Houzz Logo Print
alisande_gw

Have you read The Other Boleyn Girl?

18 years ago

I'm not usually drawn to historical novels, but I found this one at a thrift shop and thought I'd give it a try. I'm up to around page 40 (out of 664 pages) and like it a lot except for a couple of things.

The author needs a lesson in sentence construction. I'm shocked at how many times she uses a comma when a semi-colon or separate sentence is needed. This book was a huge best-seller. How does something like that get past the editors?

The other thing concerns historical accuracy. I assumed the book was fairly accurate, allowing for made-up conversations, etc. But after I noticed the punctuation boo-boos I checked out some of the Amazon reviews and found criticism for the author's manipulation of the facts. There are a huge number of raves, but among the less enthusiastic reviews were complaints from people who said the story as she told it was not true in several respects. There were also comments about the poor quality of her writing.

I'll keep reading as long as I'm enjoying the book, but I'm disappointed that I'm not going to learn as much about British history as I'd thought.

Have you read the book? What do you think?

Susan

Comments (6)