skip to main content

Building a Home

Roof Trusses or Stick Built for open Kitchen/Great Room

9 years ago

Hello, we are in the final design phase with our architect on a home that we are building in a 120 MPH wind zone in Southern Rhode Island.

Here is the issue, our architect initially wanted to use roof trusses for the whole house but our framer wanted to stick build the roofs. After going over it with the architect she was OK with stick built roof over everything except the open ceilinged great room/kitchen. She wants to talk to our framer about it but he doesn't see the need and just said have her draw the plans as stick built.

I've attached a jpeg of the first draft of the first floor. The footprint of the house is 56'x26', we added 2' to the plans that I've attached to this post so they're not completely accurate.

This is our first build and we are somewhat ignorant on the matter. We would like to build in the most cost effective way but not sacrifice strength as we are in a high wind zone.

Since the great room/kitchen is open and there will be no second floor over it the trusses seem to make sense to us but again, we are not experienced.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Comments (5)

bronco33
9 years ago
In my neck of the woods framers get a higher rate for stick built roofs. There is an art to it, so make sure your framer has the necessary experience. Also in high wind areas there is more attention to detail since a stick built roof will need additional bracing.

As for trusses they are built in a controlled environment on a jig and shipped to the build site. Computerized engineering goes into their design to ensure the structural stability. Using trusses will also allow the house to be dried in faster as long as the order is scheduled properly. Depending on design they can however eat up storage space in the attic.
Briarwood1
Original Author
9 years ago
Hello Bronco, thanks for the reply. The framer has decades of experience. We completely trust his building expertize.

The open ceiling over the kitchen/family room will never be used for anything else, no attic or additions so the trusses seemed like a fine idea to us but every framer we've talked to doesn't like them.
Related Discussions
Interior Load-Bearing Wall under W-Truss Roof ??
Q
Comments (5)
I doubt any residential property with trusses has any interior load bearing walks both outside walks are load bearing. And I'd say all commercial building with trusses wjth interior walks are definitely load bearing not residential . Me I would treat it as a load bearing wall building 2 posts Anda large beam the span of the wall to be removed . Or better build two walks the. Height of the wall to be removed and 3 foot longer with studs 3 foot o.c on center first then remove the wall. If I seen it . I'd know in a minute if it was. But I seriously doubt it is with house trusses only your exterior walls that run the length of the home are load bearing . W trusses . If the home has floor joists on a second floor that's the only time it would be load bearing....
...See More
How much refrigerator should stick out from a built in cabinet?
Q
Comments (27)
I assume that if Peggymeeks' fridge sticks out 8", it can't be counter depth. Peggymeeks - can you provide us the model number of your fridge, or its dimensions? From your brief description, I am thinking you bought a full-depth fridge, but perhaps should have bought a counter-depth fridge, or a fridge not quite as deep as the one you have. Samsung is known for having spacious fridges, which also means their non-cabinet-depth fridges are deeper than most. Even their "cabinet-depth" fridges are deeper than other brands. A Samsung standard depth is about 34" deep, and a Samsung counter-depth is about 29" deep, which includes the doors.
...See More
Open Great Room, Dining Room, Kitchen Layout help, Please :)
Q
Comments (3)
What I would do if it were my kitchen: 1. move the DOvens to the R of cooktop 2. make that sink area to the L of fridge = clean up zone: - make sink bigger, and - put the DW to the L of the sink 3. Move island sink toward the R (closer to patio): I like to come in from patio to wash my hands after being in the garden, etc. - So now island/cooktop = prep/cook area, clear path to fridge, w/out the rare use of Oven in the way 4. Clean up/putting away clean dishes has its own zone So much potential; great space. Make it awesome! Amanda
...See More
What all is covered in city inspection of truss roof
Q
Comments (14)
If the 24” skylight aligns with the truss spacing shown on the engineering, there should be no issues with inspections, as long as the original structural plans on site align with what was built. If you have taken the liberty of adjusting spacing of the trusses to fit your desired location of the skylight, then you have compromised the structural ability of the roofing support. That requires reengineering the roof, and replacing or altering some trusses. The only ones who can specify if altering a truss is possible, are the exact engineers who designed it from the beginning. It is a can of worms to open. But it is better than your roof sagging and collapsing because of an unapproved change. Or failing an inspection. Which you have already done. That raised red flags with the inspection department to scrutinize your project even more closely on all future inspections. Better familiarize yourself with the IRC.
...See More
dekeoboe
9 years ago
but every framer we've talked to doesn't like them.

