Homemade laundry soap vs. Charlies Soap?
bookert
16 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (41)
cynic
16 years agograinlady_ks
16 years agoRelated Discussions
Results using homemade powdered laundry soap
Comments (25)I have recently been using Fels Naptha as a pretreater for stains. Wet the stained area and rub the stain with a bar of Fels. Rub the resulting soapy stuff in well. Somtimes I use an old toothbrush to get it into the fabric well. Let it sit for 10 minutes before laundering. I find the "new" Fels Naptha has quite a strong perfume, so I keep the bar in a plastic container. As to it not being the same as grandmom's Fels, Stoddard Solvent is also called white spirit in other parts of the world. It is a type of naptha, which is a petroleum distillate. It's the naptha in Fels Naptha that makes it the most effective soap for removing greasy oily soils. Perhaps Dial is being more specific in naming the particular type of naptha being used in the formula. They have also highly scented the product. It no longer is "the soap with the clean naptha odor" touted in the old ads. I have used Zout for years, and loved the results. I recently ran out of my original formula Zout. It was very lightly scented. The Zout I replaced it with is still effective, but I object to the way it perfumes my clothes, hence the switch to Fels....See MoreDo I have to use Charlie's Soap with every load?
Comments (17)You do what is right for you. I'm a CS fan myself, but what works for me may not work for someone else. On top of that, when I switched to CS I still had other detergent here I was trying. I'm not about to let the other stuff I had prior to the CS go to waste no matter how much I like the CS. To do so would be wasteful. I just figured out a way to incorporate different things into different loads and use the CS exclusively on my lil ones clothing and the hubs uniforms right now. When I first got my HE washer, I got some Cheer HE to try it since the HE's were suppose to rinse better I figured the scent may not hurt. Everything seemed to be okay for a while. Then I got some Tide Free HE to help another poster as they were having a suds prob and wanted to see if it was the detergent. Found out it was as that stuff sudses a lot in certain machines. Then I got some ALL FC HE to see if that would do the same thing. It didn't suds as much and rinsed out much better, but it didn't get all the stains out either. Now to use them up, I use the Tide Free HE on my and my hubs clothing because I can use an unscented fabric softener to cut the suds. I put a cap of the Cheer into a spray bottle with water to use as a pretreater on our clothes as the Tide washes out the Cheers perfume. I use the All FC on all of our bedding as they do not get stained. Like I said earlier, I use the CS on my lil ones clothes and hubs uniforms. As I use up all of my old detergent, other things will get switched to the CS. CS was just the over all right thing for me as: I can't use scented things on mine and my kids clothing for very long, I can't use fabric softener on my kids clothing, Tide Free HE was leaving behind too many suds because of the way my washer works (very little water) and cutting it back too much didn't get my clothes clean, and the All FC wasn't getting all of the muck out of the kids clothes. As you can see, I have special needs for a detergent anyway. CS just fit the bill in my situation. On top of that, CS does work slower than many commercial detergents so pretreating and presoaking are definitely a requirement here for me, but I use to do that before anyway so it wasn't that much of a switch. I can see where many would not like the CS for that reason alone and do not begrudge them for it. Also, the CS does have to be orderd online as it is not carried in many stores in many areas. Depending on where you live, it may very well be more expensive than what a person could find at the store. For me the CS happens to work out cheaper per load even with the multi purpose pretreater. I'm a big advocate of finding what thing or things work for you. If you want to use more than the Charies go right ahead. You have to do what is right for you. There is nothing wrong with that. You may end up not liking the CS at all, so it would be good to have other things on hand. If that ends up being the case, use up the CS by cleaning out your machine with it occasionally or mopping your floors with a little or whatever you can think of. At least, in the long run, you will be happy with the results of whatever you do and that is what matters the most. : D...See MoreResearch: Samsung 448, Charlies soap, Seventh Generation, Vinegar
Comments (6)I had already written on another thread that I just purchased the Samsung 328 so I'll paste some of that here: *********************************************************** A little over 5 years ago I bought an LG WM2277HW - and now it's kaput. The maintanence history was not extraordinary - the motor had to be replaced shortly after the manufacturer's warranty ran out, but to LG's credit it was replaced without charge. I noticed that the new LG's have a 10 year warranty on the motor (guess I wasn't the only one with a motor problem) But now my LG has blown electronics and bearings, estimated $1,000 to repair. In a matter of two days I've purchased a Samsung WF328AAW. It's a little bigger than my LG with a few other snazzy upgrades pertaining to Samsung. ($750 from Best Buy using a price match from Frys sale). The LGs still looked good but I just could not bring myself to buy another LG because my old one should have lasted longer. I figure the Samsung and LG are comperable, I just decided to give my business to Samsung this time. I most definitely prefer a FL because I like to wash bulky things like comforters, stuffed animals, throw rugs, sleeping bags, etc. My daughter has many household