Fontignac enameled 'steam cooking' cast iron cookware

18 years ago

Does anyone have experience with or knowledge of Fontignac enameled cast iron cookware? It's made in France, and has the dimpling inside the lid (?like the doufeu of Le Creuset), and the Diva ones have an indent on the lid holder for a spoon. They're supposed to be ok on any kind of oven/stove, but I didn't see any temperature maximum mentioned on the website.

I like the colors which include a darker green than the kiwi that's popular now in Le Crueset, a pretty yellow (vanille), blue and ebony. I saw a few in a cookware store, and a round casserole Diva pot was under $110 Cdn.

I'm wondering how it performs compared to Le Creuset which seems to be a gold standard (I have none of any.... yet). Oh yes, and whether the dimpling design would preclude any type of cooking that the regular Le Creuset type items do, re the "steam cooking".

Here is a link that might be useful: Fontignac: http://www.fontignac.com/Pages/panglais/gammea/cocottea.html#mervillea

Comments (4)

kbuzbee
18 years ago
By steam cooking I assume you mean braising??? If so, the reason Le Creuset seems to work so well is the fit and the weight of the lid. It also has very high quality enameling (helpful for cleanup). I would look at the lid and see how it seems to fit (barring anyone here having actual experience). I think people are generally happy with most brands of enameled cast iron they've tried. Have yet to hear anyone say "Stay away from X".

Good luck and let everyone know if you give it a go.

Ken
jerrymb
18 years ago
I have to agree with Kbuzbee, I think the days of LC ruling over their particular niche of cookware is slipping fast, There are some good competitors out there, at some excellent price points, I just bought a round enameled item myself, its about as deep as my LTD saute pan, and it has a Pyrex lid, and straight walled and about 10" in diameter, and has the typical everyday handles, I have not tried it yet but i am thinking my enameled lid from my other dutch oven will fit, that would be sweet. I picked this up for $18.00. I will try to report back with a review soon.
Related Discussions
dutch oven: stainless steel clad vs. enameled cast iron
Q
Comments (6)
I can't speak to enameled cast iron Dutch oven versus clad stainless steel Dutch oven. As for cast iron skillet versus clad stainless skillet, they would be ideal for different tasks. Cast iron is a poor conductor of heat, but will hold (store) a lot of heat. When you put a cast iron pan on the burner, it will take a significant time to heat up and may have hot spots while it is heating. After a while (on my burner, 2-3 minutes), it will be evenly hot. When meat is placed in the pan, the pan will stay hot because it has so much stored heat. This makes cast iron great for searing and browning. After the cast iron pan gets seasoned with oil, it is also practically non-stick, if you wash it properly (no soap). However . . . cast iron pans do not change temperature quickly. If you cook something more delicate than a ribeye and it starts to scorch, turning down the heat won't quickly cool down the pan. Rapidly getting to a particular temperature is a bit tricky. They are heavy, so flipping and tossing is hard. Clad stainless steel is almost the opposite. The aluminum inside is an excellent conductor of heat, but does not hold much heat. So the pan will heat up quickly on the burner, and cool quickly when you lower the flame, it is responsive. You can get the desired temperature - say, a medium-low heat - right away, and the pan will have an even temperature without bad hot spots. But when you put the cold meat on the pan, the pan cools down quickly, until the burner brings the heat back up. So it is not as good for heavy searing. Stainless steel is sticky, protein (meat, fish, egg) sticks immediately and stays stuck until it gets browned and releases. Even then, bits of crusty food are left on the pan. That is a good thing - it is ''fond'', the foundation of a pan sauce - but if you weren't planning to make a pan sauce it can be a pain. You can avoid stickage by using plenty of oil, of course. If you get a stainless pan really hot, food and oil will scorch onto it, making for a cleaning job. Basically, you should have both, and use each for what it is best at. I use my cast iron pan at full-hot, for searing meat mostly. I use my clad stainless for more medium and low heat cooking, or at high heat if I want fond. If I could only have one, I'd get the clad stainless.
...See More
Steam escaping in my Staub Enamel Cast Iron Dutch/French Oven
Q
Comments (11)
If you look at the underside of your Staub lid you will see 3 little nubs cast into the rim. I called Staub about them, and they said it helps the raised dimples on the underside of the lid work better. They are there to allow the pot work more efficiently. Le Creuset's latest saucepans with the phenolic handles DO have a hole in the lid for some steam to escape. That is normal, and desirable on the Staub, as they were put there for a reason to allow some steam to escape.
...See More
Recipes to test my new enameled cast iron 'French Oven'?
Q
Comments (11)
How adventurous are you? Anything which needs long slow cooking will work. Its forte is braising meats: brown on the top of the stove, add liquid and cook slowly for a long time in a slow oven. Chili is really easy, as are pot roasts. Here are two classic dishes: "Gigot de sept heures" --seven hour leg of lamb. Brown lamb, add stock and vegetables, put in a very slow oven for 7 hours. Yes, it takes 7 hours to cook but your involvement is mostly about 20 minutes at the beginning. Perfect for when you have to be in the house all day doing other stuff, because you shouldnÂt be peeking at this dish anyway while it cooks. Do a google search and youÂll find a few versions of this recipe. The lamb comes out juicy, delicious and fork-tender. Another classic dish is "lapin en gibelotte"Âa fancy rabbit stew. The link below is to one version of the dish. If youÂve never tried domestic rabbit, give it a try: delicate, more flavorful than chicken, not at all gamy. Here is a link that might be useful: lapin en gibelotte
...See More
Cast iron with enamel...
Q
Comments (8)
Lara, don't worry about those edges. I have a lot of Le Cruset and other brands of enameled pots. What seems to happen is that the edges pretty much season themselves. When you cook with them some grease mixes with the steam/liquid and coats the edges and it ends up as seasoned rims. That's how it appears to me anyway. When I look at the rims on my pots they do look like they're seasoned and I sure didn't do it on purpose. It just happens. Smiles. Congrats.
...See More
bluebloom
Original Author
18 years ago
Thanks for the comments. I just noticed on some ads for Staub similar dimples or protrusions on lids... I guess it helps to make the water/liquid drips more evenly dispersed.

