Need layout help - where to place new window?

9 years ago

Hi, I have been a somewhat silent and infrequent follower of several GW forums for many years, and have found lots of great answers. I'm hoping the collective knowledge/wisdom on this forum might help me in my current project.

The situation:

We have just started a master bath renovation - removed 2.5 tons of old tile/wallboard (who knew a bathroom weighed that much!), and framed in the new walls, as well as lowered the floor for the curbless shower.

Many of the decisions have been made - in addition to the shower, we are going with a Victoria and Albert tub - the IOS, reusing our old reliable toilet (when you get a good 1.5 gal flush toilet, you don't get rid of it!), as well as all of the tile decisions and most of the lighting decisions.

What is perplexing me now is where to place the window! In the old bathroom, it was a 48 X 48 double casement over the tub that matched a similar window in the dining room on the other side of the front door (this bath is in the front of the house - north side). I purchased a 30 W X 48 H single casement to replace it, thinking that I would put it in between the two sinks on that wall. After playing with layouts, I'm not sure that's a good idea. (The window size was selected to match other windows on the front of the house.)

Here's a photo of the wall:

Some of the constraints are:

1. The toilet and shower positions are fixed, as well as the two door locations (to closet, and to bedroom)

2. The tub will be a freestanding tub, and needs to stay on the wall between the window wall and the shower. The tub's location can slide up or down that wall as needed, but it should make some design sense, since that will be a focal point wall, with vertical accent tile.

3. The window size is pretty much fixed, based on the need to balance the front of the house. It can move left or right on that wall, though it would be easiest to not have to change the rough opening on the right side (looking out). (that would make it 10 inches from the stud on the tub wall.)

Here is the floor plan after the demo:

And here is my thought about the design.

I'm worried about moving the sink too far to the right, where it will be in the way of the tub, so I thought I might have a window seat/pull out hamper at that location. At this point, I am going with a 36 inch high vanity, with a granite top, and Kohler Caxton 19 inch undermount sinks.

I'm not married to my design, so please give any/all options! I need to finalize it in the next few days, so that I can give rough in instructions to the plumber and electrician.

Thanks!

This post was edited by pennpeggy on Fri, Jul 11, 14 at 22:27

Comments (9)

palimpsest
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
How about the tub on the window wall with the vanities down the windowless wall?
pennpeggy
Original Author
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
That would be similar to what we have now (or had). I think I just switch my current set of problems for another set. I wanted the "wet" or humid areas to be close together, and away from the closet - hence moving the tub close to the shower. I think I still would have to move the window unless I shove the tub into the corner, which seems a shame to do.I was really liking how it is the focal point of that wall, and was planning on highlighting it with a vertical tile design.

