Seasonal window cleaning; to screen or not to screen?

10 years ago

Hi! I'm Caroline (in North Dakota) and while I've been a Garden Web member for eons, and usually post on the KT; I thought I'd ask for some advice here, too.

Do you keep your window screens up year round, or do you remove them for the winter?

I clean windows twice a year. Winters are so dark here; I want every speck of light to find its way into the house.

Seven of the windows are double-hungs. The sashes tilt in so I can clean both sides of the glass from inside the house. This is the best feature of the new windows.

The worst feature is the windows' screens. They cover the entire window area; the old windows had half screens. I have to either remove the entire screen (which I usually drop and then have to go outside to retrieve ) or just wipe at the sills and pushing some of the grime under the edge of the screens' frame.

So, long question longer...

Do you think the screens would protect the windows from some of the dirt? I'm in an industrial farming land area, with open prairies, very strong winds and clouds of dust at times. The screens get very dirty between washings. Winter brings some dust relief since everything is frozen and covered with feet of snow. Still the winds will scour the snow from some of the fields an flying dirt can still be an issue.

I have to keep one screen on in the front of the house. The east window in my sewing room faces the bird feeding tree. If I take that screen off I get too many fatal bird strikes. I keep it on to protect the birds.

Should I take off all the other screens, and get more light in winter; or leave the screens on and deal with the shading and dirty sills?

From the front of the house you see the larger living room window, no screens, and the tall sewing room window with a full screen, but it is partially blocked by the white spruce tree.

I'm in an old, plain, tired house, in an old, plain, tired town. The neighboring homes' windows are a mish-mash - some windows have screens; some don't; some screens are removable; some are tacked on. I don't "have to fit a pattern" but I do want my house to look as tidy and cared for as possible.

Featured Answer

grainlady_ks

10 years ago

This is one of those times where there isn't a right or wrong answer, but you might consider these things....

1. Convenience. Is it a simple thing to remove and store the screens? The least expensive fix, but also the most work.

2. Replace them with half screens, as eteinne mentioned, but that's an expensive fix. Half screens allow the natural light in on the upper half of the double-hung windows and you still have the protection of the screens on the bottom.

Our home had half screens on it when it was built and the second year we lived here we had them replaced with full screens. The setting sun (most of our windows are on the west side of our home) is brutal in the summer and we needed the extra protection provided by full screens, but also made them UV filtering screens, which are very dark.

3. This is my personal favorite... Leave the screens, which is an economical and convenient fix - as well as providing an additional layer of protection - and add full spectrum lights/lamps to the rooms you think you'd like more natural light. Full spectrum lights are used to treat seasonal affective disorder (SAD) through the use of "light boxes" that mimic natural sunlight, especially beneficial for those living up north.

-Grainlady

Here is a link that might be useful: Verilux Full Sprectum Light

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

emma
10 years ago
I wouldn't take them off for light, it's to much trouble. I even open windows in the winter to let in a little fresh air so I want my screens on. I do have them off in the living area because I have suction cup bird feeders on the windows and I refill them by opening the window instead of wading in the snow. I sit a couple of feet from the window and get to see close ups of hummers, finches and wood peckers. One day a woodpecker was pecking at the window to let me know the feeders were empty.
eteinne
10 years ago
I find this an interesting question. If U have had half window screens on the outside, U would notice that the windows with the screen, was the 1 that looked dirty, after the first rain. U would have to take the screens off and clean and hose them off.. Anyone reading this that has ever had sliding glass patio doors, will know the side where the outside screen was always positioned, was always dirty after a few rains.. Screens act like a furnace filter and the catch all of the dust and dirt. It rains and U have spotted, dirty, windows. That, I don't want to see. I wash my windows every 2 weeks and the outside screens have been removed 4 years. Some of my houses had them on the inside, and they tilted in 2 wash and the others, back in the day U had 2 go outside 2 clean them and remove the screens. I always had clean windows and cleaned them all winter long.

This was what I used:

2 gallons of water, this can B cold

1 tsp. of Dawn

I tsp. of Jet dry. and 1 tsp. of Denatured Alcohol

U have 2 B able to use a squeegee in the winter. In the summer U just use a hose end sprayer and rinse it off. This works great and the window washer who did my windows @ my hair salon, gave it 2 me and I have been using it 4 years.

