SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
carlab44

New radiant heat under existing wood floors?

carlab44
15 years ago

We are in the middle of a gut and remodel and are going to be using radiant heat. Our preference is to use radiant floor heat rather than the wall units - mostly for aesthetics. The house we're remodeling was built in the 1950's (or so the county says - during the demo we found newspapers in the walls and floor from 1906) and has existing oak floors that we are hoping to refinish. However we are completely changing the floor plan so there will be some rather large areas that will be patched with new oak.

Our contractor and radiant heat guy have gone back and forth about whether they think the floor heat option is optimal. Initially the heating sub was worried about efficiency due to multiple layers of wood floor in the existing sections, but he re ran his heat calc's and thinks it will work well if he installs aluminum plates under the tubes to build-up a small heat chamber below the floor.

Now our contractor is concerned about the integrity of the wood floors. He's worried about the wood expanding and contracting, creaking, etc. and said he won't be able to warranty the floors if we go with the radiant floor option. We would much rather go with the radiant floor (especially my husband) and are not too worried about a few creaks here and there (our current house was built in 1896 and has original fir floors so we're used to creaks) but I also don't want to end up needing to replace the wood floors in a year.

Anyone have any experience or suggestions to offer?

Comments (4)