Thanks for your thoughts - I'll play around with the full sized cut outs I've made and see what works.
Related Discussions
New House - Great Room Layout - Need Help!
Q
Comments (9)
The window over the fireplace--how high off the floor is it? I'm wondering if you could change out the fireplace to a lower-profile unit and move it to be under one of the other windows. (No idea how expensive that would be.) Then you might be able to put the TV where the fireplace currently is. Placed on a TV stand, it might block the lower part of the window. If that bothers you, you could look into a TV stand that hides the TV and raises it to viewing height at the touch of a button. Or a wall mount that would let you raise and lower the TV--up when you are watching it and lower when you aren't. That would also allow you to adjust the viewing angle, if you wanted to watch it from the kitchen.
...See More
Help needed on new Kitchen Layout
Q
Comments (16)
I had considered shaving a foot or 2 off your island to make it easier to get around, but did not show it in the mock up because you mentioned needing a lot of seating in the island. Your kids may have friends over after school (or weekends) and that can snowball. One thing to consider is to have rounded edges on the island to make traffic jams less painful. I'd also recommend that the back side of the island curve outward because you have plenty of room and it would give you a nicer look. It would also allow anyone seated at the island to have a better shot at conversing with each other. I mocked up moving the fridge/freezer setup lower. I also think a base cab at the end would be best for landing space and keeping an open feel. I like the extra opening into the great room for much easier flow. I added a base cab for utensils by your table because we have that in our new kitchen and it is fabulous. It is also next to the dw for ease of unloading. I like the idea of one more window in your morning room to get cross ventilation. Your hutch would have to be more of a buffet kind of set up. Another thought was a window seat along the left side and upper walls. You seem to have the space for it and you could use it for storage below. Otherwise the morning room is a little large for the table shown. Dooonie's is the perfect example of how you can have a feature by the stove and sink and not miss having a window at all! Her features complement each other and are not copies. btw - I could not figure out the label on the closet in the laundry room... I had thought that your laundry room could be laid out better. We have the large Lg Tromms that are stackable and that makes more floor space. I did a mockup with them side by side, but moved to the other wall with the sink. It opens up the laundry room more and gives you more options. If you stacked them, it would give you even more flexibility.
...See More
Need help with kitchen remodel ideas and suggestions of our new layout
Q
Comments (42)
Yes but its not just the desired look. If cost is not a factor, anything is possible. But if you have not done a lot of remodeling, you may not be aware of all the associated costs with changing all this. The ceiling, the lighting, framing out the window and wall, matching and replacing the existing exterior. While maintaining the exterior design balance. Moving plumbing, gas and electrical. Your house was built for this kitchen so everything you are considering has major expense to change. You might be better off as far as function and design to bump out the back and redo the whole thing.
...See More
Need help placing my island in my kitchen remodel layout. Pathways?
Q
Comments (9)
Here is the information y'all requested. I appreciate all feedback. Clearly, I need the help!! Our home is a ranch in an established subdivision outside of New Orleans. We have 3 teenagers / college kids and dogs. We cook and eat at home often. We entertain and host all holiday meals at our home too. Kids usually eat at the island. We eat family dinners together in the kitchen at our table most nights. As my teens / young adults grow, I envision our home and kitchen being the gathering spot for holidays and get-togethers, and the kids usually have a friend or two over visiting also. We tend to use our island as our “drop zone” during the week as we are coming and going. DETAILS: 1. Getting new appliances. A big, french door fridge (35.5 inches wide, SS) Keeping current dishwasher (standard 24", SS) Adding a drawer microwave (27" Sharp SS) Still trying to decide about range or cooktop / oven. If I get a range, it will be 30" with a double oven configuration. If I select a professional range, it will be 36". If I do a cooktop / oven, the cooktop will be 36" and double ovens. All SS. Big, deep single bowl SS sink 33" (requires a 36" cabinet) 2. Yes, I definitely want an island that we can have at least 3 stools at it for teens to eat, etc. 3. In the lower left corner, we already have a table and eating area. 4. Things I would like: * A pullout base cabinet that will hold 3 trash cans (21" cabinet) * I would prefer that most or all of my base cabinets be drawers. Otherwise, If I have lower cabinets, then I want pull out shelves. * I'd like a big island, and I think I could accommodate that. * I want some floor to ceiling cabinetry that I can store all of my kitchen appliances in (i.e. - blender, rice cooker, instant pot, crockpots, roasting pan, air fryer, etc.) * I would like to have a hood in my kitchen to help get rid of cooking smells * Off-white traditional style cabinet doors, full overlay, raised panel PICTURES: A. Our CURRENT home layout. The kitchen area is circled in red. The wall that we want to remove has “XXXX” on it. We don’t really use the butler’s pantry for much other than storage, so we were thinking of getting rid of our current pantry, and making the butler’s pantry into our food pantry. (and closing off the opening into the office area.) The reason we want to remove the wall between the kitchen and living room is because we want a more open concept layout to allow us to see out into the backyard more. But, of course, this is the wall the currently had all my cabinets on it. B. The dimensions of our kitchen area. NOTE: We are on a slab and we can move plumbing, electrical and gas anywhere currently. Again, thank you for taking the time to read all of this and thanks for offering opinions and advice. I really appreciate it!
...See More
enduring
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Can you double check your scale of the drawing. It doesn't look like the vanity at 116", is in scale with the 58" of the shower wall, at the opposite end of the room. With a scaled drawing it is easier to make changes in the plan, because it is clear where things will fit.
badgergal
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
I can't help you with where to place the windows but since you said that you will be using the 19" Kohler Caxton sink I thought I would mention (in case you dont know) that that sink comes in a 17x14" size and a 15x12". They are all the same depth. I actually used two of 15 x12 size on a 60 inch vanity. We find that size plenty big enough for us. Even if you only went down to the 17" size you will gain valuable inches of countertop space on each side of the sink and behind or infront of the sink.
Here's how the 15x12s look in my application:
Karenseb
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Wow, I think your tub would look great on the diagonal in the corner with free standing vanities on either side.
pennpeggy
Original Author
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Thanks for the quick feedback...

