Daltile vs American Olean

11 years ago

My bathroom is 6'x 11' so I'm gonna need a large amount of tile. I want a 2" white hex floor tile and 3" x 6" white subway on the walls. I've been looking for over a year and no regular tile line out there has the accent color I want so I might be custom ordering from Waterworks a more expensive color liner and accent tile. So does Daltile have an advantage over American Olean or do I go strictly on price? Does Lowe's have the same quality AO as going to the AO showroom? Will I save more shopping online or do I help by using my money at a local store? Thanks!

Featured Answer

guy_tile_yahoo_com

11 years ago

Actually there is a lot of bad information on this site... Which is understandable as there are only about 10 billion flooring options on the market.

AO and Daltile's subway tile is made at the same mill. I even had to call the mill checking on AO subway tile for a customer once and the person answered the phone "Daltile". Both AO and Daltile are part of the Mohawk name brand and I have been told by my distributor that AO and Daltile subway tile are actually the same exact product. After looking at samples of both, I would have to say they do look the same.

Lowes and Home Depot sale SOME of the same tile that you will find at your local dealers. While manufacturers do make some extremely low quality tile for HD and Lowes, HD and Lowes also like to rename things. So sometimes if you find it at Lowes or HD you can find the same product elsewhere at your local tile store under a different name.

Buying tile online - the truth. There are companies online that sell flooring products. Depending on the size of your order, and the company with which you are looking at, it may not be cost effective. While there are not many good online companies, there are some out there that will save you hundreds if not thousands of dollars off of your local prices. I buy from only one online dealer and I save a good bit even though I buy direct from the manufacturer. I then sell that material to my customer for profit even though they could have bought online for the same price I did. But then again, if I didn't buy from the online guy I would be out of business. I have never heard of an online company requiring you to have a fork lift before... I've had several dropped off to my customers' curbside no problem.

The particular company I buy from online actually has told me they sell tile to HD and Lowes a lot. People go into HD or Lowes, place an order for their tile, HD or Lowes then goes and buys it from this online company, and then resales it to the customer. Kind of funny how that works sometimes, but then if I am getting better pricing from them than my local guy I guess HD and Lowes is in the same boat.

The best bet is to CALL the online company and talk to them. Read their reviews... Check their BBB rating. Make sure they are selling first grade material AND that warranties are offered with their products. A LOT of online companies don't get warranties with their products, I know of only ONE which does and that is the one I buy from. If they don't have 3rd party reviews, a good rating with the BBB, or they are not willing to answer your call or return it, then I would suggest not doing business with them. I'm not giving away where I shop as I don't want my customers knowing where I buy my material, but I promise you there are good companies out there.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

cangelmd
11 years ago
I shopped hard for tile online before and the shipping killed the price advantage. Onnline was still a little less expensive, but not worth the hassle of delivery (you needed a fork lift to accept delivery, and had to have a place to store a pallet of tile)

