Ventilation question

12 years ago

I have been researching on the forum for the past several weeks during the planning phase of our kitchen update and really appreciate all of the valuable information I have learned.

I have a 30 yo electric downdraft cooktop in a 50 inch wide brick alcove which sits between double ovens on the left and refrigerator on right. The problem is that the new 30 in induction cooktops I'm looking at are all about 20-21 in deep and require 2-3 in at the front and back. This doesn't leave any room for the downdraft (counter is 25 in deep). Do you think it would work to bump out the cabinetry/counter 3 in or so to provide the space? Would it look funny to have it sticking out past the brick?

I had originally considered capping off the downdraft and going w a recirculating vent. Have since learned that is not a great option. I'm afraid venting through to the roof is cost prohibitive due to the positioning of the kitchen. Also not sure how effective it would be since the space for the insert is only 16 in deep and 45 in above the cooktop. I really don't use the downdraft much. Just occasionally when frying bacon or cooking fish. The grate is covered with a towel most of the time to keep the cold air from coming in so I tend to forget I have it.

Sorry for the long ramble but hope the info helps with any advice you might have. Thanks for your help!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

kaseki
12 years ago
Even in a alcove a downdraft vent system should be expected to miss a lot of effluent, but it is better than nothing.

Why is there a cold draft? There should be a damper between the outside and the vent system, or between the vent system fan and the vent aperture.

To get to the point: I deliberately bumped out the cabinet and soapstone counter where my induction cooktop is by three inches. Your reason is one of mine. I haven't noticed any snickering from guests, but don't have a statistically significant data base from which to draw a conclusion.

kas
thrauli
Original Author
12 years ago
Kaseki, thanks for the response. It's reassuring to hear someone else had the same issue. In all my searches either the cooktop being replaced was in an island w enough space or had overhead venting. As far as the cold air is concerned, I'm sure at some point there was a damper of some sort but it has long since broken. I'm sure if I took the time it could easily be fixed but I'm too lazy and just use the towel :)
Related Discussions
ventilation question (roof vents AND fans)
Q
Comments (3)
If you go the exhaust fans route, put the fans as high as you want cooling. Hot air rises so the upper part of the greenhouse will always be hotter than the lower. You want the exhaust fans to push out the hottest air and replace it with the coolest air possible. Natural ventillation, roof vents, roll up sides, etc, will cool to about 10-30F warmer than outside. To do that you need vents that are 40% of the area of the greenhouse. Most are much smaller. So you have a very hot greenhouse except right at ground level where it can be reasonable. As discussed earlier exhaust fans with one air exchange per minute can cool to about 10-15F warmer than outside. Two exchanges per minute will cut the temperature rise in half. In my area with moderate dew points an evaporative cooling system will keep the inside as cool or cooler than outside with one air change per minute. The best evaporative system is exhaust fans and a wet wall opposite. A house evap cooler pushing in cool air is not as good because the cooler air pushed in mixes with hot air inside and a mix is pushed out. You want to exhaust the hottest air and replace with the coolest no matter the system.
...See More
ventilation question - can I go with fewer CFM's?
Q
Comments (22)
There are many rules of thumb for cfm, even linear dimensions of the hood edges excluding walls. One can also calculate on the basis of effluent velocity and hood aperture. (I've covered that somewhere.) But all of these will, as pointed out above, likely end up being well over 300 cfm for any hood that would work with a 48 inch cooktop. Most of us would agree that if financially feasible, a properly heated, pressurized, balanced MUA system is needed, and, (in my view) the affordability of a 48-inch Wolf range should include the MUA cost in the project. However, there may be ways of circumventing some of the costs. One way (won't work for fireplaces) is to have any other combustion appliances (furnaces and hot water heaters and gas dryers) in a room that is isolated from the kitchen (air flow wise) with its own not necessarily well heated minimal MUA (after all, the flow rate for these appliances will be small). Then the safety issue is accounted for, even if the inspector won't care. Then a passive MUA design (a damper in a duct) passing outside air to a heater would be sufficient to pull in sufficient replacement air. The kitchen pressure would be low (lower if filtering is used), the hood flow would not be what one might expect, but the code would be met and safety achieved. A 10-inch duct with pressure sensitive damper flowing air (due to negative house pressure) past a heater of some type (think 100 kBTU/hr order of magnitude) would be the type of heater required, maybe larger in MN. You would save the cost of the big blower needed for pressure balanced MUA, and the cost of a proper pressure control system and its tuning. kas
...See More
Hood ventilation question for new build
Q
Comments (3)
My kitchen is fairly contemporary. I wanted an efficient hood so bought an undercabinet Broan that was new with features I thought would keep it from being noisy. Didn't buy the cheapest because wanted quality. Turns out there is a slant to the underside which I hate. I posted on this forum and some indicated that the slant would make the hood more efficient. Had I chosen to have a hood with a cover, I could have made the underedges of the cover totally horizontal and could have more easily covered up the slant. Details are a bit too complicated to post here but bottom line, I think the cover gives you some advantages later to get the exact look you want, that's my experience anyway. You can always get a stainless cover if you like stainless. I'm a newbie and not a pro at this so don't take my input as the last word. Good luck to you. Wish I would have put in the hood vent first before anything else. It was my biggest installation challenge. (I'm my own G.C.)
...See More
Attic insulation ventilation question
Q
Comments (6)
no foam mike_home, contractor is proposing blown insulation either fg or cellulose, only OP knows. just google baffles for attic ventilation OP. lots of pics there.baffles are installed on roof at eaves to do two things. one is to keep insulation at low point of eaves/soffits from clogging up air flow. the other is to establish a pathway for air to enter attic at soffit/eaves. attic ventilation that works is one of these three methods. all are stand alone, not strategies to be mixed. gable end vents. soffit/eaves may or may not have vents cut into them. soffit/eaves vents with ridge vent at peak of roof. or lastly soffit/eaves vents with passive vents installed on roof. the idea is to take air from soffits & vent from gable end, ridge vent or passive vents. google attic ventilation for more detailed info. prior to adding insulation minimal air sealing of air barrier (ceiling of living space) from living space to attic is done. for example recessed lights (Insulation contact not IC air tight recessed lights) would be addressed prior to insulation. much harder to dig out each area to be air sealed with newly installed insulation. fortunately, you can do a lot of air sealing from inside the living space. making as tight of an air barrier between living & attic spaces is one of the first steps to efficiency (and better air quality that goes along with it). it is easier to heat/cool a house with minimal air leakage. first area to air seal is house to attic. then floor to crawlspace (now that we have that info) once the air sealing is completed...then insulate. (3" closed cell foam installed on underside of floor, installed from under the house) if you have 8, 12 or 20+ inches of insulation & there is air moving through it...then it isn't performing. keep in mind that there is a diminishing return for more inches of insulation. the first 6" of insulation does most of the thermal barrier work, added insulation above this 6" saves you less & less $$ in utility costs. meeting code minimums is the least you can do. here in La. R0-30 is code, but people often have R-38. not a big jump in price, and not a big savings in utility costs. you make your own call on what to be installed. are you willing to do any work? (ie caulking etc) whats your location? best of luck
...See More
kaseki
12 years ago
In my case the cook-top is on a peninsula, part of which is a bar configuration, and I wanted to move the cooking away from the bar as well as shifting the island hood away from the bar.

