a/c & gas furnace vs heat pump with gas backup

14 years ago

I have to replace a 2.5 ton a/c & gas furnace. Heating load done =23,228 & cooling load = 27,206. 1500 sq ft ranch with small room over attached garage. I live in SE VA with relatively mild winters & sometimes hot summers.

Gas for this month was 39.97 for 14 ccf and electric is 7.32Â¢/kWh jun-sep and 6.69Â¢/kWh oct-may.

I got estimate for 2 units:

York Affinity 3 ton a/c 15 seer, 80k btu 80% modulating gas furnace. Honeywell prog t-stat, lifetime warranty on compressor & 10 yr parts & labor. i believe he said it was a 2 speed a/c which I was told would help with short cycling. I wondered if this unit may be oversized, but I was told .5 ton is not that big a deal and the 2 speed would help with short cycling. Est. $6,942

York Latitude 2.5 ton a/c 14.5 seer, 80k btu 80% single speed gas furnace. same t-stat, 10 yr warranty on compressor, 5 yr parts, 1yr labor. Est. $5,437

Then I was told by someone i know that I should look into a dual fuel system-- heat pump with gas furnace back up.

I got an estimate from another company for Amer Stand 80k btu 80% 2stage variable speed gas furnace with 36,00 btu 14 seer heat pump condenser w prog t-stat & new tubing. Est. $7,231.83.

Also, est for 80k 95% 2 stage variable speed gas furnace with 36k 14 seer a/c condenser (is this supposed to be compressor?) with new tubing. Est. $8,110.99.

Now I don't know what to do. The 2nd estimate seems way too high, but I'm not sure what would be best for me.

Sorry about the long post, but any suggestions? Pros & cons?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

ryanhughes
14 years ago
Based on the information you've provided, sounds like the York quote is the best option, but I don't agree with the 80% modulating furnace. That's a high-end furnace, and going with the 80% version doesn't make sense to me, especially in our region where it can get cold at times (I'm in Maryland). Is PVC venting an issue? The York Affinity is a nice line of equipment. American Standard isn't bad, either, but the equipment that the York rep. is quoting is better in my opinion. 3 tons is a bit much for your cooling load, but it's what you'd have to go with if you went with the Affinity line. The 2.5-ton Latitude unit would be the better fit. With the low stage on the Affinity approximately meeting the cooling load at design conditions (which won't be met on all days), I don't think you'll be getting those long run times that you should with a 2-stage system. Ask the York rep. if he can quote the CZB or YZB 2.5-ton single-stage Affinity unit with a 90+ efficient v/s furnace (modulating or 2-stage). Not sure where the American Standard rep. came up with his sizing. Do you like it cold in your house (68-70)? Did the York rep. do the load calculation?
ryanhughes
14 years ago
Also, are you sure about your heat loss (heating) value? 80k is way oversized for your heat loss if what you have is accurate.
Related Discussions
Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace: Which should I install?
Q
Comments (9)
Where milder/less mild matters is in the heating season with a heat pump. The AC functions about the same, but if it's too cold out the heat pump BTU output may not be enough to keep up. Even if you have plenty of AC capacity in the summer. I assume you're on NG and not propane. Also, $2.1 per hundred cubic feet (ccf) would be more normal. Ours in ATL is around $1/therm (therm = ccf), and it might be $2.1 once you add on the administrative costs. It might make sense, if you're already paying the overhead on your NG account, to go with a dual fuel system. The extra use spreads that admin cost further, if your system is set up to do it when it makes sense. A dual fuel system will run the HP until it can't keep up (or the controls lock it out based on outside temperature), then kick on the gas furnace as the 2nd stage. This takes advantage of running the heat pump most of the time without needing electric heating strips as backup heat. The HP will put out about 3X as much heat as the energy it uses- that's what makes it cheaper to run than a NG furnace. But the backup heat strips are 1:1 on energy to heat, which usually isn't competitive with NG. Also, I kind of like the idea of having a standard efficiency gas water heater. Offends my drive for efficiency, but as a kid on the N end of AL, the power went out enough during hurricanes, ice storms and the like that it was nice to still have hot water (and a fireplace) when that stuff happened.
...See More
AC + gas furnace vs, Heat Pump + furnace
Q
Comments (5)
All units are Bryant Furnace = 355BAV A/C = 127A Heat Pump = 226A Had to order today to take advantage of rebate offer that ends 8/31. Never could figure out how to estimate the cost of running the heat pump vs. the gas furnace and couldn't locate any on-line calculators/spreadsheets that would help. Figured I'd save a bunch with new 95% furnace over the old sigle-stage 80%, and the new 17 SEER a/c over the old single-stage 10. It's small house (1450 sf) and well insulated, and I didn't know if I'd squeeze enough additional savings with a heat pump to justify the extra initial cost of the pump plus whatever extra cost would be involved in replacing it sooner because of running it much more. When in doubt, play conservatively (at least where money is involved), so I went for the a/c unit. Wish I'd discovered this website a month earlier. Thanks to all those who responded.
...See More
Comparing Heat from HeatStrips, Gas Furnace & Heat Pump
Q
Comments (4)
Post your electric rate in cents per kw-hr, and your gas rate in either $ per ccf or $ per therm. The heat output of a gas furnace is very similar to electric resistance strips if enough kw are used. Utility costs decide which is cheaper. 5 kw electric strips put out air temps about 15F greater than room temperature. So a typical 10kw strip heat puts out 100 degree air if the room temp is 70F (70 + 30 = 100). This# is based on 1200 cfm air flow from the indoor fan. 15kw = 115F which is more in the range of gas furnace temps. The air handler must be sized to handle this heating load. These temps are for the strip heat only and do not include any btu's from the heat pump. The heat pump itself puts out air temps from about 90F to 100F based on outdoor air temps. The 90F supply temp air from the heat pump combined with 20 kw aux electric strips provides minimum 120F output air when needed. Heat pumps provide enough heat up until the balance point, which is around 32F or so based on home construction/insulation (mine is 25F). At temps lower than the balance point, aux heat is needed - either furnace or strips. The good thing with the strips is they can run along with the heat pump. The furnace cannot run when the heat pump is in heating mode; its one or the other. When the heat pump goes into defrost mode, the air output is in the low 50's. 10 kw provides 30F to temper the air into the low 80's so it doesn't feel too cold while the heat pump is defrosting. The furnace will provide 120F air during a defrost cycle. The heat pump is typically 300% efficient down to 35F ambient. Heat pumps make cheap heat. One comment about the XP-19. It's "up to 19 SEER". Not all combinations get 19 SEER. Model numbers can be used to determine actual SEER. Also, dual-compressor systems like the XP-19 are more for hot and humid summers than for heating. In the cooling mode, running on 1st stage saves $$ and reduces humidity. Once on 2nd stage, it loses its operating $$ benefits. A 14/15 SEER usually provides the best combination of purchase price and operating cost. If you can afford a "19 SEER" system, go for it. Whichever SEER you get, you want as close to 12 EER and 9 HSPF as you can get for low operating costs in cooling and heating respectively. Good luck.
...See More
Heat Pump w/gas furnace and fossil fuel kit
Q
Comments (1)
I don't have a dual fuel set up, so I can't comment whether the behavior you are seeing is expected. However it sounds like it is wasting energy. Have you asked your HVAC contractor about this? I am curious as to how the 30 degree set point was calculated. This sounds too low. Post your electricity and gas rates, and the COP value at 30 degrees. There is a calculator to see if 30 degrees is the correct set point.
...See More
liborn
Original Author
14 years ago
I don't know where the Am Stand rep got his sizing either. I know the 95% is much more efficient, but I don't think the budget will allow 8 grand.
I don't keep my t-stat that low in the summer, more like 76-78. And, yes, the York rep was the only one who gave me a printout of the load calculation.
ryanhughes
14 years ago
Tell the York rep what I said about the sizing and cycling and see what he says:

