Film is inexpensive, easy to apply, lots of choices and changeable. Glass is glass.

What is wrong with "permanent" frosted glass?

Smart film?

(If you do look at this product please give us the scoop! Sounds intriguing but I'm not at the point of looking at it yet.)

Here is a link that might be useful: wi-fi enabled smart film

Film as in one that you apply yourself after the side window is installed? If so, you need to check to see applying a film will void the warranty on the window.

We used seedy glass in our entry doors, we have a similar set up as you as far as people who are at the front door could see into our family room. We have been super pleased with it. Here is a pic

Why don't ;you discuss with your architect? There's lots of options for a modern house.

If it was my house I'd probably work out a geometrical design, harmonious with the rest of the house, and sandblast it on the glass door. Don't forget to work your hardware (pivot plates, pull and lock set) into the design.

Good luck with your project.

Thanks for your thoughts, everyone. The reason I am hesitant to go the permanent route was it is so permanent. And if we don't like how it turned out, that's an expensive mistake. The reason I am hesitant on film is because I'm not sure how it holds up from a quality perspective.

Oaktown: Wow, that's cool film. I wonder if it works? Very interesting.

Virgil: We have tried pinging the architect on it. He hasn't responded to our emails. I wouldn't mind him being more engaged on the issue, but maybe he thinks it is too small an issue to get involved? I imagine if he did weigh in, he would say to just leave it all plain glass (no obscure). I will try to give him a call and ask about it. I get the impression that he thinks we over-think things.

I think you look into some interesting glass options other than frosted glass. Glasscraft and Rogue Valley have samples of glass on their website. I think the film might look tacky, it may peel from heat etc...
We have the same set up of an open floor plan. We are doing solid beveled glass and we feel like our family room is far enough away from the street for people to look in.
NINI - gorgeous doors! I so wanted the seedy glass but we are in FL and we would need to sandwich the seedy between sheets of solid plain glass due to the wind code in our area.
We often feel like we over-think things too....you are not alone....building is a big deal and takes alot of time, thought and energy.
Pam

Do any of the films come in a wide enough width for your door? The ones I've used were only 18 or 24 inches wide, iirc. Seams would be very difficult to make invisible.

I used film for smaller windows and I'm VERY happy with it - no peeling or bubbling at all. 2 years in.

You could apply it in a pattern like this:
{{gwi:1506991}}

That said for a large expanse on a front door, and if the budget allowed, I'd be VERY tempted to pick one of the many beautiful glass inserts out there. They make some lovely glass!

I would do something permanent. After-the-fact film would be REALLY difficult to install in such a large size, if it even comes in that size.

Robotropolis' "frosted rectangles" is my favorite, in fact a house in my neighborhood has it. Or how about some fantastic art glass: