As you can probably tell from the number of entries in this newsgroup, there are a lot of fans of the Members Mark Grill available at Sams Club. I am a new owener of this grill and am extremely happy with it. So far I have done rotisserie chicken, burgers, chicken breast and wild turkey on my new grill and this grill does an awesome job. Installation is very easy, and for the money, you can't beat it.

Of the four barbecues you mentioned, IMHO the only one worth buying is the Napoleon. Why? Napoleon offers a limited lifetime warranty on their grills and is built as such. MHP is cheaply made and Broilmaster was great 30 years ago, but now its no better than Fiesta. If you do high heat grilling a lot (90% or more of the time) you should consider the infrared sear burner. If not, don't buy it. You give up half your space for a burner you can only use a fraction of the time. The turn down on ceramic infrared burners is very small and using that part of the grill when that burner is off can cause the ports to plug with grease.

MHP makes a real nice product. Broilmaster is cast Aluminum but one of the best ( and oldest) cast grills on the market. This is a company which has changed hands recently but they make a legendary grill. Remember one thing when it comes to Grills. You get what you pay for. I don't think that you can get a durable stainless grill for less than $1000. I am sure I will get some who will say different but the cost of quality stainless steel (say 304 which has a high nickel content) is quite high and gets higher every year.

Why pay for sheet metal and cheap burners when you can learn, compare, and get a quality grill in the same price range? For Gas Grills 101 check out "How to Choose", "Major Differences", and "What to Look for" at www.picksinc.com/GasGrills/home.htm For Gas Grills 201 check out the "GrillTalk Message Board" at www.picksinc.com/Grilltalk.htm Don't spend $500 or $1000 for a grill that is poorly constructed, made of sheet metal, and has cheap burners!