However, I use a large island hood (also covers an induction wok hob) and it is about 34 inches above the cooktop surface. So with a high flow rate blower I can pretty much keep all cooktop effluent out of the house.

The difficult to solve problem is capturing oven effluent when an oven door is opened. I have registers above the wall ovens connected to a separate ventilation system that try to capture, but there is just too much spillage into the room upon door opening to be immediately successful.

The "eyebrow" scheme used in commercial cooking would be expected to be more effective, but far from fully effective. Any scheme built in by the manufacturer might dry out moisture in the oven unless a means of replacement were included.

You might consider ways in which your alcove could be enhanced to curl the effluent that passes the downdraft around where it might have a second chance for capture. Sheet metal formed to resemble a closed off recirculating hood might help.

Anyway, good luck.

kas
User
12 years ago
Don't assume that venting upwards would be cost prohibitive. If the alcove is within 30 feet of an exterior wall, it could be possible for a professional to route ductwork to the exterior. It's worth exploring before settling on a downdraft.
thrauli
Original Author
12 years ago
Thanks for the responses. I will look into those options.
beintruth
12 years ago
I had a downdraft and just got rid of it. It was so ineffective and really effected the cooking temps of my gas range. I highly recommend not having a downdraft. It sounds like you could have a vented hood.
Good luck

Ventilation question

Comments (6)

kaseki

thrauli
Original Author

Related Discussions

kaseki

User

thrauli
Original Author

beintruth

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Ventilation question

Comments (6)

kaseki

thrauliOriginal Author

Related Discussions

kaseki

User

thrauliOriginal Author

beintruth

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

thrauli
Original Author

thrauli
Original Author