rangetop vs cooktop(wolf)

9 years ago

Hi All,

After doing lot of research and reading forums and post by lot of others,We have narrowed down to wolf 36'' 6 burner gas rangetop(3800$) vs 36'' 5 burner cooktop(2100$) for our new home.

Range top- 5 big burners and 1 small burner
cooktop- 1 big burner,1 medium burner and 3 small burners.

We cook almost everyday and entertain couple of times a month but not for big crowd(maybe 10-15).

We have seen both and me and my wife like the cooktop but was thinking does it make sense to spend extra 1700$ and go for rangetop or will cooktop do as we don't want to repent later thinking we picked the wrong choice.

if we pick cooktop for the hood we are planning to go with 500cfm blower and 22'' depth hood

If we pick rangetop for the hood we are planning to go with 600cfm and 24'' depth hood.

Are our choices of hood ok or should be go with 600cfm and 24'' depth for cooktop also.

Can folks offer their suggestions as we need to make our choices soon to submit to builder.

Thanks

Featured Answer

friedajune

9 years ago

I prefer a rangetop, though each has its pros and cons:

- there is more room under a cooktop for an additional drawer. Versus a rangetop which will use that space so you'll lose a drawer.

- rangetop has knobs along the front; the cooktop has the knobs easily viewed on top. The downsides to the cooktop's knob placement are (a) they take up real estate on the cooking surface, meaning your burners are more crowded than they'd be with a rangetop, and (b) the cooktop knobs are quite close to the hot pots, particularly the style that has the knobs running down one side of the cooktop--you may not want to have to reach your arm along bubbling, splattering pots to adjust the knobs.

- aesthetics: the cooktop is a sleeker look. The rangetop is heavier, more restaurant-professional look. Personal taste.

- most rangetops have each burner the same (or perhaps one high-power and the rest the same), while cooktops have different size burners. Many people don't like that with a cooktop you have to use a specific burner for a specific pot, and would prefer a rangetop where you can use any of the burners for any of your cooking tasks. Other people don't mind. Personal taste.

- counter cutout and future replacement. A cooktop needs a custom counter cutout for it; a rangetop is just dropped in to the standard width of 30", 36", or 48". If you need to replace a cooktop in the future, you will have to find a new one with the same counter cutout as the old one. We have seen many posts on the Gardenweb about this problem. It's almost impossible to find a cooktop the same size several years later, even with the same brand, which means your choices are limited and you will have to bring in a stone fabricator to adjust the cutout. A rangetop on the other hand does not need a cutout, and can be switched out easily.

- rangetops tend to cost more than cooktops.

Regarding your hood choices, I see no reason to choose the shallower 22" hood if you opt for the cooktop. Also, make sure your ductwork is large enough for your hood; you will need an 8" diameter duct. Since you are building a home, this should not be a problem - don't let the builder tell you that his "standard 6" duct is fine".

This post was edited by akchicago on Sun, Nov 16, 14 at 10:17

Comments (10)

mtnrdredux_gw
9 years ago
So do you mean you are deciding between ...

A cooktop and wall oven

Vs a range top?

Or will you have a wall oven in either case? Or double wall ovens?