And yes that would be for braising, but I was wondering if enameled cast iron is great for any other method of cooking (besides "lid off" roasting & baking) that the Fontignac cookware wouldn't perform well.

There was another even cheaper brand (couldn't see a brand name) at the same store... seemed lighter though. That would be nice for my weak-ish hands, but I'm kind of lusting after one of the pretty heavier ones... would probably keep it to either a 3-4 quart size, or maybe one of those shallow round casserole items with lid. In any case, I don't go much to the stores so will read more and probably take some time to decide.... especially since I'm reasonably well-stocked with stainless steel cookware. And also have Romertopf clay bakers that I picked up super cheaply at garage sale/second hand store. But that's not for stove-top use, and our oven's on the blink right now.... hmmm....

Meanwhile, I've learned a ton & really enjoy browsing some of the posts here - thanks!
kbuzbee
18 years ago
Yes, there are similar dimples on some Staub and Le Creuset models. They are, as you indicate, supposed to make them auto-basting. Reviews I've read say the water does not condense and drip from them as the lids are simply too warm. I think they are basically a non issue.

I find the Le Creust works equally well on the stovetop as it does in the oven. I would expect the same from similar products. I was out of oven space last Thanksgiving and made an Indian Corn Pudding dish on the stovetop. It came out perfectly! I would stay with the heavier castings though for uniformity of heat distribution.

Ken

Fontignac enameled 'steam cooking' cast iron cookware

Comments (4)

kbuzbee

jerrymb

Related Discussions

bluebloom
Original Author

kbuzbee

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Fontignac enameled 'steam cooking' cast iron cookware

Comments (4)

kbuzbee

jerrymb

Related Discussions

bluebloomOriginal Author

kbuzbee

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

bluebloom
Original Author