Wood floor first or base cabs first??

13 years ago

I am our GC now (lucky me) and I'm clueless about construction. I'm getting conflicting info on what comes first--wood floor or base cabs. We will be putting new, site-built oak floors down throughout the main part of the house shown here, including the kitchen. Here's the general floorplan to give you an idea. (Fridge and ovens have swapped places. Furniture won't be like that. Windows and upper cabs have changed slightly, but ignore those parts.)

From a post many, many months ago I remember reading that floors should come first. I think that's my preference, but don't really know enough to understand the pros and cons. What should be installed first?

Featured Answer

mikomum

13 years ago

It really is the whole chicken/egg story all over again. When you say site built, do you mean site sanded and finished?

When I sold hardwood, *we* preferred to go in after cabinets but before toekicks. This was mainly to protect the floor from the cabinets getting installed. In new home builds it was usually careless trades coming in after us that damaged the floors.

Floors first, pros;

--you can change base cabinets easier at a later date

--the cabinets won't get dinged by the flooring install (and finishing equipment in site finished floors)

--you don't have to deal with the sanding dust in your new cupboards (site finished)

cons;

--the floor is likely to get some damage with cabinet installation. You can do the final site finishing after the cabinets to hedge your bets.

--you're using extra square footage of wood

--you can't easily change your mind on the floor after the cabinets are in

things to consider:

if you install your cupboards first and run the hardwood just under the toekicks, you'll need to remember the 3/4" thickness of the wood when installing your cabinets.

some people install their base and wall cabinets, do hardwood and THEN install the island. With small/midsized non-plumbed islands you can just lift and move them slightly to install underneath *if* you don't have multiple electrical coming up form the floor.

HTH!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

brianadarnell
13 years ago
Breezy- One HUGE pro of doing the floors first is that when/if a remodel occurs somewhere down the road, the layout won't matter as much because you will have the wood floors everywhere. They may not match exactly because of fading, scratching, etc. but they will be way closer than trying to find a matching wood to blend with the older floors. This could also apply if something happens with an appliance and it needs switched out. Just a thought...
breezygirl
Original Author
13 years ago
Very, very good point. That had crossed my mind at one time. To me, that falls under the category of "doing it right the first time." I've seen many folks here trying to reno that have that exact problem. Thanks.
Related Discussions
tile floor first or cabinets first?
Q
Comments (10)
We pondered this question a lot because I wasn't sure I really liked the flooring I picked and thought replacing it a couple of years down the road was a real possibility. I was concerned about not having the floor under the cabs at the same height for all the reasons mentioned above. I didn't want to put plywood under the DW for fear of what would happen in the case of a leak. Still, the prospect of wanting to replace the tile down the road really concerned me. Then, a friend told me about her experience retiling their entire family room, dining area, and kitchen. They had a crack develop in their foundation that resulted in many cracked tiles. Once the slab was repaired, they were ready to replace the cracked ones. Unfortunately, the old tile had been discontinued, so they couldn't find any to match. But, she explained how easy it was to score the tiles that went under the cabs and remove the exposed part. They installed the new ones butted up next to the original ones right at the toe kicks, and you can't tell at all. So, she now has the old tile under her cabs, but who cares? She saved enough of the new tiles so that if she ever wants to change the footprint of her kitchen, she'll have that option. Now that I've lived with my floor for awhile, I know I won't be changing it any time soon. I'm glad I have it under my cabs.
...See More
Floor first or toe kick first?
Q
Comments (7)
No, I would put the toe kick in after the floor. The floor will expand and contract leaving a gap or worse buckling if it is placed right against the toe kick. The floor should be run up to your cabinets (technically under the cabinets, but that is not possible) with a small gap for expansion. Then you place the toe kick in. If the cabinets are raised to the same hight of the floor there should be no reason to rip them down.
...See More
Sagging Wood Floor on first floor.
Q
Comments (19)
Transnationalq- we are removing the load bearing wall on the parlor floor to have a large living/dining/kitchen space (open floorplan, for shame!) and are using a series of posts hidden in a powder room and pantry wall, plus one exposed post. Our townhouse is 21' wide, which is too wide to span without the posts. If your rooms are not as wide, you may be able to just use steel footed in the front and back. The other two floors will have posts in the same locations but hidden in bedroom walls (the current load-bearing wall is actually being completely removed, posts added top to bottom and then the walls will be built back in a slightly different space to make for wider hallways.) Our project is a complete gut plus an extension, so the whole thing is costing a fortune but the steel is not a small portion of the project. We likely could have gotten away without steel at all if our span was only 16' or less, but alas...the wide house needs the beam and the concrete footings. I don't have any pics that actually show the sagging in any capacity, but my profile picture shows the stairs which you can sort of see are pitched to the right (towards the center of the house.) We lived in the house with the current state of the floors (stadium seating) and it wasnt the worst, but it was pretty obvious in some rooms. On our top floor, the corner of one room where the rear facade is was about 2 inches higher than the middle of the room. Can't see it in pictures, but it was a very strong slope.
...See More
Kitchen: Gray cement floor w/ wood cabs or wood floor w/ blk cabs? Or?
Q
Comments (6)
Thinking on this but my first thought is not to do black cabinets. And, don't worry about "floor fatigue" so much. It's not like you'll be standing for hours in a kitchen like a restaurant chef. I have porcelain wood look tile and I don't notice the "fatigue" of a hard floor. It always looks best to have the flooring the same throughout so nix the idea of changing the flooring from the living space/kitchen space. The floor plan you show is too small to see details. I'm thinking if you are going concrete floor, mix the cabinets with natural wood look and a light counter...maybe a white quartz.
...See More
brianadarnell
13 years ago
Our close friends are doing a complete gut job on their kitchen but leaving the floors the same. They are stuck with a peninsula coming off the wall at a 45 degree angle due to the floor running up to but not under the current cabinets...good luck with being your own GC. sounds like you are almost done...
macybaby
13 years ago
The main downside to putting the floor down first is potenital damage when the cabinest are installed and extra cost for material you don't see.

