Help - wrong slab installed!

10 years ago

So I spent weeks selecting my carrara marble slab for my vanity counter. Went to no less than 5 granite yards in 2 diff states and finally found a beautiful soft gray carrara marble slab with delicate veining and that pretty dot like pattern. I got the shower bench in last week and when I saw it, it didn't look like it came from the same slab - much stronger, wider, almost brown looking veining. But as I feel like I have been a pain in my contractor's rear (and I do tend to obsess), I figured they must have just cut it from a different part of the slab and that I'd live with it bc it was only the shower bench. Today they installed the vanity top and there is NO way that it is from the slab I selected. The veining is heavy and thick - over an inch wide in places and varies from a very dark gray to a brown. Seriously it cannot be the slab I selected. Of course, after telling my contractor this and showing him the photo I took of the slab at the marble yard, he called the marble yard (and they say the block number they delivered to the fabricator is the one specified) and the fabricator says their paperwork also matches the one specified. BUT I know it's not the slab I picked. So, what to do?? I feel like if I live with it, I will always be unhappy with it. Truly, I'd never have selected this slab in a million years. (In a true unfair twist of fate, my daughters' bathroom got a remnant carrara top also installed today and theirs is fine and I'd totally have taken that one). Someone clearly screwed up here - don't know if it was the fabricator or the marble yard and don't know what to do to get what I want. Thoughts?? (Of course this particular marble yard happens to be the one that was farthest away from me - an hour and a half drive each way).

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

treasuretheday
10 years ago
Oh no... That's such a disappointment! If you have a picture of the exact slab that you chose, is it possible to enlarge it enough to show what sounds like an obvious difference in the vein pattern & size? I would feel the same way and be unwilling to settle for something that I never would have chosen. Did you put 1/2 down with 1/2 due at installation? I'd withhold payment until this is resolved. If nothing else, I would expect a significant discount to persuade me to keep it. I hope you are able to get this resolved so that you can finish your project feeling good about your counters.

We fell in love with some granite that was at a large granite warehouse that fabricates all of the granite that they import. We didn't have the option to use an outside fabricator. On the one hand, that meant that we couldn't compare prices but it also meant that there wouldn't be any finger-pointing if there was a problem with the installation. We met with them to sign off on the fabrication drawings and to tape off the outlines of each piece, specifying where we wanted everything cut. That also gave me the opportunity to take pictures of exactly what would be installed.
kendog2
10 years ago
I agree with everything that Treasuretheday said. That would drive me crazy too. Take photos of the slab that was installed as well so that you'll have proof that they are different slabs. Be sure to save the photos onto a computer to make certain you don't lose them. I would send the photos to the fabricator and the marble yard. Be polite but very firm about getting this resolved. Hopefully, they will do the right thing and exchange the slab.

