Does this sound right? (Tile question)

9 years ago

We had a custom tiled shower installed as part of our complete home renovation. Existing bathroom was completely removed and rebuilt, including the studs. It's a walk-in, about 3' x 6' (small bathroom).

We're 95% done, and I just checked the shower. The are pockets of the tiled floor that are lower than the drain, and obviously hold water. That was the last straw with the tile guy, and I told our contractor that I had no faith in his ability to fix that. One of the (many) other tile issues in the bathroom is that the junction between the 2x2" tile floor and the 3x6" subway tile wall is not straight. It looks like a toddler tried to draw a line with a crayon.

Today the contractor told me what the new tile guy has in mind to fix it: he said that removing the tile floor completely, along with the first row of subway tile, will compromise the integrity of the waterproofing of the shower wall and floor. Instead, he wants to remove the first row of subway tile, 'scuff up' the existing tile floor (leaving the tile in place), apply a layer of mastic on the existing tile floor, and then place another layer of tile on top of that.

He said that by doing it this way, he can fix the drainage issue as well as the aesthetics of the floor/wall junction. I said I'd research it.

I did, and what I've seen is that mastic is an organic compound, and any exposure to moisture can create mold, etc. My hesitation is that if he does it this way, the mastic between two layers of floor tile will act like a 'potential space', just waiting for a crack in the top grout layer, and then eat our shower away from beneath.

Full disclosure, I know nothing about tiling, just what I've been reading the last couple months, and specifically tonight re mastic.

Has anyone ever heard of fixing a shower this way? What's the industry standard on something like this? Will I be setting myself up for failure once my 1-yr warranty (on the build) runs out if i use mastic?

Thanks so much in advance for any insight!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