Even if you don't put it under the cabs, you shuold put something under the cabs to bring the bottoms up to the level of the final floor - you have to be careful that you don't end up with a "drop" where your dishwasher will go, and you have to make sure that the opening will still be tall enough if the cabinet bases are lower than the finished floor height.

Depending on the style of base (mine has feet in front to look more like furniture) setting the cabs first could cause major problems.

Personally - I'd put the floor in first.
mountaineergirl
13 years ago
Our wood floors were site finished BEFORE cabinet install and there was no damage to the floors. I think if the guys are careful and put something down to protect the floors where they walk/etc it'll be fine. But also, the floor guy waited until after the cabs/appliances were installed to come in and do a final 3rd coat of poly, which would've covered any minor damage.
artemis78
13 years ago
If you are site finishing, I would lay the floors unfinished and sand first, then install cabinets, then final finishing (and spot sanding if needed) of floors. That way, floors are under cabinets (and I am a big fan of this for all the reasons outlined above) but you don't have to stress if they get a nick here or there because they will get finished afterwards. We did our floors first and the cabinet guys covered them very carefully---our only scratches were from appliances, which would have come after the floors no matter what.
formerlyflorantha
13 years ago
If you're doing your own floor, it's much easier to sand and finish the floor if it's a wide expanse. More likelihood to gouge with sander or make an uneven finish if you're working around installed cabs...and the floor will take longer to work on because you're constantly working with different light, different angles, different different different.
Stacey Collins
13 years ago
Put the floors in first, then when they're totally cured, cover with several layers of rosin paper (red stuff in rolls at the Home Center or lumberyard) with the seams taped and taped to wall edges. That will prevent grit and screws and stuff getting underneath, which would scratch the floors. If something happens during the kitchen construction phase, like a spill which wets/damages the paper, or a tear, simply cut out and patch that are, sealing it with tape again.

This has always worked well for us :)

Best wishes from a fellow CG!
kngwd
13 years ago
Our cabinet guy told us we could do either, but as someone already said you have to take into account the height of the flooring if you do flooring later. We are DIY'ing prefinished hardwood, so we have decided to spend the little extra and put the floor in first and go under the cabinets before they are installed.
kittenkat_2002
13 years ago
We did the same thing as mountaineergirl. Floors were installed with two coats of poly, base cabinets and island were installed and then the third coat was applied. The only problem that we're running into is that a few floor boards that were patched in with the existing floors are having issues and need to be replaced. Not sure how our flooring installer is going to accomplish that. Anyway, I'd still put the floors under the cabinets.

Here is a link that might be useful: My Blog
breezygirl
Original Author
13 years ago
bumping this up for Clueless_in_pgh.

And I never came back to thank everyone for their responses. Bad Breezy.

Thank you everyone. I'm definetly doing hardwood FIRST!

Wood floor first or base cabs first??

mikomum

Comments (12)

brianadarnell

breezygirl
Original Author

Related Discussions

brianadarnell

macybaby

mountaineergirl

artemis78

formerlyflorantha

Stacey Collins

kngwd

kittenkat_2002

breezygirl
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Wood floor first or base cabs first??

Comments (12)

breezygirlOriginal Author

Related Discussions

breezygirlOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

breezygirl
Original Author

breezygirl
Original Author