SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
macece

Bedroom set: Solid wood vs. Veneer.

macece
9 years ago

We are shopping for a bedroom set. What we looking for are simple style, good quality (durability) and reasonable price. By reasonable I mean not overpriced for the product. The budget itself is flexible.

My wife is a huge fan of solid wood furniture and she hates any kind veneers. But as you can imagine, it's pretty hard to buy pure solid wood furniture these days. 90% (if not more) of products on the market have more or less veneers. This is even harder for us since we live on the west coast (most furniture stores are on the east coast?)

When we shopped for the dinning set, we went to a lot of local furniture stores and got really upset. Most sets are using veneers. Some imported sets are made of inferior wood (e.g. rubberwood, which I am not a fan of). The real made-in-USA cherry/maple sets are super overpriced (e.g. http://www.mckinnonfurniture.com/bedroom/bungalow/beds.htm , well this is a bed :). We then started to search online and finally bought a hard-maple set through an Amish furniture online store. It turned out to be pretty good! We really love the set. To give you an idea about what kind of simple furniture I am look at: see

http://assets.dutchcrafters.com/product_images/pid_47218-Amish-Logan-Chair--1140.jpg

Now we are in the market for a bedroom set. We have the same standard: simple style, durable and reasonable price. For me, I can accept veneer as long as it's good quality. But I don't really like MDF (engineered wood). I always feel MDF could swell or break and contains chemicals. But that could just be my bias. The funny thing is, I went to Ethan Ellen and ThomasVille stores, and the salesperson doesn't know exactly what the beds are made of (what kind of wood, where veneers are used, etc). For most other stores, they don't talk about material in detail either.

So we turn to online stores again. Here are some sets I am currently interested in:

1, Vaughan-bassett simply cherry collection:
http://www.bedroomfurniturediscounts.com/vaughan-bassett-appalachian-hardwood-simply-cherry-mansion-panel-bedroom-set-in-light-cherry.html#59279
Currently this is our top choice. But we really have no idea about the quality. See questions below.

2, Universal midland park bed at Costco: http://costcocouple.com/universal-midland-park-bed The nice thing about Costco is that you can pick it up locally. And don't need to worry about customer service. But this uses some veneer.

3, Amish online store, e.g. http://www.onlineamishfurniture.com/Shaker-Beds_c_135.html, or simply Amish. One problem with online Amish furnitures is that their product pictures are horrible. You have to use your own imagination to figure out what the end product will look like in your home :) Also, shipping will be costly.

Here are my questions.
1, I heard a lot that solid wood furniture is better than veneer furnitures. But really why? Is solid wood furnitures more durable?

2, When veneer is used, what's under the veneer? Is it some secondary solid wood, plywood or MDF? For example, the bed sold in Costco claims "poplar solids and cherry veneers". Can I assume there's no MDF on this bed?

3, How's Vaughan-bassett's quality? To be honest, the "simply cherry collection" is cheaper than any pure solid hardwood set we saw locally. It's also cheaper than the Amish online stores. Will the quality, material selection (e.g. wood grade, thickness of boards) be as good as those Amish furnitures?

Any comment will be appreciated. Thanks!

Shawn

Comments (3)