worthy
9 years ago
Mastic is not suited for wet areas such as a shower floor. Maybe the contractor misspoke, confusing it with thinset, which is the appropriate material. Normally, you would tear it down and start over if this were an old shower bed, but adding a layer should be no problem. Of course, this assumes that a tilesetter who couldn't figure out the proper slope did the bed properly.
Gabe
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks Worthy. I'll verify tomorrow if the contractor misspoke, or if we need to discuss the planned material further.
So assuming the shower bed the original tilesetter built is correct, then it sounds like there's no problem having thinset between 2 layers of floor tile?
That's a relief that there's an alternative to tearing the entire thing out and starting from scratch again. Thanks!
Related Discussions
Construction loan...does this sound right?
Q
Comments (7)
I'm no expert but based on the fact that mortgage rates are currently at near historic lows and the government is pumping billions of dollars of new money into the economy (all those stimulus package bailouts), I think we're going to start seeing inflation VERY soon - double digit inflation in fact. If so, mortgage loan rates will rise with inflation. My personal suspicion is that your banker also foresees inflation coming and he doesn't want you to lock in today's low rates by getting a one-time close loan because such loans are very tough on the lenders. Your banker may look for the "best rate" available for you when your construction is done, but I strongly suspect that "best rate" won't be nearly as good as what you can lock in right now with a one-time close. Keep in mind that your loan is a business transaction for the bank. The bank wants to make money off of it and your banker has the bank's best interests at heart, not yours. As for possible over-runs in costs, if you're doing a "fixed price build", the only cost over-runs should be from "change orders" and I highly recommend paying for any and all change orders "out of pocket." That is one sure-fired way to keep yourself from going overboard on changes. LOL!
...See More
One of those, 'does this bid sound about right' questions
Q
Comments (4)
Thanks for the replys, guys. Yeah, at first blush I thought it was pretty high, but the master bath accounts for about $13,900 of it. And as Bud noticed, there is a lot of cutting and detail work involved. And I forgot that in addition to the custom shower glass block walls, they are also replacing a small (maybe 3'x3') bathroom window with glass block. I'll definitely get another bid or two to compare, but glad to hear that it's not too far out of line. They said up front that they would not be the low bid, but they've been around 20+ years and came at the recommendation of my interior designer. BTW, she is just helping with design work on the whole project at an hourly rate, providing input and recommendations when I want, so I don't think she has a vested interest in recommending them. Her take is , sure, by all means get other bids, but hands down these guys will take care of you.
...See More
Does this sound right? Carrier Infiinity ICS without zoning?
Q
Comments (2)
We had Honeywell programmable thermostats installed upstairs and downstairs in 2001. And we're not updating our AC, which is Carrier, also replaced in 2001. I think I'm with you - seems silly not to install the zoning. As I recall, we needed the zoning at the time. Maybe with the new system we won't, but I don't know. I recall that the upstairs bedroom gets very hot during the day in the summer, even with ac - low ceilings and close to the roof, I guess.
...See More
So it's cork or linoleum--does that sound right and WWYD?
Q
Comments (29)
NYC - Interesting, I have a 30 year old concrete slab on grade foundation in Michigan, lots of freeze and thaw here. I am currently pulling up one layer of linoleum and one layer of parquet and all the associated glue off the slab. Yucky job. I am putting down all floating floors, to get off the cold slab (cork under marmoleum would have some of that effect) and to prevent any problems from any shifting or cracking of the slab. In addition, I like the non-permanent nature. I can change my mind and change it in 5 or 6 years if it is not glued to my slab!! In researching all the different floating floors, I discovered they all require a 6 mil plastic vapor barrier between the slab and the flooring to prevent moisture from the slab from reaching the flooring. Marmoleum Click has a pressed wood core with the marmoleum glued to one side and cork to the other side so my plan was to just go over the vapor barrier with Marmoleum Click. I think the main advantage of glue down is the extra protection it provides you from water damage. I think glue down tile or sheet Marmoleum is quite bullet proof against water damage. The Click is less so because it has the pressed wood core like all floating type floors. I am just going to have to be careful not to let water sit and put something under the dog's water dishes.
...See More
kas4
9 years ago
After moving into our new home we decided we didn't like the shower floor tile so we paid the tile guy to change it. He laid a new shower floor right over the existing tile so we ended up with two layers on the floor. He didn't remove any of the wall tiles. We had no problems in 8+ years.
DLM2000-GW
9 years ago
Speaking as a homeowner, bill payer and not as an expert by any means, this compromise wouldn't fly in my house. As irritating and inconvenient as it would be I'd expect a do-over and to get what I contracted and paid for, which presumably is a properly installed, fully functioning shower.
Gabe
Original Author
9 years ago
kas4, that's good to hear that you haven't had any problems in that amount of time.

dlm2000... that's been my point exactly with everyone I've talked to about this, including DW. It's not like the contractors would be fixing someone else's mistake; they're fixing their own! Well, the sub's, but still.

I spoke with the contractor today, and voiced my concerns. I'll be speaking directly to the new tile setter to see what he has in mind before I make any decisions or let him proceed.

One possible solution is to go ahead and let them apply a second layer of tile flooring, with their assurances that it will 'last'. This would have to come in the form of a written warranty that far exceeds the standard 1 yr. Perhaps a 5yr?

I've attached some pics. The walk-in shower is tiled all the way up to the 9' ceilings, and the waterproofing is up to 7' on the walls. As much of a perfectionist as I am, I think I'd really hate to have to rip out the entire shower.

I don't know. Decision is still pending.
Thanks for the input.

Bathroom overview:

Wrong slope. You can kind of see the standing water to the Right side of the drain. About 16" L x 12" W

In the back right of this photo, you can see a glimpse of the crooked junction between the floor and the wall tile.

Does this sound right? (Tile question)

Comments (5)

worthy

Gabe
Original Author

Related Discussions

kas4

DLM2000-GW

Gabe
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Does this sound right? (Tile question)

Comments (5)

worthy

GabeOriginal Author

Related Discussions

kas4

DLM2000-GW

GabeOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Gabe
Original Author

Gabe
Original Author