Dishwasher drawer vs 18 inch dishwasher

gb85

14 years ago

Hi all,

Anyone have experience with both a dw drawer and an 18 inch dw? What are the pros and cons?

thanks

Featured Answer

antss

14 years ago

you can get a cookie tray in the 18" , darn near impossible with anything else in a single drawer.

Comments (9)

hidroman
14 years ago
Haven't ever used a drawer, but you too can notice that dishdrawers have square racks as regular 24" DWs

18" diswashers are a compromise for very small kitchen. I mean : draw the biggest possible circle in a 24" x 24" square, then the biggest possible circle in a 18" x 24" rectangle.

You can see that corners in the square are closer to the circle, while rectangle ones are not that close
Spray arms draw a circle while spinning.
So the spray action in rack corners is more effective in square rack designs (DD and 24" DW) than rectangular rack design (18" DW)

If one is aware of this and loads a 18" DW consequently, there's no problem.
But if you load tall and narrow juice glasses soiled of orange juice in the corners of a rectangular rack (18" DW), you can't pretend the will be cleaned as well as a dishdrawer or a regular 24" machine do

Anyway a single drawer holds less items than the two racks of a 18" machine
A regular 18" or 24" machine is more flexible than a double dishdrawer : in case of extralarge items you can raise the upper rack or even take it out (Bosch), with a dishdrawer ... you can handwash.

I guess space is not your issue (a single drawer is as large as a 24" machine), rather you aren't supposed to have a daily full load in a regular 24" DW
In this case be aware that latest european 24" DW have load size sensing devices and use 7-8 litres of water (round 2 gallons) for a *full= two racks* load. The *single* dishdrawer uses 1.95 gallons per load, so partially loaded 24" machines can even use less water than a *single* drawer.

To cut a story short : if you have place go for a regular machine : it cleans better, you'll have plenty of place for those times you have guests at dinners and on the other side you can run partial loads without feeling "guilty"
Related Discussions
Miele 18 inch Dishwasher Review - with Pictures
Q
Comments (10)
Thanks everybody - you're welcome and I'll post another report some time later in February about our Bosch dishwasher. robert laundry: The European market has very strict requirements as far as energy consumption goes. Every dishwasher (and most other major appliances) carry so called Energy Labels. In order for a dishwasher to achieve an A rating for energy use (very low) the temperatures have to be lowered. At the same time, however, the label also provides information about the DW's cleaning and drying performance. So while the temps have to be lowered - washing and drying times have to be extended in order to achieve an A rating for washing & drying. However, all this applies only to one specific cycle usually called Eco, Save Energy or similar. Other cycles are faster, though.
...See More
18-inch dishwasher
Q
Comments (5)
We had an 18" dishwasher (GE) and it did have a problem to look out for. It was totally reliable for the 10 years we had it, but the racks were too narrow to properly hold our fiesta ware plates. I would recommend that you make certain that you will be able to fit your dishes, etc. in it if you have anything but flat, standard plates.
...See More
18" vs 24" dishwasher
Q
Comments (10)
Thanks for all the responses. The reason I'm thinking of a smaller dishwasher is because my island will be an L shape. I'd like to fit a double basin sink, dishwasher, microwave and trash pullout inside the L if that's even possible. Currently, I have a triangular island with a double basin sink in the inner triangle part and a dishwasher to the right inside the triangle. My microwave is the hood over my range, and the trash bin is a stand alone. I'm doing a new hood with no microwave and I don't have extra counter space for it. I really enjoy the double basin sink but I'd be willing to do a single if I could fit everything in. It's my only sink, not a prep sink. Also, I prefer a taller trash bin vs an under the sink short one. I store my cleaning supplies under my sink. I'd rather not do a stand alone again. My new island will be approximately 4.5' x 5.5' on the inside, or just under that. One side faces my great room so I want to keep it clean, the other side faces the table and I'll do stools there.
...See More
18 inch dishwashers - can they take an 11 inch plate?
Q
Comments (2)
Not sure if this helps but in my 18" dishwasher the plates are put in sideways not frontways. so I've never had an issue. I assume the height from the top to the bottom rack is standard.
...See More
dadoes
14 years ago
you can get a cookie tray in the 18" , darn near impossible with anything else in a single drawer./>Nonsense. A 12"x15" cookie sheet in a DishDrawer, with a 11" skillet and lid and several other items, including some things not seen behind the sheet and under the plastic container at the front right. I could get in a bit more with more careful/structured loading ... but didn't need to, had just these items to be finished.
kitchenobsessed
14 years ago
Assessing the photo above and my friend's DDs, my 18" Miele will hold more than one DD, esp. due to the 3rd rack. I have not had any problems with items not getting clean.
dadoes
14 years ago
Of course a full-height double- or triple-rack unit should hold more than a single drawer ... but neither is the pic above a maxed-out drawer. Both drawers of a typical 24" wide double-drawer DishDrawer fully/properly loaded likely would hold more than an 18" machine. There are no 18" width DishDrawers for tight horizontal space considerations, but there are single-drawer units for vertical space considerations.

Water use per drawer depends on the selected cycle. At 0.8 gals per fill, my DD603 (6.5 years old) ranges from 2.4 gals for the Fast cycle (wash-rinse-rinse), 3.2 for Normal/Eco (wash-wash-rinse-rinse or rinse-wash-rinse-rinse), 4.0 for Normal (wash-rinse-wash-rinse-rinse), to 5.6 gals for the Heavy cycle (wash-rinse-rinse-wash-rinse-rinse-rinse). 1.95 gals quoted on the newest model is likely the Fast cycle with redesign on the mechanism for lower water consumption.

DishDrawer loading examples
gb85
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks all for the info. Does anyone know where I can get the water usage for all dishwashers?
whirlpool_trainee
14 years ago
Some pictures of my grandma's 18" Miele dishwasher.

Alex

Here is a link that might be useful: 18 inch Miele
colorlady
13 years ago
I'm looking at a single drawer dishwasher to be our only dishwasher. There are just 2 of us and we don't put big clunky things in our full sized dishwasher anyway. Only glasses, silverware, dishes, soup bowls. I have the space for a full size but I don't like bending down to load and empty it. Just like I'd rather use a wall oven than one under a range. Would appreciate anyone's personal experience with one or opinion of this option.
davidro1
13 years ago
When I did a thorough study of 18" DW in 2008, some of them had a 1/2 load cycle. It's practical for people who have small loads. In my opinion it should use less soap too. But, all things considered, it isn't a big thing either way. In terms of water savings or other savings.

hiroman is generally right about most or all of his comments, if I reaqd them a certain way, in a certain context, but I also know that people who have 18" dishwashers are all happy. None have ever written in gardenweb or other forums to complain in any way (after searching I have found no complaints.)

hth