SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
abrshafer_gw

Front Door? Single or Double door?

abrshafer
10 years ago

Opinions please! I was supposed to tell my builder yesterday what front exterior door I want but I can't decide!

I have it narrowed down between a double solid 6 panel mahagony door with an 18 inch segment transom above OR doing a single door with 12 inch sidelights and transom above.

Here is a picture of my front elevation. We have changed it a little bit. It will be full stone to roofline (vs stopping at top of first floor) on three areas that bump out. Then it will be brick for the rest of the house.

Pro's for the single door is the simplicity of only one door to open and the extra light that will come in around door and into entry. Pro's for double door is more privacy (no windows exept transom above for light) and ability to move oversized furniture into house.

Here is my inspiration picture for the single door on houzz.com and the double door version would be just like this but double doors vs the sidelights. (This is also my inspiration picture for my front porch)
[houzz=https://www.houzz.com/photos/front-entry-traditional-exterior-toronto-phvw-vp~693679-Entry-traditional-exterior-toronto]
https://www.houzz.com/photos/front-entry-traditional-exterior-toronto-phvw-vp~693679-Entry-traditional-exterior-toronto

Traditional Exterior by Waterloo Design-build Schnarr Craftsmen Inc

What door do you think would be look better and also function better?

Comments (24)

  • theballs
    10 years ago

    I prefer double doors with 3/4 glass inserts, just personal preference though. That is what we have at our house, and I love them, can open both and have a ton of room to move things in/out of the house. With the glass inserts, we get a ton of bright, cheery light through them. I am a very symmetric person, though, and love the symmetry of double doors.

  • faulstr
    10 years ago

    Can't help with the doors ( I do love the look of double doors though) but do you have your floor plan posted somewhere? Your elevation is beautiful!

  • Related Discussions

    Front door color for double front entry full view storm doors with bla

    Q

    Comments (9)
    People have storm doors because, they open doors and pull down the screen for air. A storm door has a security lock on it, for safety. Phantom screens are wrecked by children and pets go right through them and can escape your property and end lost or worse. I personally, would never ever be without storm doors on my house. I have very nice wood doors, and they are original to the house and still in excellent condition because they were protected with storm doors.
    ...See More

    Double door or single door with sidelites for Georgian colonial

    Q

    Comments (7)
    Also I would not be bothered with centering the front door. Show a full elevation picture because it was obviously offset for a reason. Symmetry often times is overrated.
    ...See More

    Front double door - which door should be active?

    Q

    Comments (14)
    @strategery, @Mark Bischak, @chispa, thanks for the single door suggestion! We did consider that, but we like that we can open both doors to move large items through and love the look of the double door. @strategery, both the active and inactive doors are each 3 feet wide, which feels plenty big for us. :)
    ...See More

    Entry door - single or double, no porch

    Q

    Comments (11)
    Have you looked at the style of your home?????? No Craftsman door on this house. Additionally, the lines of the door are to line up with the lines on the arch above. Also, I would paint all the trim around the windows to match the windows white after the roof gets cleaned./ If you want to get two doors then they should match the other French doors. You'll need an arched canopy to protect your entry from the elements. Something minimal should be considered.
    ...See More
  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Thanks faulstr, I do not have the final floorplan in an electronic form that will upload on this forum but this is the last verision. We just had some minor tweaking from this version though.

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Second Floor-

    Since this version we changed the layout of the right bathroom and added a closet to the adjacent family room.

  • mrspete
    10 years ago

    I personally have no love of double doors. It makes me think, "Do they have hoop-skirted guests who have trouble fitting through a single door?

    The one perk: Double doors make it easy to get large furniture or appliances into the house.

  • millworkman
    10 years ago

    One disadvantage, unless there is a significant overhang or porch covering the entrance double doors are inherently a leaking issue.

  • rwiegand
    10 years ago

    Double doors are prone to leak air something awful (if not when new then after a while). Energy requirements for doors seem to be very lax compared to windows, we found that for many the information wasn't available.

    Unless you have a huge opening the one door you use will be narrower than a typical single door. Most everything you'd want to move into a house is made to fit through a 36" wide door.

  • kirkhall
    10 years ago

    I like the single door with sidelights, myself... Have it open so as you walk in, you see the dining wall, not the study wall.

  • zone4newby
    10 years ago

    I vote for one door. With double doors there is usually the door you use and the other door, and guests have to guess which is which.

    I would only want double doors if I anticipated having them both open on a fairly regular basis, for example if I lived in a no-bug area and were going to open the doors for ventilation & light.

