skip to main content

Building a Home

Sunroom...which roof should we choose?

14 years ago

I posted this in remodeling, since it's a room addition, but haven't received much response, so I thought I'd try the mecca of design knowledge/advice here.

We're adding a sunroom onto the back of our house (the room with the chimney going out the top in the photos below). We're trying to decide whether to make it a hip roof, which matches more with the style of the rest of the house, or a gable roof, which seems more open facing the back yard. We're on a large lot overlooking a lake, and not too many people would see it from the side view. Here are elevations of our 2 options:

Here are the front and back of the house now.

And FWIW, here's the floor plan of the addition. Any comments or suggestions are appreciated. Ignore the note that says "master bedroom."

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

sue36
14 years ago
Just based on exterior looks, I prefer the gable. The hip seems odd at the top.
jsepul
14 years ago
I personally disagree. I would go with the hip roof. It makes the addition seem like it is original to the house.

While you have some "peaks on your front elevation, you don't have any on the rear. This makes the hip roof seem more logical for the rear. If you are seeking to "open up" the room to the backyard, why not add some skylights?

Skylights are a great way to let sunlight in. They help bring warmth in during the winter. In the summer, you can close the shades or keep them open and let the sun in. Sunlight really makes a space feel larger.

If you are worried about them leaking, then you need to find another contractor. Skylights if done properly by a good contractor, will not leak. If one right, they are just an continuation of the roof. A glass shingle if you will. The skylights of the 80's are no more. They are much different now and are made of newer more "space age" materials.

See the link below for a good article on skylights. adding them now will be much cheaper than adding them after.

Here is a link that might be useful: With new materials and proper installation, skylights can save energy, lift moods
Related Discussions
Help! 2nd attempt - what color roof should I choose
Q
Comments (13)
I hate to waste peoples' time while I'm learning. You can test your attempts by using the "Preview Message" function. You can preview your attempt, and then don't post the final message. I'd like to learn to quote people too. This is also done with angle brackets -- these things . Here's how. 1. Highlight the part of the text you'd like to quote. 2. Right click. 3. Click on "copy". 4. Then type two italic commands, like this: [i][/i] -- EXCEPT that instead of square brackets, use angle brackets. You'll notice that the two commands are the same, except that the second command has a slash. The first command starts the italic, then second command ends it. 5. Place your cursor between the two italic commands. 6. Right click. 7. Click on "Paste". This will paste your text between the italic commands. The command will look like this: [i]I'd like to learn to quote people too.[/i] EXCEPT that you will have angle brackets, not square brackets. 8. Click on "Preview Message". 9. You will now see your italics, like this: I'd like to learn to quote people too. This system also works with underscore commands (use a "u") and boldface commands (use a "b") and strikeout commands (use a "s").
...See More
choosing roof tile color
Q
Comments (0)
hi there, not sure which forum this goes in, but our GC just told us that we needed to choose our roof for our 1949 ranch house by tomorrow (sorry, i dont have pics..need to figure out how to do it)...but not sure if it matters anyways as we're going thru an extensive remodel (we cant live in our house) and the exterior is going to be completely different anyways. we live in southern california. as of now we're thinking on skim (smooth) coating our stucco and it'll probably be some kind of beige color w/ dark navy blue shutters. we're looking at monierlife saxony shake lightweight tiles in either walnut or charcoal (although smokey looks good too). basically we're needing to decide whether the roof should be either greyish (hence charcoal) or brownish (hence walnut). any thoughts/recos would be SOO great!!! Thanks!
...See More
Which builder should I choose?
Q
Comments (34)
Contract types are frequently interchanged on this forum but are essential to understand as one does not get to treat their build like cost plus in one aspect, and then treat it like fixed price in another aspect. Which is this contract? One doesn’t know for sure but can assume with allowances it is likely a fixed price contract, so in this instance, one is getting a price for the job, not itemized lists of costs. Fixed price contracts can and often do provide fairly detailed bids, but this is not the same thing as the builder opening his books to you. If you want that, then proceed with cost plus. On the topic of markups, expect to pay markup on cost plus or fixed price contracts, as the home buyer should and does on any product they purchase. Trying to remove half the materials from mark-up as frequently suggested on this forum is asking the builder to work for less amount with greater risk. More expensive and complicated materials are frequently more to project manage, more effort in labor and skill to install, and CERTAINLY more risk for the builder should some of these materials need replaced during the build or the warranty period. If one paid markup on $5,000 worth of counter tops but changed to $25,000 worth of counter tops with no additional markup, it’s easy to see how the builder is in a terrible spot if he had to replace $25,000 worth of counter tops on a $5,000 worth of mark-up fee. Simple math really. Mark ups never cover all the potential things that can go wrong in a build, but they are a way to manage risk, which is real in any build. Increasing risk and work load to the builder by adding lots of expensive and complicated materials to manage without correspondingly applying the mark up fee is essentially asking them to take more risk for nothing in return. Many, especially those with sound business sense, will refuse to do it, rightfully so.
...See More
Need a new roof! What shingle should we put on our house?
Q
Comments (7)
after extensive hail damage we have to get a new roof. I love the look of slate but it is out of our budget. One Roofer suggested Certainteed Landmark Pro Black Moire and another roofer suggested Timberline HD Charcoal. I need help! Going for a classic and timeless look!
...See More
lyfia
14 years ago
I would prefer the gable as it looks better to me with the chimney and ties in with the turret roof.
persnicketydesign
14 years ago
Another vote for gable. I think that it will tie the front & back together nicely and accentuate the turret.
lmarletto
14 years ago
I vote for the gable roof too. I think it looks better from the angle that most people will see it. It also leaves room for a palladian window if that appeals to you. In terms of relating to the main house roof, historically, small additions often had simpler roofs than the main one, so I think the gable actually looks *more* appropriate.
weedyacres
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks for all your advice. We're leaning towards the gable because it'll allow us to have a (slight) cathedral ceiling and a window above the slider. The palladian (I assume that's the triangular shaped ones) or eyebrow are more than we want to spend, because they'd have to be custom sized, but we'll likely do a 2-foot transom to make it even more open and light.

