Kitchen lighting question - URGENT!

15 years ago

I need to make a decision this week, so please help me. I am in the process of getting lighting for my kitchen. Its 20"x7", and the island will have pendants, which are not expected to be a prominent source of light. At this point I don't have many options for ceiling fixtures - I could either do track lights or wire mould with surface fixtures. Do track lights give enough lighting? I have always used surface fixtures, and am nervous about using tracks as main source of lighting in the kitchen. How many lights should I have?

My contractor says that track should be fine, but I am not sure.

For under-cabinet, I am confused between LED and Xenon. My countertop is flashy so I want one that will bring out the best in the counter.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

David
15 years ago
I used a 35 lumen per sq foot guideline for the kitchen. The number of lights you need depends on the output per light, type of light.

For under cabinet, xenon will give off more heat than LED. I'd recommend LED.
0
texaskitchentoo
15 years ago
While LED certainly consumes less power it has other drawbacks. Many are not dimmable, but they may have pre-set power levels (hi, lo, off). Like CFL's the tend to put out whitish/blueish light. Even the warm light versions are not what you are used to with incandescent and the warm light LEDs put out less light. Bare LEDs are very bright as point sources, if you have dark granite you are going to get reflections in the countertops. If you have a sample of your granite I'd take it with you when you shop for lights. If you spend a ton on a nice multi-color granite and then wash it out with 'blue' LED lights you may not like the results.

I'm struggling too between LED and Xenon. I like the light qualities of Xenon but want the efficiency of lED. I just think LED is not quite there yet. Maybe in another year or two the quality of light and price will be better. Meanwhile I need lights now. I may go with 12v Xenon for now and see if I can 'upgrade' in a few years to LED. I found the mini track lighting from Juno. It runs on 12v (or 24v) and they have both Xenon and LED fixtures which can be placed anywhere on the track. The problem is to convert from Xenon to LED may need a different dimmer or transformer. If the wiring is no different than I can handle that. Once the backsplash goes up I don't want to be changing the wiring! I'm still reseaching exactly what I'd need to install this and later upgrade to better LED fixtures. But this is looking promising and while I have the old backsplash torn out it makes wiring much easier.

Other companies sell this type of lighting normally called linear lighting. The other advantage is that you can put fixtures anywhere along the track as long as you don't exceed the power or min spacing limits.

