How to tell determinate from indeterminate?
2ajsmama
10 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (13)
seysonn
10 years ago2ajsmama
10 years agoRelated Discussions
determinate vs. indeterminate tomatos
Comments (12)Until the last few years I've never grown many determinates. Most years 2-3 varieties at most. And usually one plant of each. Two of a variety at most. Although many of the market growers I know have always grown 25-40% determinates. As most will tell you I can be a little hard headed. But the last 4 years of drought has finally changed my planting habits some. The last 4 years with the drought, late springs and early heat I've only had a short harvest window early and another late. Determinates and semi-determinates have been the best performers production wise. Like Dawn stated determinate varieties vary and some will bear longer and have repeated flushes. The advantage of a indeterminate in a normal year is the continuous production. Although the initial flush will usually be smaller they will continue to set for the whole growing season. The last 4 years except in a few instances that hasn't been the case. Randy's Brandy has been an exception. This year as I expect at least some continuation of the drought cycle I'll be planting more determinate and semi- determinate varieties. When I post my 2013 list later I'll try to remember and list them as such. I haven't grown as many varieties as some but overall I'm like Dawn and prefer indeterminates for flavor and also continual production. Jay...See MoreHomestead semi-determinate or indeterminate
Comments (4)The company below lists Homestead 24 as a determinate tomato. So does this one, though it doesn't have any identifying #s or letters. Here is a link that might be useful: Homestead Tomato...See MoreDifferences between determinate and indeterminate
Comments (6)As has been pointed out to you before, determinate tomato varieties are not perennials. %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% No sir> All tomatoes belong to the same genus: As It has been pointed out to you and do it again. (from wikipedia) >>>The tomato is the edible, often red fruit/berry of the nightshade Solanum lycopersicum,[1][2] commonly known as a tomato plant >>>The tomato belongs to the nightshade family, Solanaceae.[1][3] The plants typically grow to 1�"3 meters (3�"10 ft) in height and have a weak stem that often sprawls over the ground and vines over other plants. It is a perennial in its native habitat NOTE: There is no distinction is made amongst the varieties. It is true that in the non tropics tomatoes are grown as annual but fundamentally they are PERENNIAL. This is the same about all varieties. At any rate, either all tomatoes are annual or perennial. No exception in the fundamental genus. The terms "determinant" and "indeterminant" come from statistical structure, loosely applied to tomatoes. The terms have much wider application in mathematics In tomato it just refers to the growth habit and FORM/STRUCTURE and its predictability. FINALLY: To claim that Determinant tomato plants just drop dead toward the end of season (supposedly implying that the indets live on) is just no accurate. And I am referring to the statement that I quoted. I do not know who wrote it. So this is not a personal issue with you or anybody else....See MoreCherokee: determinate or indeterminate? North American native?
Comments (24)Why is it so hard to see what I'm asking with regard to following some sort of protocol to arrive at a verifiable determination rather than "googling" peripheral or irrelevant cultural information and forcing extremely limited data to match some preconceived notion? Same or similar nonsense: 1) Astronomer finds planet in distant solar system. Planet appears to be approximately same size as Earth and approximately same distance from its sun which also appears to be the same size and age as our sun. The distant planet has a single moon approximately the same size as ours and in same or similar orbit as our moon. There appears to be a good deal of water on the distant planet and spectral analysis indicates an atmosphere same or similar to our atmosphere. The astronomer declares a high likelihood there are human beings inhabiting the distant planet ... hogwash!!! 2) Chef loves a particular wild mushroom and uses it frequently in a signature dish. He relies on a professional mushroom gatherer to provide him with the wild mushrooms, but one day the chef finds a clump of mushrooms in his back yard that look almost identical to the mushrooms he loves ... only they are somewhat smaller on average and have some almost inperceptible other differences. Chef assumes they are the same or similar mushrooms as his favorite kind and serves them up in his signature dish ... dead customers!!! Okay ... just trying here to think of some rediculous comparisons to finding two similar tomatoes in two remote locations 500 miles distant from one another and having very limited data to determine any relationship other than visual comparisons and two stories where third parties are relying on anecdotal "evidence" regarding the origin of the two tomatoes which boils down to "they've been grown 'round these parts for 80 - 100 years, and we heard they come from the Indians," or "a particular tribe was known to have had a presence" in both areas from which the two different but similar looking tomatoes came ... therefore they are the same thing just grown in isolation. Now a couple more things to consider ... Both Cherokee Purple and Indian Stripe were 80 to 100 years removed from their supposed Native American origins when they each came as seeds to the gardens of the persons who eventually set them into the SSE collection. During that 80 - 100 years that both Indian Stripe and Cherokee Purple grew independently and 500 miles distant of each other in the gardens of European-Americans, does anyone suppose that no changes occurred in each variety other than the ever so slight size difference and cluster counts? Is everyone assuming the two separate tomatoes we're talking about really remained stable and true to type for 80 - 100 years? Do we know that no cross pollination occurred? No mutations? No evolution of any sort? Come on folks ... in the 10 - 20 years these two types have been in common circulation, at least one of them (CP) has some changes in appearance and exhibitions of instability ... i.e. Cherokee Black, Cherokee Green, and Golden Cherokee. I'm not a scientist. Can someone here who is a scientist please explain the protocol that should be followed when trying to prove that two independent but closely similar cultivars are of the same genetic stock (if that's the right term) ... you know ... to where one can with something approaching certainty say that one of the cultivars "is an excellent example of (the same) variety that was grown in isolation for many years" other than simply because "(a particular ethnic group) were known to have a presence in (both regions from which the two separate cultivars came)." Okay, that's it for me. Y'all feel free to wander off into other "google-formed" fairytales, or take the discussion into irrelevant territory again....See Morerobeb
10 years ago2ajsmama
10 years agojrslick (North Central Kansas, Zone 5B)
10 years agoBets
10 years agodigdirt2
10 years ago2ajsmama
10 years agoseysonn
10 years agoseysonn
10 years ago2ajsmama
10 years agodigdirt2
10 years ago
Related Stories
KITCHEN DESIGNDetermine the Right Appliance Layout for Your Kitchen
Kitchen work triangle got you running around in circles? Boiling over about where to put the range? This guide is for you
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: A Country Home Built on Dreams and Determination
Meaningful antiques mix with new pieces in a family’s just-built house on a former strawberry farm in Oregon
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNHouzz Call: Tell Us About Your First Kitchen
Great or godforsaken? Ragtag or refined? We want to hear about your younger self’s cooking space
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESContractor's Tips: 10 Things Your Contractor Might Not Tell You
Climbing through your closets and fielding design issues galore, your contractor might stay mum. Here's what you're missing
Full StoryLIFETell Us: Do You Know How to Live With Your Parents?
If you've tried multigenerational living under one roof, we'd love to hear the details
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: Curiosities Tell a Story
An interiors stylist uses her house as a 3D timeline of her tales and travels
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESFrom the Pros: 8 Reasons Kitchen Renovations Go Over Budget
We asked kitchen designers to tell us the most common budget-busters they see
Full StoryMODERN HOMESHouzz Tour: Design Lessons From a Deluxe Spec House
This luxurious Austin home was built on spec, but you'd probably never know it if we didn't tell you. Discover 10 reasons why
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGN20 Kitchen Must-Haves From Houzz Readers
We asked you to tell us your top kitchen amenities. See what popular kitchen features made the list
Full StoryHEALTHY HOME6 Tips From a Nearly Zero-Waste Home
Lower your trash output and increase your quality of life with these ideas from a mom who did it to the max
Full StorySponsored
seysonn