A small online order might be different
bill_vincent
11 years ago
Dal and AO are owned by the same parent company, and basically put out the same product. As for AO at Lowes vs a show room or distributor-- no difference..... except maybe a lower price.
Related Discussions
American Olean Coliseum vs. Daltile Carrera Star
Q
Comments (12)
I am also doing a bath in the Catarina Coliseum White and ordered several of the trim pieces. We were unpleasantly surprised when the bullnose pieces we ordered ended up being the same matte finish as the large floor tiles. I spent a lot of money on them and can't use them on my shower surround with the shiny wall tiles. No information stating this info could be found by the dealer I purchased from or by myself on the internet. As for the other pieces, the mosaics are 9 tiles x 9 tiles, filling out the same space as a single 12" floor tile. They are the same matte finish as the floor tiles. We're using this in combination with the Etruscan brown to make a "rug" in the bathroom floor. The only really weird thing is that the white mosaics have a straight edge and the brown ones are beveled all the way around. I don't know why tiles in the same line would be set up differently. There is also a quarter-round piece available, though not through Lowes. It is the shiny finish of the 10x13 wall tiles. All in all, the tiles are nice for the price, but the selection of trim pieces is severely limited. We have found that some of the carrara trim pieces out there blend pretty nicely.
...See More
Florida Tile vs. Dal-Tile for Subway Tile Wall
Q
Comments (19)
I just want to update for 2019 and say that Marazzi has moved to new ownership recently, and I've seen reviews around the web about people complaining that there is an increased grayish tint to some of the tiles with more recent production beginning around 2018. @bill_vincent stated back in 2009 in a previous comment in this thread that the Marazzi tile he'd used wasn't always square, but we had tile layers this year who recommended it as a good-quality tile, so your mileage may vary. Upon visiting a Marazzi showroom in my area, I was very impressed with the variety and style of the tile on display. Thanks for all the comments here on Florida Tile. I believe I'll avoid it based on these reviews. We used Italian-made Happy Floors tile for a recent master bathroom project and are pleased with it. The installers said it was very square, and the style we chose was a through-body porcelain. Every word-of-mouth recommendation and online review I've read about USA-made Crossville tile has been good. Apparently they have a strict system of quality control. The one complaint is that it can be expensive compared to similar tile in other lines. However, the finish coating on some of Crossville's products is supposedly high-tech to make it more cleanable and long-lasting, so maybe it would be worth it. We've found that our area ProSource seems to offer the best price on Crossville and runs periodic sales on it. Note that there is more than one tile company with the name "Crossville," referencing the location of the city of Crossville, Tennessee, where these companies are located, but I'm talking about Crossville Inc. also known as Crossville Studios. It appears that Dal-Tile's quality is across the board and varies from style to style. Thanks everyone for the input.
...See More
Anyone familiar with American Olean 2x6 subway tile?
Q
Comments (12)
Thanks all! Yes, unfortunately the Daltile is only available in 3"x6"---they also make a 2"x4" but it only comes premounted on mesh with 1/8" grout lines, and I want 1/16" grout lines. The AO tile doesn't appear to be bullnosed on the website (they have another that is) but it's hard to tell, and just not sure it's worth trekking out there if it's not even a contender. I did try Subway Ceramics but they will only sell through designers or architects so now I'm trying to figure out who I know who could order them! We'll see. I'll look for TileSource and Home and Stone, though---we'd be happy with either 2x6 or 2x4.
...See More
Help IDing tile trim, American Olean / Daltile. I'm at a loss
Q
Comments (5)
I don't plan on leaving my house, and I prefer a bathtub...so you heard it right, I'm replacing a shower w/ a tub. The floor tile is through-body porcelain. I had no idea that one could round and polish the edges of it, so it's 100% possible that that is what is going on and that it's not actually a bullnose trim from the manufacturer. That is an interesting theory! At this point my plan was to just replace w/ wood trim. I might talk to the person doing the tile install to see if they can match it w/ our extra flooring pieces via rounding and polishing it, but ripping it out and replacing w/ a wood trim seems like a fair backup plan.
...See More
EnolaEagle
11 years ago
Ive noticed that Dal Tile is a little better as far as squareness and quality but the price is usually higher... Some of the Dal and AO lines at the box stores are unavailable through the suppliers because they are run off the mill on a separate production line specifically for box stores and the quality is less to be desired because of being made for dirt cheap prices.

Todd Stull
Enola, PA
bill_vincent
11 years ago
Todd-- If you get AO or Dal subway tile from HD or Loqwes, It's the very same tile, run off the very same productiuon line as the tile you'll get from your local Dal warehouse, or a showroom. The same can be said for all lines available from both places.
bill_vincent
11 years ago
Excellent post. Except for the info on the BBB. I know of good companies that have poor ratings with the BBB because they refust to pay the listing fee. I also know of crappy companies that have a AAA rating because they DID list with them..... including Al Queda. No joke. (I don't know if it's still there, but it was about 2 months ago)

Daltile vs American Olean

guy_tile_yahoo_com

Comments (6)

cangelmd

bill_vincent

Related Discussions

EnolaEagle

bill_vincent

bill_vincent

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US