skip to main content

Building a Home

Getting reclaimed wood floors from new floors?

9 years ago

We are about to stain ours and I'm stressed over picking the color. We have 4 inch character grade white oak and I'd like to do something different. I was hoping our floors would have a bunch of knots and stuff in them but they don't.
I really like the color depth you get in reclaimed floors and wish we could make them look like that. Has anyone done something like this before? I'm not talking about beating them with chains...I don't really care for that look, I'm just looking for the color.
Like these:

or

I like that these oak floors are darker but without the grain standing out like you get when you put darker stain on them.
I've also attached what our floors look like unfinished

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

tulips33
Original Author
9 years ago
Here's our floors with stain sample on them. I like that the reclaimed floors still have color variation from board to board too
Bungalow14
9 years ago
I don't think you'll find any stain or staining technique that will give you a wide light to dark finish variation. As I understand it, that look comes from the wood, not the stain.
Like you, we have 4" white oak "mill run" (what our GC called it; I suspect it is the same as character grade) flooring, and we chose to go with MinWax "Provincial". There isn't a stark light-to-dark difference between the boards, but we do have a lot of grain variation and plenty of knot holes.
Good luck with your finishing!
Related Discussions
Reclaimed wood floors-opinions and experiences
Q
Comments (17)
Cautionary note: much reclaimed wood flooring is manufactured by individual mills that are not part of any particular flooring association and thus may not produce the flooring in accordance to accepted standards. 1) make sure your installer is familiar with reclaimed wood flooring 2) make sure to take moisture content readings BEFORE you pay for the product and that it falls within standards provided to you by your installer 3) make sure to take moisture content readings at your house before installation, and compare the readings to other floors in your house. Had I done this, and purchased the $150 Delmhorst J-LITE pin LED meter 2 months ago instead of this week, I would have saved myself several thousand $.
...See More
For new wood floors: metal or wood floor registers?
Q
Comments (14)
I remodeled 5+ years ago and replaced all my flooring (except in the baths) with finished-on-site hard wood floors. I ordered the wood registers at the same time I did the flooring, as it was cut to order by the company that cut my wood floors (back east somewhere). I LOVE the wood registers. They're the same thickness as the wood floors, they blend in so the eye never notices the register and it is style neutral. They'll blend with whatever style you have in your home. I definitely have a traditional home, and these registers fit right in. They are worth the extra money they cost, and I'm so glad I ordered them!
...See More
Replacing original wood floor with reclaimed
Q
Comments (1)
Your best bet for reclaimed wood are salvage stores. I'd check there first. Are you near a major city? I've been to lots of salvage places around the continental US - might be able to help with some recommendations. If your worn area isn't huge, you might also take some pine out of one of your closets and patch the affected area. Then put newer wood in the closet. We have a locker full of 1918 oak that we'll be using when we finish our attic - got it from a neighbor who ripped it out so they could install tile!
...See More
Installing new wood floors over existing wood floors
Q
Comments (4)
I was thinking fire hazard as well. That doesn't really sound like it is up to current code either. I think the floor part of the problem is fineÃ¢ÂÂ¦you can lay another floor over it. But at this point with the wires etc. under there I would look at a floating click-installation wood floor. I would not be driving nails into a nest of electrical wires.
...See More
Bungalow14
9 years ago
Another random shot.
tulips33
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks for your comment, we were looking at provincial and it helps to see it!! Was it water popped? (water put on floor before stain)
Do you remember if your floors looked like ours did before staining? I was hoping that staining wouldn't disguise the color variation we do have from board to board

This post was edited by tulips33 on Tue, Jun 24, 14 at 10:58
Bungalow14
9 years ago
No water popping, just stain & poly.
Bungalow14
9 years ago
Here's what it looked like during installation. Sorry for poor image quality; the pic was taken on a gloomy winter day, without any interior lighting.

Here is a link that might be useful:

This post was edited by Bungalow14 on Tue, Jun 24, 14 at 11:09
User
9 years ago
If you're DIYing, you can tape off individual boards and stain them darker, or slightly redder, etc. before staining the whole floor. That will give you more variation, but it's very labor intensive and no pro will do that without charging you a mint. Also, a penetrating oil finish will give you more depth to the wood than a water based poly.
User
9 years ago
You can, but it's a tedious process for DIY and expensive if you hire it done.

Instead of staining with a single color, which tends to make a uniform appearance, you select or create 3 colors and apply them board by board ... about 20% should be stained the darkest color (picking the darkest boards for this), 20% the lightest color or light boards left unstained, and the remainder stained the middle shade.

What with the board-by board work, itÃ¢ÂÂs a tedious PITA. Awesome when it's done, but .... how bad do you want it.
tulips33
Original Author
9 years ago
I would totally do this but I don't think my builder will let b/c of time constraints....one of the things I hate about letting go of the control...

Related Stories

KITCHEN DESIGN What to Know About Using Reclaimed Wood in the Kitchen

By Becky Harris

One-of-a-kind lumber warms a room and adds age and interest

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: A Modern Loft Gets a Little Help From Some Friends

By Mitchell Parker

With DIY spirit and a talented network of designers and craftsmen, a family transforms their loft to prepare for a new arrival

REMODELING GUIDES Get What You Need From the House You Have

By SPACE Architects + Planners

6 ways to rethink your house and get that extra living space you need now

ECLECTIC STYLE Get Creative Salvage Ideas from Houzzers' Reuse Projects

By Becky Harris

Save money and show off your resourcefulness by borrowing from these creative home projects using salvaged materials

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING 10 Ideas for Decorating Your Summer Porch

By Laura Gaskill

Watch the world go by from a porch decked out with comfy furniture and inspiring accessories

BEDROOMS Get More From Your Bed (Storage, for Starters)

By Lisa Higgins

Find space for all your stuff — and maybe even a seat, a writing desk or another sleep spot — by cozying up to a multipurpose bed

KITCHEN DESIGN Get Ideas From This Year’s Top 20 Kitchen Tours

By Becky Harris

Smart storage, functionality for cooks and families, vintage touches and lots of personality mark your favorites of 2015

MY HOUZZ Get Ideas From the Top My Houzz Tours of 2015

Meet the DIY design-savvy personalities behind your favorite homes this year who know how to rock color and maximize square footage

REMODELING GUIDES Laminate Floors: Get the Look of Wood (and More) for Less

See what goes into laminate flooring and why you just might want to choose it

GREAT HOME PROJECTS What to Know About Adding a Reclaimed-Wood Wall

By Rebecca Pogson

Here’s advice on where to put it, how to find and select wood, what it might cost and how to get it done

Sponsored

Remodel Repair Construction

9 Reviews

Industry Leading General Contractors in Westerville

More Discussions

Anderson Woodwright vs Marvin Elevate

12

Need Help Reviewing Floor Plan!

53

Trex Deck Stairs with Builder or After Installation?

3

Foundation house plan

15

building costs in Seattle

10