Skip Trowel vs. Knockdown Cost

16 years ago

Would you please give me a rough idea of the cost difference between having my drywall texture Skip Trowel vs. Knockdown? I know that ST is done by hand and Kd is sprayed so I'm sure that ST is more labor intensive and more costly. But what is the difference in cost? Another one I really like is called Pull Trowel. What does that cost?

Thanks.

Featured Answer

renovator8

9 years ago

In New England the dominant wall surface tradition for over 300 years has been smooth plaster with paint or wallpaper. Therefore the plaster trade has always been highly skilled and today that tradition is carried on with veneer plaster on blue board and taped drywall is used only for DIYers or patching. The surface of veneer plaster is very hard, difficult to damage and easy to repair. In the Boston area It is usually cheaper than the lowest level of taped drywall finish. Textured finished are rare and a definite disadvantage when selling a house.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

pioneergal
16 years ago
kcthatsme,

I was just quoted the price of $1 sq. foot difference between ST and KD. ST being the more expensive but worth it IMOP.

Hope this helps...

Oh yeah, this North Central Texas (FW) price. It may be different in your area.
galore2112
16 years ago
Knock down is knocked down by hand after spraying. And it requires skill to knock down evenly.

Skip Trowel is much, much more forgiving. It is a finish designed to look "old". It is looking old because it is a comparably unsophisticated technique (you just need a trowel as a tool, no sprayer).
Price difference is more about what people are willing to pay than about actual labor difference (I've done both myself and find skip troweling to be faster and easier that knock down for a good result).
Related Discussions
What does it cost to hang and texture drywall in your area
Q
Comments (15)
I just had drywall and taping completed and I paid $70 a sheet for 75 sheets. It came to $2.19 a square foot. The work is excellent with very little in the way of clean up. They basically plastered the whole sheet. This is for the Toronto, Ontario area. Other quotes I got were for hourly (lowest was $40). I got these two guys to do all the work (plumbing, electrical and drywall) for about $18/hr. They completed 1000SF in 10 days (9 hour per day).
...See More
help me cut costs please
Q
Comments (16)
Pricing on things like drywall finishes vary quite a bit in different parts of the country, and while the textured look is "in" thru the western states, smooth is the norm on the east cost and therefore the most cost effective. I'm in NC and 15 yrs ago smooth (ceilings) were an upcharge over textured. 5 yrs ago it had reversed. I agree with the 24" oc wall framing, unless it's one that carries floor load from above. Do insulate the walls, and the perimeter joist band (if it's not already done) Do seal the main floor system to the exterior basement walls before you start framing. Don't put the insulation in the ceiling above. It will cause too much temperature isolation. For sound, use rubber or metal isolaton strips to hang the drywall. The interior doors and base sound a bit high, but I bet they are stain grade wood, which is pretty pricey. Last and most important, if you have done your research (references, insurance, and check with the local building inspection department about his inspection record) and this guy is reputable, suck it up and pay the price. The last thing you want to do is start off the job 2nd guessing the builder, especially if you don't have any real knowlede of the building process. If you have any conceren, at the end of end of the job hire an independant home inspector to check it out before issuing final payment. If's he's a real professional, he won't see it too much of an insult, but keep in mind the same criteria applies when you hire an inspector, and don't hire a rookie. 3 months of classes at the community college may turn a used car saleman into a home inspector, but it won't make him a good one. Look for a min. of 5 yrs experience in construction + 3 yrs in the home inspection game. A successful remodeling experience can sometimes be more than you want to spend, but it's always cheaper than an unsuccessful one.
...See More
Smooth or knockdown textured walls
Q
Comments (17)
All the walls in my home are smooth except for my downstairs basement living area that we finished ourselves and did the texture ourselves. It a more casual room, tv and kids play room. We did the knockdown texture ourselves with a thing that splattered the texture on then smoothed down. It's more random than orange peel but about the same "depth". It's more randomness makes it easy to repair any damage. I wouldn't want it my whole home but like it in that one room. I probably would dislike it immensely if in every room. But..if you ever want to do wall paper don't get it. Texture was in alot of new homes in Texas where we lived for a while, bathrooms too. I knew of several people who wanted wall paper later and spent weeks trying to smooth out the walls, yuck. The finish I have is looks like the skip trowel technique on this YouTube video, skip to end of video. https://youtu.be/C_cUnSEXnrM
...See More
Evaluating CMU construction for cost savings?
Q
Comments (110)
"I have done what DE is attempting to do and just as many people here told me it couldn't be done. If I heard it once I must have heard it a thousand times, houses always cost more to build than buying new. Yet, I built the house for significantly less than any house in the area would cost and sold it for the same amount as those houses. The difference being, I was never going to live in the house. Creating profit versus creating value are two different things. " I appreciate this . I have heard too that buying is cheaper than building but then I think people start at tract builder and add from there, while I'm starting at tract builder and deleting things. for example, no tract builder would build without a garage. I dont think they would use stained concrete floors, and if they want to sell it they wouldnt ever consider exposed concrete block or vinyl . All the new tract homes around here have granite countertops. I dislike that shizz with a passion. We do plan to live in this house though..Our goal was always to have a bigger lot - thats why we are building. the focus is less on the house and more on just having more space in the outdoors for the family to hang out, thats why I spent more on the land than we are going to spend on the house( I know your'e going to tell me that lot cost should never be more than 25% of total cost :) ).
...See More
kcthatsme
Original Author
16 years ago
Thanks for the responses.
robin0919
9 years ago
Renovator......I can't IMAGINE that blue board/veneer plaster is CHEAPER than regular drywall!!!! That sounds 'impossible' because it is ALLOT more labor involved. What is the s/f cost for both in your area? Are the subs in your area union?
The plaster is what they always use on TOH, but they never talk about the cost.

