look for a small leak where the stack goes through the roof. It's not uncommon, especially with cast iron pipe, for that joint to leak. Cast iron pipe is rough on the outside and doesn't seal as well against a rubber boot on the roof - often they are just sealed with roofing tar - which dries out and cracks. Look for daylight around where the pipe goes through the roof.

A short-term fix is roofing tar if it's leaking. A longer term fix is to cut the cast iron pipe in the attic and use PVC pipe (very smooth surface) and a new rubber boot on the roof. Join the PVC with the cast iron pipe using a Fernco fitting. Be aware that cast iron is VERY heavy.
0
Related Discussions
Moisture Issues In Master Bathroom
Q
Comments (4)
Let me preface this by saying I am by no means an expert, I just know from experience and things I have read. Yes, you really must have an exhaust fan. There are also probably other moisture problems you can't see due to there being no fan - but for your sake hopefully nothing major. It definitely should vent outside the house - you either have to cut a hole in the gable of your house or through the roof, or, if you must, in the soffit. Venting though the roof I *think* is the best way, but also the most difficult to do correctly. They make all the pieces for whatever you need depending on where the vent will be. We have one in my house that had to be vented to the soffit, and we have a little circular grill/vent cap that only opens when air comes out of it. I'll link a similar product. As for who should do it - if you're handy you could probably DIY (I believe there is a video on how to do the gable version on this old house), otherwise probably a roofing/attic insulation type contractor would be good. Here is a link that might be useful: Bath Fan Soffit/Undereve vent
...See More
Venting Issue???
Q
Comments (1)
You definitely have inadequate venting. Under the International Residential code are structures are required to have one "Main Vent" which must run undiminished in size from the main drain through the roof. After that any additional auxillary vents may be reduced to 1/2 the diameter of the line they serve but in no case may a vent be less than 1-1/4" The code minimum diameter for a watercloset drain is 3" and a drain line may not be reduced in diameter in the direction of flow so it would stand that the minimum main vent size would be 3". Under the Uniform Plumbing code all vents may be reduced to 1/2 the diameter of the line it serves providing the sum aggregate total cross sectional area of all vents is equal to or greater than the cross sectional area of the main drain. In this case the total cross sectional area of all vents must be equal to or greater than the cross sectional area of a 3" line (7sq.in). The size and placement of vents is the most critical aspect of the entire DWV(drain,waste & vent) system. The maximum allowable lengths of the fixture arms from trap to vent are very carefully regulated by code therefore indescriminately placing or increasing the size of a vent may not resolve the problem.
...See More
What might cause moisture inside walls?
Q
Comments (9)
We saw the problem (with the wet insulation) in two places -- one in a wall on the east side and one on the west side of the house (the roof slants towards these two sides). Both are places that we know get a lot of rain hits (one is where water falling off a porch roof hits the side of the house, the other is at a place where the house has sort of an "L" shape, so water splashes off one side of the L and hits the rotted side). The north side of the house has very wet and slightly rotted clapboards (even the trim is rotted), but we haven't dug in enough yet to check out the insulation. The painter is planning to check the rest of the walls tomorrow, so I can hopefully give some more information then. From what I can tell, the south side of the house is comparatively fine. The paint peeled less on that side as well (although it did peel some). There are pipes in one of the two problem walls, but not the other. I have to admit that I don't know what the moisture barrier would look like. There's some sort of clear plastic up against the sheet rock (inside the insulation), there's also something on the outside that looks like black woven fabric with a silver paper-like surface (the silver side is towards the outside of the house). I doubt we have too much insulation - we've done some work in other parts of the house and the insulation seemed correct for the age of the house (built in 1987), although it's a bit short of current standards. We keep the house really cold in the winter - generally 60 degrees - and we don't have AC or central air, so the summer temperatures are about the same as outside.
...See More
Adding kitchen vent hood caused my upstairs bathroom pipes to freeze
Q
Comments (2)
Blame it on the contractor, not the pipes themselves. In a cold climate, the exhaust vent pipes of any vent like the bath vent or kitchen vent should ALWAYS be insulated. Otherwise, when the moist warm air hits the smooth cool metal (and it should be rigid metal, not flex duct)you will get condensation, just like your iced tea glass in summer. You also need to check for moisture issues in and around the ducts since he didn't insulate. Running the vent may aggravate any moisture issues. It might be better to just let the taps run a bit to keep them from freezing. Believe it or not, we're having to do that down here well below the Mason Dixon. 9° this morning down in the holler.
...See More
brickeyee
12 years ago
"Cast iron pipe is rough on the outside and doesn't seal as well against a rubber boot on the roof - often they are just sealed with roofing tar - which dries out and cracks. Look for daylight around where the pipe goes through the roof.

A short-term fix is roofing tar if it's leaking. A longer term fix is to cut the cast iron pipe in the attic and use PVC pipe (very smooth surface) and a new rubber boot on the roof. Join the PVC with the cast iron pipe using a Fernco fitting. Be aware that cast iron is VERY heavy. "

Or have an actual lead boot installed correctly.
They last nearly forever, like the cast iron (especially old oakum and lead caulked cast iron).
0
clippillo.gmail.co
12 years ago
Thanks for the replies.
I'll check for a roof leak around the pipe. It had not rained in days when I had checked it and the moisture on it looked like when a pipe "sweats." We shall see. I'm going to have to go up there when it rains next time and really look if I can't come to any solid conclusions.

I think it did only have moisture down closer to the insulation, which I know someone said they didn't think was "normal." I'm wondering if there is a lot of moisture from the bathroom fan not being vented and it has made all of the insulation that soggy.....I THINK the bathroom fan was installed in between the ceiling and a solid floor up in the attic somehow (lovely, eh!?)...the solid floor has newer blown in insulation on top of it, but there is old insulation in between the ceiling & the floor. Possibly the moisture from the insulation is collecting on the pipe? I'll have to check it out in more detail this weekend and will let you know what I find. From my investigations last weekend, I did not find the bathroom fan---so in any case it is buried, whether in the new insulation or the old stuff under the flooring.

Thanks so much for the responses!

Cassie
0

Toilet vent pipe causing moisture issue?

Comments (4)

bus_driver

jakethewonderdog

Related Discussions

brickeyee

clippillo.gmail.co

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US