Here is a link that might be useful: Juno Trac 12
0
Related Discussions
Urgent question re: pinching back leaves on seedlings
Q
Comments (1)
I would not pinch back plants that small. The lights need to be 2-3 inches above the tops of the plants. Here is one way to do that with different sized plants. Yes, when you re-pot you should plant them to just below the lower leaves john
...See More
Urgent Question: Rubber Tubing for Gas Line to Stove?
Q
Comments (9)
Under the IRC you can plumb the entire gas system with CSST if locally approved. you can also run natural gas with copper tubing providing the gas is certified to contain equal to or less than 0.3 grains of hydrogen sulfide per 100cu/ft of gas. gas lines run under a slab must be sleeved and the sleeve must be sealed on the inside end and vented to atmosphere on the outdoor end. All copper lines run under a slab must be continuous roll pipe or all joints must be "brazed". (No soldeer or mechanical joints under slab).
...See More
Pool equipment question - urgent
Q
Comments (23)
Peter- Thanks for the link to the Intelliflo technical discussion. Obviously this was an Intelliflo only discussion and only addressed low speed efficiency. Variable speed pumps with BPM motors will always use less power than a PSC motor at low speed. There is no argument here. However, variable speed at higher speeds suffers from large power consumption due to two primary power robbers 1) high current inversion of AC to DC power in the VFD, which is very inefficient and produces a lot of waste heat as a result 2) Compromised impeller design because the impeller can not operate at peak efficiency for a large gpm range so the engineers have to make a choice where they want to optimize the impeller and at the same time a choice at where the impeller will not be very efficient. In the case of Intelliflo, from their published power, TDH and gpm curves, they have optimized for low speed operation and rightly so, but this choice also causes the higher speed efficiency to be miserable. Also of note, while I agree with your warning of using FLA to estimate power consumption, I would also add that the Intelliflo curve is true power consumption in watts and not FLA. Using FLA to calculate 2 speed pump power is worst case and, to your point, will only be better in the real world which makes the 2 speed even more favorable over variable speed. Just wanted to offer a balanced view here. Variable speed has its own merits, mainly low speed efficiency and ability to tune flow to plumbing resistance for optimum performance. But, to suggest using a variable speed pump for multi-tasking, which requires higher speeds, is not doing the energy conscious homeowner any good. In the case of pools with multiple water features or in-floor cleaners which require higher flows, multiple 1 speed or 2 speed pumps that are tuned for the higher flows will always save energy over a variable speed that is trying to inefficiently cover a large operating range. jj- In your case with a floor cleaning system...the floor cleaner will have to run for about 2 hours a day to get full rotation of the heads and full cleaning. For other hours of the day, the pump can ran at low speed allowing the pump to operate easier against lower resistance providing turnover and filtering for your pool. A variable speed or a 2 speed will both provide energy efficient operation for your cleaning and filtering needs. Only you can make the decision if you want to spend the extra money for the variable speed. To help you justify the extra cost for variable speed over 2 speed, use 200 watts per hour savings over 2 speed at low speed and 1,000 watts per hour cost over 2 speed at high speed. Knowing how long you will run the pump at high and low speed will allow you to calculate how much money is saved per day with variable speed and 2 speed, helping to make your decision. Hope this helps!
...See More
URGENT Construction Question
Q
Comments (27)
Though I do think this is an excellent example of expectations and their management. The OP knew very well what their personal aesthetic and expectation was, and what "just 10" " would do to that. Sometimes, a lot. Similarly, if I were to try to do something like the picture chicagoans posted, I think it would likely involve a window on either side of the range/hood, with a glass cabinet. Now, lacking the central cabinet AND the ability to also make the far left side of the cabinet glassed in (mine would have a wall oven tower in that location) would make such an arrangement much less "airy" in feel and look. I might be in for serious disappointment if I were not to understand that, up front. (I do, and I would have some concerns about keeping all that glass clean, next to the range). One of the problem with "inspiration" photos is that you need to clearly communicate what you expect YOUR version to look like. Because "small" changes (10", no central window) can have a very big impact on the result.
...See More
Related Professionals
Arcadia Lighting · Fort Washington Lighting · Glendale Lighting · Wilmington Furniture & Accessories · Fillmore Furniture & Accessories · Fountain Furniture & Accessories · Centerville Interior Designers & Decorators · Ashland Electricians · York Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Solana Beach Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Arbutus Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Athens Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Chandler Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Fort Pierce Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Windsor Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures
footwedge
15 years ago
Texaskitchentoo, I like this idea but do you have to have the lights now? I know the cost of the xenons is minimal when compared to quality leds but why not just wire for a future install of an led system. This is what I'm thinking if I can get the DW to agree. I also plan install a low voltage recessed dimmable halogen lighting system to be upgraded to leds in the future to take care of the lighting needs.

In our kitchen, I see the uc lighting being used more for a mood setting even though I know it will be used for task duties also. I just expect newer and better led technology in the future and hopefully lower pricing.
0
tomorrowisanotherday
15 years ago
My xenons are HOT. Be aware of that if you keep food/medicines in the cabinet above a xenon fixture. The light quality is great, but I don't use them as much as I wanted to because of the excess heat. I would not install them if I had it to do over. What good will a fixture do if you don't like to use it?

I like footwedge's suggestion.
0
David
15 years ago
The backbone of any undercabinet lighting system is the wiring.

For low voltage, there is a transformer (or 2) located somewhere in a cabinet or other hidden spot(s).

Changing from 12V to 24V or 24V to 12V would entail replacing the transformer & lighting strips.

Changing from standard AC to low voltage could be more involved.
0
dancingsams
15 years ago
We are going LED. There is a lighting show in Las Vegas - Lightfair International, May 12-14, that will demo a huge amount of residential lighting. Although locals are not always up to speed, there are many manufacturers making excellent, effective LED lights right now!
0
dim4fun
15 years ago
It's difficult to wade through the exagerations and false information presented by the dozens of "me too" vendors at that show. Buyer beware. It's hard for the real technology leaders to stand out because they tend to be honest about their product's performance.
0

Kitchen lighting question - URGENT!

Comments (7)

David

texaskitchentoo

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

footwedge

tomorrowisanotherday

David

dancingsams

dim4fun

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US