Because I think your question usually has to do more with layout or how many ovens you want?
Related Discussions
Dacor 6 Burner Rangetop vs. Wolf 6 Burner Rangetop
Q
Comments (1)
Buy the one which has the knobs that feel the best to you or looks better. Both pretty much the same for cleanup. Wolf has more cache FWIW.
...See More
Thermador vs. Wolf Rangetop
Q
Comments (3)
"Posted by CT_Newbie I had been set on a Wolf rangetop until I read a recent thread in the Kitchen forum which said Wolf went to sealed burners for cost reasons, not for product improvement. The Consumer Reports for their latest range model wasn't very good. I have a Wolf DF and I really like the burners. It has great control especially at the low end. It is very easy to clean but I think something like a BS would also be easy to clean. I don't think it is a matter of one being easier to clean, sealed vs open but varies brand to brand. I think the cost savings for Wolf, is that they only have to deal with one burner type. I am not sure why they picked the semi open burner to discontinue. I am guessing that it might be because the semi open burner wasn't really a true open burner. Also the simmer on the sealed burner is wider so the heat is more diffused on the sealed burner. I know that some posters here wanted to get the semi open burner before they dc'd it but I preferred the sealed over the semi open when I bought mine. Unfortunately I will probably be looking to replace my range, less than five years old, because of issues with the blue enamel so I wouldn't be recommending anything Wolf. Their "decades of service" promised, has shrunk. Their level of service over the time I have been on this forum has definitely declined. " Can anyone explain which simmer is better?" There are negligible differences in the simmer. Look at the BTU rating. For some the clicking is annoying. As far as ovens. I would allow for 30 inch ovens if possible. I would also stay away from anything with blue enamel. I have had it fail in 5 appliances with three different brands. If your ovens work and you like them I would be inclined to keep them!
...See More
KA 36 ' rangetop vs Wolf rangetop
Q
Comments (6)
I admit to having a Wolf and never having looked at this KA until I looked it up for this post, so am starting out biased. ;-) I like all my burners the same power, which is one reason I chose Wolf. For example, I can use a 2 burner griddle sideways or vertically on any burners I want, and I can always arrange whatever size pans and whatever I'm cooking the way that works best for me, not by what output each burner provides. Also, Wolf customer service has an exceptional reputation for standing behind their products. I didn't experience that with Maytag, which is now in the same business family with KA, so I'm not sure if it's better or worse than I dealt with. There's the open vs sealed burner issue, which you can probably do a search on to find previous discussions on this forum. Different people prefer different things, but I thought the open burners looked like the best performers and what I'd prefer to clean. I only ever wonder if I should have gotten a BlueStar to have burners that are even more open. Do you have natural gas or LP? The KA specs say it's configured for NG, but can be converted to LP, which usually means a loss in BTUs for propane users. These are all tough decisions, especially when you're talking about so much money for either choice. I just didn't want to spend thousands and be disappointed, so after my research decided Wolf was my best bet for satisfaction without regret. Best wishes on your decision.
...See More
30" Rangetop - 4 vs 5 burners - Wolf, Viking, Thermador
Q
Comments (11)
"4 burner ranges don’t actually use the same amount of space - there is dead space in the middle and it seems like more around the sides too. Whereas the 5 burner range uses more of the actual 30”." The 30" width is the constant between the two choices. The "dead space in the middle and more around the sides too" on the 4 burner configuration is exactly my point. That is why there will be room for your 12" pan and your dutch oven at the same time. If you cannot find the Thermador 5-burner range on display, just go to a store that has several other brands' 30" 5-burner ranges on display, like Best Buy or whatever local appliance stores there are. Bring your pans with you. You will still be able to see the difference in layout and how your pans fit on a 5-burner 30" range vs. a 4-burner 30" range. Perhaps you will like the 5-burner setup. I do not because of the reasons I've stated about fitting pans. Also, I have never needed 5 burners at once, even on Thanksgiving. A totally different approach would be to go to a 36" cooktop. You won't have the industrial look your husband likes, but unlike with a rangetop, you can fit an extra drawer under it, and you won't have the issues of fitting pans, and even have some room to set down pans that aren't cooking. I understand you said you cannot fit another 6" of width. Perhaps post your layout on this forum (post separate thread, entitled with something catchy like "Pls help me fit a 36" cooktop in my kitchen!"). You will need to provide measurements. There are some amazing layout gurus who hang out here, like amazing.
...See More
Uday Madireddy
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks akchicago for such detailed explanation.I think this will help me and wife decide on the rangetop vs cooktop.
I will go with 24'' depth in hood and would 500cfm do or is it better to go with 600 cfm..just wanted to avoid repentance later trying to save 200$ now :)
I assume you meant duct cover (8'') as wolf guy said he is giving us 12'' for my configuration.
Uday Madireddy
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks mtnrdredux for your reply..
We will have single combi steam wall oven in either case with convection microwave.

Our whole question is regarding selection between rangetop vs cooktop.
mjocean
9 years ago
Hi,
We have the 36" Wolf range top and love it. The extra real estate the range top provides comes in very handy. Akchicago's point that the range top will be much easier to replace due to its standard sizes is a good one; we actually didn't consider that at time of purchase and now we're even happier with our decision.
We have a 24" deep 900 CFM which is 42" wide. It was suggested to us to get a blower that is 3" wider on each side for better coverage.
Best of luck,
MJ
Uday Madireddy
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks MJ ,after akchicago and your comments now I am seriously considering the range top.

I will keep you updated once I talk to my wife.
friedajune
9 years ago
Wolverine82 - I did not mean the duct cover. I mean the exhaust duct that connects the hood to the outside. The duct that the air is pulled through to eventually pipe to the outside. Your hood specs will state what diameter the duct needs to be. It is most commonly 8" for a 600 cfm hood. A more powerful hood of e.g. 1200 cfms will usually specify a 10" duct. If your exhaust duct diameter is smaller than what your hood specifies. you will have increased noise and decreased efficiency through no fault of the hood. Often that is why a hood will be quiet in one person's home, and the same hood will be noisy in another home - it's the ductwork. As I said before, since you are building a home, it should be easy to get the correct duct diameter installed. However, many builders "default" to a 6" diameter exhaust duct. You should clarify with your builder that your exhaust duct diameter --I.e the duct that carries the smoke and grease from your cooktop/rangetop out of your home--should be 8" diameter.
Uday Madireddy
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks akchicago for the detail.
I will check with my builder first thing tomorrow about this.Really appreciate such a good and detailed input.
whocareswhoiam
9 years ago
Did you go with the range top? Did you install 8" duct and did you install the motor on the roof or where? Also, it was interesting comment made that a 42" hood was suggested for a 36" range top - what size did you end up installing? We are going through this decision process now cooktop vs range top. We do like the M series Double Oven. How do you like your Wolf range top/ovens? Our home was not built with a duct, so those that got a 6" duct were luckier than us who only got a recirculating vent hood. Now that we want to replace GE Profile with high btu stovetop...we need to install. We will meet with the contractor to discuss installation. Any suggestions are more than welcome and appreciated!!!!!!!!!
Nisha Sheth
2 years ago
What did you end up getting and how do you like it? We are on same situation right now. Thanks

rangetop vs cooktop(wolf)

friedajune

Comments (10)

mtnrdredux_gw

Related Discussions

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

mjocean

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

friedajune

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

whocareswhoiam

Nisha Sheth

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

rangetop vs cooktop(wolf)

friedajune

Comments (10)

mtnrdredux_gw

Related Discussions

Uday MadireddyOriginal Author

Uday MadireddyOriginal Author

mjocean

Uday MadireddyOriginal Author

friedajune

Uday MadireddyOriginal Author

whocareswhoiam

Nisha Sheth

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

Uday Madireddy
Original Author

Uday Madireddy
Original Author