SW Harmony vs BM Aura vs Mythic paint...
catlince
12 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (16)
Kati
12 years agocatlince
12 years agoRelated Discussions
Pittsburgh Pure Performance vs. SW Harmony
Comments (6)Truly, I don't spec BenM because it's not uber convenient for me. That's the only reason. Sure would if I could. I could walk to the ICI store from my house if wanted to and I adore the full spectrum paints from Ellen Kennon which are mixed via ICI. The Pittsburgh Paints store is right down the street from the Design Market Place where I rent space. In Ohio there's a Sherwin Williams store on just about every street corner (well it feels like it any way) and I have a lovely, brand new ACE hardware that carries the ACE Paint brand, Cabinet Coat, Pratt & Lambert and Ralph Lauren. I like spec'ing a mix of all different brands. Keeps me from getting bored, love a lively diverse network of people too and I think the mix lends each project I do some individuality in some way which may only be noticeable to me. But that matters. :-) Waiting for the BenM resource that is within a reasonable distance to me to offer Aura, at least I hope they will. Would love the opportunity to try it. As of now, I just don't have a reason to make a special trip to the BenM store because I have so many other wonderful options that I just happen to like more....See MoreAura vs Ellen Kennon ICI paints (cross post)
Comments (5)Hunzi, I've spec'd and painted with Aura and ICI mixed FS a lot. Rarely do I spec or use anything but those two. I like ICI's LifeMaster in eggshell. It, IMO, has a comparable *hand* to Aura Matte. ICI's Velvet Sheen and LifeMaster are similar to SW's Super Paint in that just about anyone can paint with them and end up successful -- they are very DIY friendly. Can't say that about Aura. It takes a certain knack and many DIYers (and painters) have to rethink and then adjust how they brush and roll the paint. There are several threads about that on here already. When it comes to color, there is nothing like full spectrum. Nothing. FS is an age old topic around here. Full spectrum mixed in Aura paint would indeed be it-on-a-stick and then some. Don't see that happening any time soon. :-D Affinity is the name of the color palette designed to go with the Aura paint. There are 22 colorants. Having had a handful of *regular* colors mixed in Aura I can say that 22 colorants does give the mixer person a better shot at getting a good match, but 22 colorants in the wrong hands can be about 20 colorants too many. As we all know from the years and years of full spectrum color discussions, it's as much about how all those colorants are balanced and mixed together as it is about the actual number used. Once you gets passed the basic spectral seven, one has to question what is necessary -- if ya need more representation in a color than the basic seven, maybe it's time to revisit color mixing philosophy and/or skills... or, maybe not. IMO, more is not always better. Which leads me to my critique of Affinity colors. They are rich, they are complex, they are pretty, they can have an edge of deadness and a feel of limited dimension. They are not full spectrum color. Having *regular* color mixed via Affinity processes can leave you with a can of paint that looks *puddled* with colorant, overworked, overdone. Totally depends on the color. Restraint with all that color power at one's fingertips is paramount. Doubtful that there are too many other people on the planet who would share that opinion with me. A lot of people really want Aura to be it-on-a-stick, all that and a bag o'chips in its own right. I think it's great stuff, lots of positives, but it does not hold all the allure and wonder of color to be had in the universe. Just like every other brand, it has pluses and minuses. At the end of the day, having to make the decision between Aura paint and full spectrum color is a pretty darn great place to be!...See MoreBM vs. BEHR paints . . . (cross-post)
Comments (7)Isn't that what they mean when they say primer and paint in one? That you will get good coverage (opacity) in two coats of finish paint without needing to cover the old paint first with a base coat of "primer?" Good question snooks. But not necessarily. It's splitting hairs with a spin. Isn't that the best kind of marketing? lol! :) There are colors in Behr's palette that won't cover in one coat. Once you get into the deeper, darker colors that use the more shear or transparent Behr colorants, you're looking at needing a tinted primer. If no tinted primer, then you'll need to do more than two coats to develop the color. So, it's not about the color *so much* with Behr's claim of paint and primer in one. It's more about slightly amped up sealing performance properties. Which, like I said before, many top tier brands have and continue to offer the same thing. If you notice BenM doesn't claim paint and primer in one. In my estimation that's because BenM's focus is on their Gennex colorants and how they cover in one coat; most all Aura Affinity Collection colors fully develop in two coats without tinted primer/undercoat. And since Aura is a top tier, one could (and I do) assume that like many other top tier paints, there is a factor of amped up sealing performance properties in in the can. In the grand scheme, a brand that offers coverage in one coat and fully developed color in two coats, even with deep/dark colors, is of more value than one that offers industry average/standard paint performance properties. As a side note, one coat coverage is not the same as fully developed color. You need to do two complete coats to hit all areas of the walls evenly and to achieve fully developed color. Depending on brand, grade, and specific color you might need to do more than two coats. But the point is just because a paint color covers in one coat doesn't mean it's okay to only do one coat. You need two for several reasons beyond what I've mentioned here. Behr is pumping up their paint's performance properties. BenM puts the focus on the colorants. Both are playing fair. It's just confusing for the consumer when it comes to prep and colors. i.e. Do I need a *real* primer or will the amped up sealing properties be enough for my project? Does the color I chose need a tinted undercoat/primer to help build opacity or will I be okay with two full coats? The best way to navigate the marketing landscape of paint and color is to always ask your paint store pro those two questions. Rise above the fray of marketing spin and don't assume anything. This post was edited by funcolors on Sat, Dec 29, 12 at 20:11...See MoreBM Advance vs. SW ProClassic
Comments (9)Christopher, does BM even sell Satin Impervo any more? They don't show it on the website. I bought some about a year ago and I had to special order it and it was only available in quarts. Maybe it is still available in other places besides Cali ... ? Their new Advance line specs say that it won't yellow as quickly as oil based, but the Impervo said non-yellowing. I don't know why they discontinued the non-yellowing Impervo for a paint that could yellow in the future....See Morecatlince
12 years agoajpace
12 years agoLori A. Sawaya
12 years agonostalgicfarm
12 years agopaintguy1
12 years agoajpace
12 years agojessicaml
12 years agojessicaml
12 years agoLori A. Sawaya
12 years agoKati
12 years agoajpace
12 years agoLori A. Sawaya
12 years agoBespoke Decorative Finishes
8 years ago
Related Stories
COLORHow to Layer Tones of Gray for Depth and Harmony
Use texture, pattern, contrast and more to create a subtle, sophisticated look with this popular color
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDESGet the Scoop on Finding the Best Paint for Your Money
Scoring the best deal on paint for your home may have nothing to do with advertised specials
Full StoryMOST POPULARThe Right Way to Test Paint Colors
Here are 5 key steps to take to ensure you're happy with your wall paint color
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDESEasy Green: 5 Ecofriendly Paint Companies
Dizzy spells and headaches, begone. Be kinder to your health and the environment with these safer paint choices for your interior decorating
Full StoryTRIMWhat Color Should You Paint Your Trim?
Learn the benefits of painting your trim white, black, neutral, a bold color and more
Full StoryCOLORPick-a-Paint Help: How to Create a Whole-House Color Palette
Don't be daunted. With these strategies, building a cohesive palette for your entire home is less difficult than it seems
Full StoryHouzz Call: Show Us Your Paint Makeovers
Let your newly repainted house or room do the "How d'ya like me now?" strut right here — it might just be featured in an upcoming ideabook
Full StoryPAINTINGBulletproof Decorating: How to Pick the Right Kind of Paint
Choose a paint with some heft and a little sheen for walls and ceilings with long-lasting good looks. Here are some getting-started tips
Full StoryHEALTHY HOMENontoxic Paint 101
If 'VOC' sounds like gobbledygook and you have no clue what causes that funny smell, check out this primer on ecofriendly paint types
Full StoryWHITEHow to Pick the Right White Paint
White is white, right? Not quite. See 8 white paint picks for 8 very different effects
Full Story
ajpace