1. If the heating load isn't even 30k btu, why is the 80k furnace being quoted? The 60k would be a better match and still be oversized. I've never seen a heating load less than a cooling load--not saying it can't be possible... I'd want to make sure the calculations were correct.

2. The Affinity 15 3-ton unit is a 2-stage unit. First stage would be around 75% of the full capacity. That's 27k btu's, which is about what your load is. The load is at design conditions, which is when the temperature outside is "extreme." That means that the unit will most likely cycle a lot in low stage, removing less humidity and costing more to operate. I would bring this issue up with the dealer and see what his opinion is. The 2.5-ton 13 SEER Affinity might be the better choice.

Also, I recommend that you get the Honeywell VisionPRO IAQ thermostat and have it setup for dehumidification on demand. I also suggest the 90+ efficient furnace. Not sure why the 80% was quoted. Maybe PVC venting was an issue.
liborn
Original Author
14 years ago
He never mentioned pvc venting, but I'll ask. Do you think I should bother to ask about the dual fuel system, or just go with the a/c & furnace?
ryanhughes
14 years ago
With those electric rates, a heat pump would be economical to heat and cool. It's worth asking in my opinion. I'd be more focused on the sizing issues I've mentioned above though. Sizing is a very important factor in any installation. The good thing about the modulating furnace is its many steps of heating--1% increments from 50% to 100%. But a 80k is still oversized for your heating requirements assuming they are accurate. Double-check on the heating load with the company.

Important note: There are two York modulating furnace. One does NOT have the variable-speed blower. Make sure the one you're getting does. It can provide better dehumidification and is better with two-stage outdoor units.

I know there's a lot of info for just replacing your HVAC equipment, but getting it right saves you a lot of trouble in the long run. Just read some of the horror stories some people have had from poor installations and oversized equipment.

a/c & gas furnace vs heat pump with gas backup

Comments (6)

ryanhughes

ryanhughes

Related Discussions

liborn
Original Author

ryanhughes

liborn
Original Author

ryanhughes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

a/c & gas furnace vs heat pump with gas backup

Comments (6)

ryanhughes

ryanhughes

Related Discussions

libornOriginal Author

ryanhughes

libornOriginal Author

ryanhughes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

liborn
Original Author

liborn
Original Author