My favorite tonight (I can't remember her name) but she's the one Simon said it looked like her grandmother dressed her. lololol

I hope Amanda goes home tomorrow. I thought she was truly awful.

I was surprised that the judges liked Brooke so much too, it did sound off key to me as well. I thought Carly did the best too, and I do like Ramielle (sp) even though her song wasn't all that special. Amanda can go home anytime.

I actually enjoyed the guys more last night than I did the girls tonight.

I agree, Amanda was horrible too.

Brooke changed my mind about her tonight. Hope she redeems herself next week, but don't doubt she is one to go home. She just doesn't have enough umph! and she didn't do well tonight. I still think she has a lot of potential for that Carly Simon genre, but we aren't the major voters.

Well, we didn't have to like her kind of music, but I did enjoy that she was true to herself. Tonight, however, Amanda showed us she cannot sing a lick. Finally a song she didn't have to yell and grind every word, and we see there is no singing voice in there at all.

I keep saying Carly is the best of all the girls, but it's so funny to me how she does not have an edge over them. They are more personality, or more dynamics, or more appealing when they sing. Can't put my finger on it except to say she doesn't shine like some of the others who don't sing as well.

Asia'h was stunning tonight........then screwed up her song. I think she needs that adenoid (sp?) surgery. She's so extremely nasal and so is Alexandrea, but she really rocked "Baby, Please Don't Go."

Ramiele is my little sweetheart. She's gonna win.

I like so many of them. But I think Ramiele is my favorite. She didn't do that great tonight, though.

Amanda - that is the 'rock star' one, right? - gosh her hair was just awful! It, plus all the heavy make-up, etc. make her look about 45 or 50. When they showed her parents in the audience, they looked younger than she did! Paula was right in saying that she looks so much fresher and better in her candid film clip than she does on stage. Too costumey... And her song... blah.

But all of them (nearly all!) this year are so talented. It is going to be extremely hard to narrow it down to one winner.

Here is a link that might be useful: My blog-The Bee Hive

Amanda is on right now here....she is terrible! Looks like the bride of Frankenstein. She really can leave and hurt nothing. I think she's trying way too hard to portray herself as the "rocker chick". She was off tune alot tonight.

I agree about Amanda. She was actually scary looking last night. Could you imagine her being your nurse and walking into your room?

I really like Brooke. Her Carly SImon song to me was great.

The two that I would like to see voted off are Amanda and of the guys Danny. He butchered the Karen Carpenter song on Tuesday.

SamKaren
your resident DJ

My favorite was Kristy Lee. I hope she goes country.

I still like, and most don't is Amanda.
And she was horrible tonight.
I hope she finds herself. I like her voice.

The girls couldn't hold my attention. The great thing about 70's music is that the original singers really could sing and hit the right notes. The Idol contestents just aren't that good.

My fav thus far is Carlie, then Brook, then Kristy. It's only been 2 weeks-these 3 hopefully will "blossom into awesome", by week 6!!!

adella, I agree I just can't pay attention to the girls..I'll watch the boys start to finish..the girls...well I didn't sit down until Idol #7, and those last three weren't worth it!