Related Stories

LANDSCAPE DESIGN Which Pergola Is Right for You?

By Joanna Tovia

A covered pergola can increase the time you spend in your outdoor living space. Which covering should you choose?

KITCHEN DESIGN Houzz Quiz: Which Kitchen Backsplash Material Is Right for You?

By Jennifer Ott Design

With so many options available, see if we can help you narrow down the selection

KITCHEN DESIGN Open vs. Closed Kitchens — Which Style Works Best for You?

By Vanessa Brunner

Get the kitchen layout that's right for you with this advice from 3 experts

KITCHEN DESIGN 12 Great Kitchen Styles — Which One’s for You?

By Sheila Schmitz

Sometimes you can be surprised by the kitchen style that really calls to you. The proof is in the pictures

REMODELING GUIDES Which Window for Your World?

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

The view and fresh air from your windows make a huge impact on the experience of being in your house

TRADITIONAL ARCHITECTURE Roots of Style: Dutch Colonial Homes Settle on the Gambrel Roof

By Steven Corley Randel, Architect

Colonists from the Netherlands brought the gambrel roof and other quaint details. Has your home adapted any of these features?

REMODELING GUIDES Architect's Toolbox: Roofs that Connect Earth and Sky

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

A roof's design can connect us to the land or lift us above it all. Which style is for you?

GARDENING GUIDES Healthy Home: How to Go Green With a Living Wall or Roof

By Jess McBride

See 10 ways to add this earth-friendly element to your home

EXTERIORS Roofing Materials: Slate Makes for Fireproof Roofs That Last

By Rachel Grace

It stands up to weather and fire without losing its high-end look. But can your budget handle it?

MORE ROOMS 11 Elements of the Perfect Sunroom

By Natalie Myers

Relax in your own sunny retreat right at home — these features will make your sunroom comfortable, inviting and entertaining

Sponsored

46 Reviews

Loudoun County's Top Kitchen & Bath Designer I Best of Houzz 2014-2022

More Discussions

February 2023: Building a Home

45

What Cabinet Brands Worth Considering

25

looking for LVP or hybrid floors to match rift cut white oak

0

Does this cabinet layout look right?

23

Looking for a new up & coming source of modern house plans…

2