This post was edited by robin0919 on Mon, Sep 1, 14 at 23:30
ILoveRed
9 years ago
R8-that is amazing.

We recently purchased the house my dh grew up in after his mother passed. All plaster walls.

I don't know if there are any contractors here that even do plaster anymore. Midwest.
ksc36
9 years ago
Here in MA I just paid about $1.50/sq/ft for blueboard and plaster. That includes all materials and labor. I have no idea what drywall prices are, haven't hired a taper in 30 years. I always looked at taping as more labor intensive for an inferior finish.
robin0919
9 years ago
KS...are you a GC? That price is very good. I'm shocked it's that low. Curious....was the company that did the work union?
The last time I got a quote for sheetrock in this area(SE) it was around .75/sf but that was 9 yrs ago. Just did a search and found a web site that you can put in your zip and get an estimate of what it is in your area, it says around $1.70/sf here now. I would much prefer plaster but I really don't think anyone in the SE even knows how to apply it. I think it's really a trait that's very specific in local areas in the country. My wife grew up in a house that had plaster walls that was built in the early 1900's. Those were the first plaster walls I ever saw and haven't seen any since.
Lindsay De Hoyos
2 years ago
I just bought 4,480 sq ft home. The painter gave me a quote for $13K for wallpaper removal and painting only. After removing the wallpaper, he said there is no texture without his knowledge so he charged me another $7K for adding texture. After learning he started the knockdown texture style, we stopped and prefer as smooth as possible. The smoothest he could go is to do skip trowel. So, he charged us for more so it went up to $7,600 for skip trowel since it takes longer. Is it fair to charge me extra after charging texture (didn’t say what kind) for $7K? This is feeling so unrealistic. Please advise.

Skip Trowel vs. Knockdown Cost

renovator8

Comments (9)

pioneergal

galore2112

Related Discussions

kcthatsme
Original Author

robin0919

ILoveRed

ksc36

robin0919

Lindsay De Hoyos

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Skip Trowel vs. Knockdown Cost

Comments (9)

Related Discussions

kcthatsmeOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

kcthatsme
Original Author