enduring, I checked the scale, and I believe it is correct. The shower wall is half the length of the window wall... I realize my scan didn't copy that well, especially since I needed to rotate it, but I think it is accurate.

badgergal, I had already begun to wonder if the sinks were too big. I forgot to measure what we had before Habitat carted it off this week, but I'm sure they were smaller than 19 inches. I think 17 would be fine, and I'm glad to see your photos of the 15 (love the granite!)

Karenseb, what a great idea! I'm not quite sure why I rejected that position at the beginning of the project. I had looked at plenty of photos of the corner tub, but thought it would take up too much space, and feel too much like the old whirlpool tub that we just yanked out. I played around with my full sized templates, and kind of like it. Plus, it means we won't have to change out the window (yay!) Here's a photo of what that looks like, as well as an updated floor plan:

This design does raise a couple of other questions, though...

1. I had planned for a panel of glass for one of the shower walls - the one on the same wall as where I had the tub originally. It would have meant there was a clear line of sight all along that wall - no cabinets, etc. I can still put that glass in, but now it would be next to the cabinet, and I think I lose the "cool" effect... plus I'm wondering if it would feel weird to shower and have someone standing at that sink at the same time...

2. I had planned to tile the entire blank wall that the tub was originally on, with a couple of recessed niches with accent tiles running vertically from floor to ceiling. Obviously that won't work now, given that the wall is now broken up, so I'll need to rethink through what the tile accent "wow" factor will be. The main focus when entering the bathroom from the bedroom will be that wall/window corner. Any ideas?

Thanks again! Every time I think I've come up with all possible options, someone comes up with another one...
Karenseb
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
What's on the other side of the long windowless wall?
The corner plan looks good. I would do longer vanities than what you have drawn.
pennpeggy
Original Author
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
The shower is in the 58 X 64 area. It's a curbless shower, and has a glass wall - originally intended to be full length - separating it from what is now the vanity.

I agree that the vanities should be bigger - still working on what size I would like here. The concern I have is that the vanity near the shower will now be next to the glass wall....so I'm wondering if I should put up a short pony wall here, topped with glass instead of the full glass wall.
Karenseb
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
I think a pony wall with glass on top would look nice. Then you could extend the cabinet to the wall on both vanities if you needed more storage. In my last house I had a tub in the corner with a window on each side, very pretty. One of the vanities had drawers on one side and a built in hamper on the other side. I'm guessing the vanity was 60 in.

Need layout help - where to place new window?

Comments (9)

palimpsest

pennpeggy
Original Author

Related Discussions

enduring

badgergal

Karenseb

pennpeggy
Original Author

Karenseb

pennpeggy
Original Author

Karenseb

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Need layout help - where to place new window?

Comments (9)

palimpsest

pennpeggyOriginal Author

Related Discussions

enduring

badgergal

Karenseb

pennpeggyOriginal Author

Karenseb

pennpeggyOriginal Author

Karenseb

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

pennpeggy
Original Author

pennpeggy
Original Author

pennpeggy
Original Author