Evergreen seedlings - size required to fend off deer?

10 years ago

We live on a wooded lot, and "dear neighbor" on our north side cut down a ton of trees last year, exposing her "car dealership" style lighting on her house and driveway. A major project for this coming year will be to plant evergreens to shield her out....eventually. We realize it won't happen overnight. Also, we want to make it look like a natural evergreen barrier, not a row of arborvitae toy soldiers. We will need to mix varieties and stagger the plantings in a random pattern.

Our challenges:
1. The area where we need to plant these trees is along an established deer path (too large to fence in, so fencing is not an option)
2. Water source will need to be super long hoses from the house to aid in getting trees established, about 100 feet.
3. I'd say it's a partial sun area, especially when the deciduous trees come out with their leaves.
3. We have a prized ornamental crabapple in the front, so I think cedars are out of the question due to cedar apple rust.
4. The larger, established evergreens are not only expensive (especially for the number that we'd need) but also, it would be extremely difficult to transport the large root balls up the hill, as well as hand dig the holes.

It looks like the Arbor Day Foundation sells several varieties that I would consider planting, and the prices can't be beat, given the quantity we will need to plant. However, the size of the seedlings are only 6"-12"....babies!

Question: Is it even worth trying to plant these, or am I simply planting bite-sized hors d'oeuvres for the deer? I am willing to risk losing about 25% of what we plant if the other seedlings are likely to make it.

Alternatively, Is there anything we could do to protect the mini seedlings from the deer, or, do we not need to worry if the variety is considered deer resistant (I know....nothing truly is!), for example, Norway Spruce.

We would appreciate any insight from anyone who has tried little baby seedlings. Thank you!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

shadeyplace
10 years ago
I have found that Norway Spruce is deer resistant in my yard. Also Hemlock (but then you may have the wooly adalgid). Cephalotaxus is also deer resistant. Pieris, Nandina mixed in to fill. and SPRAY. definitely a problem. Good luck
wisconsitom
10 years ago
Yes, N. spruce is "usually" not browsed on by deer, and is a very fine and imposing conifer. I think you should look for sources other than Arbor Day Foundation. For whatever reason, that just has not been a very good source for most folks. Meanwhile, and especially if small size is not unacceptible, there are numerous other options. One that I like very much is itascagreenhouse.com. Most of their stock is in "styroblocks", strofoam trays such that you are actually planting a plug, not a bare-root seedling.

Here's what I see as your issues: 1) Deer..........one way or another, you're going to have to deal with them. Even if you find some species to work with that don't seem to be browsed, eventually a buck is going to come along and just demolish a tree or three, and most likely, your favorite ones, rubbing the fuzz off of its antlers! Believe me, this will happen. Some kind of fencing or diligent use of the spray-on antifeedant products are going to be necessary. 2) Light requirements. Most conifers do their best in full sun or at least light shade. There are exceptions: Hemlock (Wooly adelgid problem out by you guys), balsam fir (Very shade-tolerant but rare in commerce-Itasca's got em), Thuja occidentalis-the species tree, not the various cultivars, although one cultivar-"Hetz Wintergreen" is quite species-like. But these too will do better with more sun. Yews are fairly shade-tolerant but well, they're yews! Other than such rarities as Taxus canadensis, I don't get too excited about yews! 3) Watering. I don't get too bent out of shape if I'm working with tiny transplants such as seedlings. We planted 6000 last spring up at our N. Wisconsin tree farm, never watered them, and with timely rainfall, nearly all survived. 4) Small size of transplants. That one is up to you. Working with seedlings has a number of advantages-easy to plant, less watering concern, low cost, wide availability, etc. You just have to be patient. Now here's what I've observed, once again at my tree farm: The oldest stuff we planted went into the ground up there-fairly decent soil though quite a bit of sand and very stony-4 growing seasons back. Now these are fast-growing species, but I've got hybrid larch (Wouldn't work in your shade_ that are in excess of 12 ft. tall. Norway spruce are right behind them. We had a lot of rain up there last year and I kid you not, some of my Norway spruce grew 4 feet! So don't rule out starting small. The growth rate may surprise you.
Another possibility that would be somewhat shade-tolerant is white pine. I've got a bunch of those too and they're doing well.

Finally, check with yoour county conservation service, they are typically a wealth of info and a source of a variety of small transplanting stock. Or just do a search on seedlings and get ready to be buried by hits! Hopefully I've given you something that helps. Get back if you have more questions. I've done a ton of this stuff!