  • mpg2004
    10 years ago

    We have double doors, with no sidelights and I really dislike not being able to see who is on the porch before I open the door. We do have a peephole (like in a hotel door) but it's set fairly high, so I don't find that very practical. The double doors DID make moving in to the house much easier, but I prefer the single & sidelight setup we had in our previous home.

    Hope this helps!
    Michelle

  • Annie Deighnaugh
    10 years ago

    We have double doors, but they are full of glass so we get a lot of light.

    In your case, I'd rather a single door with sidelights only because you will get more light and you have an opportunity to see who's at the door without a peephole.

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Thanks everyone!

    I asked my builder his opinion and he likes the double door better. I do like the fact the double door is an 8 foot tall door but it is only 5'4 wide so the individual door is smaller than the single. Cost is within 100 dollars of each other so that didn't help with the decision making.

    I do like the look of both doors equally. I did not realize the higher risk of leaking and less insulation with double doors. The main reason I was leaning towards the double door was the height (like the look of 8 foot door) and the ease of moving furniture in house. Plus, my husband initially prefered the double (for moving the furniture).

    However, after analyzing the pro's and con's (how often will I be moving furniture in house, etc). I believe we will be going with the single door. I really do like the inspiration photo's door and hopefully it will look as nice on my house.

    I didn't realize that this was going to tbe such a tough decision.....Wow and I have so many more to come.... Glad that I have found such a nice community to ask for advice! Thanks again.

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    ***NEW QUESTIONS***

    I decided on the single door but....

    my builder is telling me I can save a lot of money if I go with paint grade trim and a textured fiberglass door vs mahagony. He is saying the inspiration picture (in first post above) is so dark I may just want to paint the door the dark color and save the $

    Also, I could do the single door at 8' vs 6'8 (may need to keep if the mahogany here though). What do you all think of a single door being 8 ft? The foyer will have 17ft ceiling so I think it would fit the inside of house, I just don't know if it would look funny walking in such a tall single door.

  • ontariomom
    10 years ago

    I like the 8 foot doors in double doors better than a single with sidelights unless the single is quite wide as per millworkman's suggestion (very tall narrow doors can look off). Our ceilings in the entry are 12 feet so I am glad we replaced that 6 foot 8 inch door in our house prior to our addition with this taller one. The 8 foot doors looks so much better with tall ceilings. We have a fiberglass door that looks like wood. It was quite thermal, so not sure all double doors are created equal in terms of energy rating (we are in Canada and the door is north facing so we paid attention to energy ratings). Here is our door in our house under construction. I love the glass as it lets in nice light.

    Carol

  • jlband25
    10 years ago

    Your floor plan is beautiful. Very similar to what we are looking to build. Can you tell me what your total square footage is? Thanks

  • jlband25
    10 years ago

    Your floor plan is beautiful. Very similar to what we are looking to build. Can you tell me what your total square footage is? Thanks

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Jlband25

    Thanks. The first floor is 2711 sq ft and the second floor finished sq ft is 1477. Total finished sq ft will be 4188 (Lots of unfinished places though...)

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    millworkman

    Thanks for suggestion. I did get my builder to get me a quote for a 3'6 wide 8 ft tall door. It sounds really nice but it's about 1600 dollars more than the 3' wide/ 6'8 tall door. So something we are trying to decide if worth the extra cost.

    Part of the increased cost is the sidelights will need to be the additional height too.

    Thanks everyone for all the help.

  • millworkman
    10 years ago

    Think long and hard about it as you will be looking at the front of the house for a long time and you really only want to do this once!!

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Update:

    We ordered the door... and we decided on the 3' wide 8' tall single, 4 panel mahogony door.
    At first I thought it would be to narrow BUT our entrance actually is only 6'3 wide and I thought a 3'6 door and and 12 inch sidelights would be to big for the entry when taking into account trim (builder said it could work but would be really tight)
    If our entry was 7 feet or wider, we would have upgraded to the 3'6 door.
    Now waiting to see how it will look :)
    Builder says it usually is a minimum 4 week timeframe for custom doors and framing should be finished in 3-4 weeks.

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    New Update:

    I love the door! Thanks for all the great advice!!

    Here is a picture of the door we choose. I was wanting to wait till it was fully finished to post but I saw this thread linked to a newer, similar thread and thought I would update :)

    It still has protective plastic on glass, door is filthy, and they haven't gotten the custom molding for the above door yet.

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Front porch view- Can't wait till its stained and house is finished!

  • abrshafer
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Front porch view- Can't wait till its stained and house is finished!

    {{!gwi}}