If you don't get anywhere, you could open a case in small claims court. I doubt that it will come to that though. Sure hope this works out for you.
Related Discussions
Help with DIY Install of wood floor on slab?
Q
Comments (2)
It is all in the floor prep, the gluing part is pretty easy. The concrete must be flat 1/8 of an inch in a 6 feet radius all over the slab. All contaminates must be removed to a residue in the pores of the concrete and the remainder encapsulated.
...See More
Help! Is my new Neolith countertops cut and installed wrong? See pic.
Q
Comments (19)
Still can't post pictures using full site on my laptop but I can post pics using phone app. So weird. Thanks everyone for the ideas. Talked to fabricator, basically he measured/cut wrong. Nothing can be done at this point. They also broke one of the dual vanity bathroom sink when installing vanity counter. When I tried to order another sink for the dual vanity, it'd been discontinued, argh. May need to remove the one sink already installed and buy 2 new sinks. I hate Murphy's Law. Here are more pics. Kitchen peninsula is 123" x 44" plus a another small section that make up the L shape. The seem was done well. A corner was chipped a little. A close up pic shows a surface scratch (really hard to see) and a crack under the surface easily seen. I put an iPhone 6 Plus and a 1.5" glass cabinet door knob on the peninsula as reference. Really love the inset cabinets.
...See More
HVAC install gone wrong -help getting out of carpet?
Q
Comments (14)
I don't see how that can be PVC primer. I'm no expert, just a DIY, but I've never seen bright blue PVC primer. My first thought was blue RTV sealant. But the way it's apparently run down one wall doesn't suggest RTV. It looks more like some kind of paint. The marks on the carpet also suggest that he set something that had been coated with whatever it is right on the carpet. What was he thinking? Regardless of what it is or what he was thinking, there's no excuse for this kind of sloppy, shoddy work. Serious question - do you think that the installer might have been drunk or high? You don't really say what you've done about this. You probably should have called the HVAC company and raised holy howdy the day after he left. If it's been a few weeks, they can probably argue that something else caused it. Hey, you have a toddler, so they can always blame the kid. :( Still, it can't hurt to have a quick chat with your lawyer. Sometimes a phone call from a suit is all it takes to get a company's attention. The common perception is that the low bidder will usually do a poor job. My experience has been that many factors affect the bid, and that there isn't anything close to 100% inverse correlation between the bid amount and the job quality. Notably, you can get solid gold references and still end up with a crummy job.
...See More
HELP! Corian install gone wrong!
Q
Comments (60)
Joseph: I enjoy reading your well informed comments. I have white Corian countertops in a kitchen that was nicely remodeled by prior owners. I have a 10 and 1/2 foot run of countertop on the longest side. No visible-not even mildly visible- seaming. It has a sink plopped down in the middle and no visible seams. The little strip that runs vertically for 1 inch under the countertop and has to make some angles/turns does have visible seams. But they are quite neat and snug. I also have Corian in the main bath with an integrated Corian sink. It has a 6 foot run with mitered edges and an integrated sink of Corian. Very pretty , seemingly very durable and again, no seams. Maybe we are just lucky in our contractors in OKLA. I hope so as I am getting ready to have serious masonry and concrete work done -storm damage-what a mess.... Anyway the Corian is great and has stood up to teenagers cutting things sans cutting board-lectures followed but it buffed out. Handymen also had to trim it a bit to install a new range which theoretically had the same dimensions exactly as the prior range. Ha ! The deliverymen just left it in the middle of the room . The guys I called are friends and not the highest end professionals but they cut the Corian and wrestled with the range for me. I love the stuff. Heaven knows what I would have had to endure with a tight granite or quartz opening. I don't even want to think about it ! It does not permanently stain either. Easter egg dyeing with a 6 year old just last week. It all comes out. Wine, tomatoes, oils ditto. Cannot recommend it highly enough.
...See More
dvarnell
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks for the good advice. Since yesterday it has lightened up a lot - which is good - apparently bc marble is so porous, it absorbs the adhesive quickly and then needs to dry out. The drying has made it better. It's still not perfect and I'm still sure it's not my slab - or else they cut it from a bad part of the slab and not the pretty section - but my husband has convinced me that I tend to overreact and that we should just live with it. Truly, we are a week away from finishing a 4 month renovation that has displaced us from half of our home and I'm just ready to be done. Is this the perfect solution? No. Is it the best solution to get us moved back into our bedrooms/bathrooms/closets and laundry room? Yes.
desertsteph
10 years ago
I'd take pics of the installed pieces too and have large prints (maybe 5x7) made of them and the original slab. it'll only cost a few $s (try at Walgreens). then I'd be looking to find WHERE on the whole slab they took the pieces they installed.

I wouldn't let anyone 'convince' me unless I could 'see' it myself. If I couldn't 'see' it, I would have the gc 'show' me where those pieces are on the whole slab. Just because 'they' tell you it's the same slab doesn't mean it IS.

Good reason behind taking a number of pics of the whole slab you pick out. Also for marking the areas of the slab you want used in your counter tops (shower, whatever) in advance of them cutting it out.

Help - wrong slab installed!

Comments (4)

treasuretheday

kendog2

Related Discussions

dvarnell
Original Author

desertsteph

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Help - wrong slab installed!

Comments (4)

treasuretheday

kendog2

Related Discussions

dvarnellOriginal Author

desertsteph

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

dvarnell
Original Author