+oM
Related Discussions
Need evergreen shrub/tree suggestions
Q
Comments (8)
My standard hedge shrubs for deer have been boxwoods and hollies. Have both the common box and dwarf English in full sun and the deer hate the smell (as do some people)--I really don't smell it in the ground and the dwarf English are very close to house foundation. There many types of hollies available that might be useful as long as you are okay with pruning. (Dwarf Burfordii, China Girl/Boy,)--I wouldn't use "Nellie Stevens" as they get big. One of my favorites is the native Inkberry "Ilex glabra" I believe--very nice conical shape. Have fun!
...See More
mixed evergreen screen recommendations please!
Q
Comments (27)
vvesper- There is a cv of River Birch that is very heat tolerant. Came out of Georgia I believe called Betula nigra 'Dura Heat'. It does have a little smaller leaf. The White Bark Birch that Dax mentioned is Betula papyrifera, the Paper Bark/White/Canoe Birch. They are beautiful trees, and the ones Indians used to make canoes out of, but I'm afraid you will have problems growing them. They are rated to Zone 7, but they DON'T like humidity. Grandpa had a huge one on his farm in western Ohio growing up, I have tried to grow them, but the years I planted them were rough, and they never made it. I think I still have a couple potted up out in the nursery, but I can't remember for sure. I want to grow one in my yard. I used the Hybrid Poplar behind the Spruce and inline with Thuja to get height and block the neighbors house. I planted them all as 6-12" tall sticks in the middle of a blazing HOT July of 07 with a terrible drought. I watered them through August and then forgot about them. The ones that have been left to mother nature are about 6-10 feet tall, and there are a few on the back of a planting bed that are nicely mulched and very occasionally watered (not intentionally, just catch the sprinkler when watering the bed) and are pushing 20 feet or better with a lush full canopy and a trunk caliper of 8-10". I'm contemplating cutting those two down already b/c I'm not sure I like them there and are starting to put off a lot of shade. That gives you an idea of how well they will fill in and grow to block the view, but they are still small enough to cut down easily. Not to mention that I paid about $2 a piece for them. Def. got my money's worth. Eliot
...See More
Native Evergreen Hawthorn Shrub?
Q
Comments (11)
I could buy bigger plants but I have an acre to do that has nothing on it, or nothing I want, plus retaining walls to build. I'm going broke! My demanding birds will just have to remain unimpressed. I am trying specifically to create a wildlife corridor. It's about 25'x 180', filtered sun with little direct sun. Still, the filtered sun is a decent amount. Wooded with mixed hardwoods, pine. The soil is good, acid side but that's good for what I want. The canopy is good, but I pulled miles of honeysuckle out of it so expect it to grow. The honeysuckle killed the middle layer and forest floor so it needs rebuilding. It's not dry but not moist enough for anise. It may dry out more since again, the vines totally blocked the sun. I intend to plant mahonia (NOT NOT NOT bealei!) in the deeper shade, a couple southern wax myrtles in the sunnier spots and several deciduous berry happy viburnums. What I lack is evergreen. Summer with all the viburnum will be fine but in winter I only have two spots of evergreens. There is no wildlife coverage on this property. I am not a native purist but I am a non invasive purist. I need that perfect, instant growing, shade loving, dense shrub that's non-invasive to boot. I don't ask much. If all else fails I will use Cleyera japonica (Ternstroemia) which as far as I can see has no invasive status. Grew it before (inherited) with no problems and something was always nesting in it. Maybe leatherleaf viburnum but I am not good with leatherleaf - ordered Dirrs book for help. If you have any alternative thoughts I'd be happy to hear them. I have planted two yaupons and a few other hollies, but in a sunnier spot. Love hollies. Common I know but dang, they are perfect. No suckers, grows anywhere, needs no pruning and is a wildlife bonanza. Let native hollies be common I say! Pick them over bradford pears any day for mass subdivision, office park plantings.
...See More
Low-Cost Tree Protectors for Deer
Q
Comments (13)
I need to be brief but I want to help you; We started out by purchasing plug stock from itascagreenhouse.com. That vendor was (and probably still is) the only source for the hybrid larch-Larix marschlinsii-that i dearly wanted for this project. Oh wait, I forgot one year prior where we purchased Norway spruce, a few ponderosa pines for fun, and a smattering of other things. But anyway, we dicked around with small quantities-250 seedlings, that sort of thing-then went big and rented the tree planter from the county and ordered 6000 seedlings. That was three years ago and now, the planting is mostly done. We will always be doing something there but the bulk of it is done. We have woods there two and the planting area and the existing woods will blend together. I also purchased seedlings from our own state DNR, from the Michigan DNR (our land is near the border) and other sources. There are numerous sources for seedlings. Since so many of your initial species are hardwoods, yes, deer will be a problem. Interestingly, on our land, white cedar (Thuja ocidentalis) is a major species and the deer don't touch it. This flies in the face of everything we know about deer and that species. I can drive less than a mile away from our land and see the usual browse line on all the cedar in this cedar-rich region. So something weird about that but in a good way. Initially, I would actually dig a hole and spread the roots out, the whole bit. That was only at the very beginning. When we went with that 6000, the machine did the digging. It's just like a cabbage planter-you just sit on the thing and kind of fling the seedling out so that the roots spread out and then the machine grabs it and plants i t. You'd get it if you ever saw it in action. Deer won't touch your Norway spruce. In some ways, foresters I've know speak of "capturing" the site for forest. In other words, when we plant all these seedlings, this is really just the opening act. In time, other species will work their way in and the whole stand will diversify. I'd work with the easiest stuff first-the conifers. Then, once your land is starting to take shape, try to plant "pods" of these other items, protecting them with nothing more than a polygon of t-posts strung with orange baler twine at about 1-foot intervals. That way, your stand will appear more natural-trees often occur in groves-and each pod can be protected by one of these inexpensive enclosures. We've done just this with some large plantings of tamarack (not a big item for deer usually) and white cedar ( a deer's version of chocolate ice cream) around some of our stormwater management practices in this city. It's worked out pretty well. One issue we did have this year was rabbits. These enclosures do nothing to stop bunnies and we seem to be in the midst of a rabbit population explosion. so some trees got messed up by bunnies, but for deer, this simple system actually is working.
...See More
JillyWillyCT
Original Author
10 years ago
thank you for your incredibly insightful info...just what I needed to know!

Evergreen seedlings - size required to fend off deer?

Comments (3)

shadeyplace

wisconsitom

Related Discussions

JillyWillyCT
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Evergreen seedlings - size required to fend off deer?

Comments (3)

shadeyplace

wisconsitom

Related Discussions

JillyWillyCTOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

JillyWillyCT
Original Author