Have you asked them why? And how does your architect respond when you tell her the reason the framers do not want trusses?
Briarwood1
Original Author
9 years ago
The framers and builders we've talked to about them have given a myriad of reasons.

They can stick build a better roof than any off site company can.

The trusses lose structural rigidity during transport.

The wood used is inferior.

The crane issue is more trouble than just building them on site.

And on and on and on.

Our architect just says she's surprised that the people we've talked to don't like them. She says most builders/framers are using roof trusses now.
bronco33
9 years ago
I don't really buy any of the excuses that the framer is trying to sell you on. Trusses are transported on special trailers. Most truss builders use machine graded lumber rather than visual graded. A crane with a experienced operator and a knowledgeable crew on the ground can have the roof on in a day, two max while the framer will more than likely take a week or better (depending on weather) to stick build.

Will the walls be 2x4 on 16" centers or 2x6 on 16" or 24" centers? If the walls are on 16" centers I would have it stick built with the rafters lined up with the studs. If 24", then I would go trusses and have them lined up with the studs. Keeping them lined up will provide better structural integrity.

Sign Up to Comment

Related Stories

REMODELING GUIDES Room of the Day: A Great Room in a Former Church

By Mitchell Parker

Handmade details, beautiful trusses and a bell make the most of this converted church’s good bones

REMODELING GUIDES 8 Ways to Stick to Your Budget When Remodeling or Adding On

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Know thyself, plan well and beware of ‘scope creep’

KNOW YOUR HOUSE Know Your House: Components of a Roof

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Don't get held up by confusion over trusses, rafters and purlins. Learn about a roof's features and their purposes here

REMODELING GUIDES How to Stick to Your Remodeling Goals

By Incite Design

Avoid getting lost in the sea of remodeling decisions by using these 5 steps as an anchor

ROOM OF THE DAY Room of the Day: A Great Room Pays Homage to Ordinary Architecture

By Annie Thornton

This Texas renovation embraces a stick frame home's simple structure and its place in the community

REMODELING GUIDES Supporting Act: Exposed Wood Trusses in Design

What's under a pitched roof? Beautiful beams, triangular shapes and rhythm of form

ORGANIZING Stick to Your Resolutions: Help From a Pro Organizer

By Jennifer Phelps: Organize. Design. Reinvent!

Accomplish your goals — from decluttering to rediscovering fitness — for real this time

ARCHITECTURE Learn the Language of Trusses in Design

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

If figuring out all those intersecting beam configurations under roofs makes your eyes cross, here's help

ROOM OF THE DAY Room of the Day: Eclectic and Casual in a Michigan Great Room

By Mitchell Parker

Distressed finishes and a mix of styles make this newly built great room fit for a laid-back family

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Connected, Open Oregon Remodel

By Vanessa Brunner

Removing a chimney, a half-cabinet and a countertop helped create elbow room and an open flow for a galley-style kitchen in Portland

Sponsored

Dave Fox Design Build Remodelers

49 Reviews

Columbus Area's Luxury Design Build Firm | 17x Best of Houzz Winner!

More Discussions

Composite Decking? Photos?

3

I need help with front double door!

5

Polished Nickel Framed Shower Enclosure

8

Kitchen reno tip for first time homeowner?!

41

Windows too close to floor

14