allergies so I like to wash all that stuff regularly and I used the extra-hot sanitary cycle on anything that could handle the heat (supposedly kills dust mites). I probably use the extra-hot sanitary cycle every-other-day and believe that that is why I've never had a problem with mildue/mold I need the onboard heater. I also liked the hand wash cycle on the LG, unfortunately the Samsung I bought doesn't have that cycle. I plan to keep the LG dryer - I don't care if the washer and dryer don't match, they're in the garage. The Samsung washer is scheduled for deliver on Monday - it will take me a couple days to catch up the laundry, when I get a good feel for the washer I will post my experience. ********************************************************** Houserookie - your model is fancier than mine: bigger capacity, steam, and more washing options. I had the salesperson put in the delivery order to be sure to leave the machine in the box and DO NOT remove the shipping bolts until the machine is almost in place. The salesperson said that the delivery guys already know that but I had her add it anyway. I really liked my LG, but it should have lasted longer. After reading this forum I'm beginning to wonder if I was using way too much detergent and I am to blame for its demise - I'm a little compulsive about cleaning products - I always put in the amount written on the pachage and maybe a little more. Then I read on this forum about people using one or two tablespoons detergent. This time I'll try to control myself and not over-do it. I used various HE detergents over the 5 years, they all seemed fine EXCEPT the Costco Kirkland liquid HE. That's when the LG motor broke down. Now I stay away from generic brands. Not long after that I noticed that Costco didn't carry it anymore. Maybe I'll try Charlie's soap. I've got a mountain of laundry building up for the delivery. Hope there isn't much of a learning curve....See MoreSave Money With Homemade Laundry Soap
Comments (10)It's doable and the right blend would not gunk up your washer. Fels and Zote would because they are blended to be skin safe. The basis of many detergents is indeed a soap. Sodium coco anything is saponified coconut oil. It's oil reacted with sodium hydroxide lye. That's soap. Washing soda and citric acid = sodium citrate. D limonene ($3 a liter) heavy duty degreaser (orange essential oil is 90% d limonene) often listed as citrus extract. Zeolites and sodium silicate - crystal cat litter ground fine or some of the eco friendly tsp. Add a bit of grapeseed extract for antioxidant properties. Just made a batch of Biokleen powder :). The DIY crowd just needs to think bigger. Edited : left out a few ingredients :) Sodium sulfate is a cheap filler. It does nothing. It's only real use is as a laxative as it binds so well with water. Laureth 7 - secondary surfactant. It makes bubbles but doesn't actually clean anything. It's there so you see bubbles and are happy. Cellulose gum is listed as a chelator. It's a thickener, a starch. Used to thicken liquid soaps and foods. More filler basically unless your water is too thin.......See Morebookert
16 years agograinlady_ks
16 years agobookert
16 years agograinlady_ks
16 years agobryansda
16 years agobookert
16 years agocjtinkle
16 years agobookert
16 years agograinlady_ks
16 years agocynic
16 years agobryansda
16 years agobookert
16 years agophillygrl
16 years agobookert
16 years agobookert
16 years agograinlady_ks
16 years agophillygrl
16 years agobookert
16 years agophillygrl
16 years agobookert
16 years agophillygrl
16 years agocharliesoap
16 years agojrdown
16 years agocharliesoap
16 years agojrdown
16 years agosshrivastava
16 years agoUser
16 years agoreeree_natural
16 years agosshrivastava
15 years agocatkin
15 years agomyclementine
15 years agophillygrl
15 years agorosabearr
15 years agomyclementine
15 years agophillygrl
15 years agorosabearr
15 years agorosabearr
15 years agosshrivastava
13 years ago
Related Stories
BATHROOM VANITIESBetter Places to Stash That Soap
Banish gloppy bars and flimsy pumps, and the only things you’ll need to clean are your hands
Full StoryLAUNDRY ROOMS8 Tips for Cleaner, Greener Laundry
Let go of harsh chemicals and hot water, and go easy on your clothes, your wallet and the planet
Full StoryMOST POPULAR10 Smart Ideas for Your Laundry Room Remodel
Make washing and drying easier and more comfortable by considering ergonomics, storage and special features
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESContractor Tips: Advice for Laundry Room Design
Thinking ahead when installing or moving a washer and dryer can prevent frustration and damage down the road
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPINGWhen You Need Real Housekeeping Help
Which is scarier, Lifetime's 'Devious Maids' show or that area behind the toilet? If the toilet wins, you'll need these tips
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDES8 Reasons to Jump Off the DIY Bandwagon
You heard right. Stop beating yourself up for not making stuff yourself, and start seeing the bright side of buying from others
Full StoryEARTH DAYGrow a Beautiful Garden With Ecofriendly Greywater
Reducing home water waste means lower bills and a healthier planet. Here's how to set up a greywater home irrigation system that can help
Full StoryFEEL-GOOD HOMERegain Calm With a New Weekly Routine
Having a day-by-day housekeeping schedule makes the chores a lot more manageable
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPINGHow to Clean Hardwood Floors
Gleaming wood floors are a thing of beauty. Find out how to keep them that way
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPING4 Secrets to a Shiny-Clean Bathtub
Learn how to get your bathtub sparkling clean and keep it that way
Full StoryColumbus Area's Luxury Design Build Firm | 17x Best of Houzz Winner!
bookertOriginal Author