People who have vinyl clad windows should omit the alcohol. It may change the color.
Related Discussions
Screened porch or Four Season Room (Sunroom)?
Q
Comments (36)
We enclosed our previously screened-in carport, placing two small conventional windows on the SW side, facing our tiny sideyard. Both the SE side (facing our back garden) and NW side have sliding glass doors, the NW doors having glassed-in miniblinds. Both sliding doors have thermal drapes that can be used to cover them completely in weather that is too hot or too cold, and I have both a portable dehumidifier in the SW corner and and a large "end table" automatic quartz heater in the NW corner. I placed three large area carpets over the concrete slab, giving me essentially three different areas in which to arrange things. The slab absorbs both heat and cold, so if I am attentive to the room's needs it is entirely possible to keep it comfortable year round by adjusting the drapes, ventilating, and running the dehumidifier and heater. My sliding glass doors are screened, so on a good day I can open the doors at both ends and have a wonderful breeze through the entire room, and almost have the look and feel of a sun porch *and* a screened in porch, but without the inconveniences. The NE side opens into our tiny dining area, and we have an air conditioner in there. On very hot, humid days, our "sun room" is cooled sufficiently from that and a ceiling fan we added. This is a fairly low cost solution for anyone with a roofed-over carport or garage that they never park in; it's incredible the amount of living space that can be added to a home--it's now the largest room in the house, and the most attractive in terms of view, lighting, and general comfort.
...See More
3 season room screens etc
Q
Comments (5)
hee hee....my 3-seasons room has sort of evolved and taken on a life of it's own. When I first designed this house, there was going to be a deck off the diningroom, and a deck off the master, both at the back of the house. I was going to put a water garden between them. then I changed it to 2 screened porches. Then I changed it to one large screen porch, 47' long and 14' wide. Then I changed it to double-hung windows instead of screens (now it's turning into a 3 seasons room). It was supposed to be unheated...but we have since decided to add a nice fireplace and an window air-conditioner so it can be a 4-seasons room. Since it's heat and air are independent of the rest of the house, I can leave the windows open for most of the year and enjoy the sounds of nature, but I can easily close them and make the temperature comfortable on the hottest and coldest days. This room is going to be everyone's favorite beause of the view. There is a huge, double opening french door between the dining room and the sun room so for big family dinners we can just open the doors and make the two areas feel like one big area. I LOVE this design!!
...See More
3 Season Screen Porch Remodel
Q
Comments (1)
You could either use a screened porch kit to build your screened porch on your existing deck or patio - or you could construct columns, roof and frames for the screens.
...See More
Screen Porch that converts to 4-season room
Q
Comments (13)
I am looking at ReliaBilt windows at Lowes. They are made so the windows come out for cleaning - I will be taking them out and leaving them out for the summer. I will certainly be careful about buying windows with the correct heat gain coefficient and U factor. I am concerned if I do not completely take out the windows, I will still get too much solar gain in the summer from the south facing windows. As to water entering the room: The north wall is the original house wall so there will be no windows there. The east wall is beside a covered porch so no rain will enter there. The south wall could be problematic for sun and rain. I am hoping to minimize these problems by having a 2-ft roof overhang and then running an 18" awning type porch valance across the overhang. The west wall will also have a 2-ft overhang. These windows will have awnings to help protect the interior from sun and rain. I do plan to fully insulate the room and to use a direct-vent gas stove to warm it in the winter. I don't plan to cool the room at all. I will install 2 ceiling fans (the room will be 16 x16). I live in the mid-atlantic region. I looked at the Harvey Industries system, but they are not located near me. I plan on having a regular foundation. I appreciate all the comments.
...See More
oldfixer
10 years ago
My screens come down, and storm windows go up. Clean is not an issue. Who wants to look out at winter weather? UGH.
emma
10 years ago
I do, I love nature and the birds at my feeders and the fox cubs playing near the trees.
rockpine
10 years ago
I take my screens off in the late fall. I love every bit of light shining in my house in the winter. In the spring i give my screens a good scrubbing before putting them back up. I need to clean my screens once a year anyway so i might as well take them off once and leave them off until spring.
~diane

Seasonal window cleaning; to screen or not to screen?

grainlady_ks

Comments (6)

emma

eteinne

Related Discussions

oldfixer

emma

rockpine

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US